US Attorneys' Bulletin Vol 45 No 03, Health Care Fraud II

117 Pages·1997·0.28 MB·English

USABulletin
r 3e7b 9 m 9e u,1 nN5 eu4mJ ul oV
Health Care Fraud Issues
eus ssIi hnTI
weivretnI htiw detinU setatS yenrottA dlanoD .K ,nretS tcirtsiD fosttesuhcassaM
United States v. Dr. Ivan Namihas, M.D. rsdoUef irreC v:eeHN
es aaCinrofil a fCdolei heSu leB h:tses adCua reFr ahCtla exHelpm o nCsignideeco rlPellaraP
sci p meotohrnrtTefmtaerT
noitc Ama Tiu QA
sdra wlAaun nhAt 5s4’laren eyGenrottA
noitnevno Csnopae WlacimehC
senilediu Gwa Ls’nageM
dehysbilbuP
Executive Office for United States Attorneys
Washington, D.C.
,leotrrsoaitCtctearBiiDD
United States Attorneys’ Bulletin Staff, [phone]
David Marshall Nissman, Editor-in-Chief
Wanda J. Morat, Editor
arabraB .J ,noskcaJrotidE
ecirtaP .A ,airolFrotidE
re nc ngi,aihy sspeeuealySDrtDGraB
Nina M. Ingram, Student Assistant
:ot snoitcerroc ytitnauq dna sserdda noitubirtsid dneS
,.W.N ,teertS E 006 ,1106 mooR ,gnidliuB lainnetneciB ,syenrottA setatS detinU rof eciffO evitucexE ,noskcaJ arabraB
20530-0001 D.C. Washington,
(202)6 16-8407o rf ax( 202)6 16-6653
Letter from the Editor-in-Chief
n a, mfwe roehwiiteavnh rCdeet rnh uigrt uua,ooeerfch ut,dd e e onsue sorIisweatthsrentialip
eht yenro tst’Alare nyerGos i,vedeAttimmoC noD .nretS .rM ,nretS eht detinU setatSyenrottA
morf eht tcirtsiD , sftotesuhc assashaM a ciman yedgassem rof lla tnatsi sdseAtinUsetatS
.sye nerH od t eeltsts aAi s ilnyen et airrigvro imeenietetivti tpvnrnsrcxleciuueeotolsolpoc
s meerlo bfy lo.eeearsbhmnpetoosciietrbacn
,s e m .wltsod de c r i rnfu ifesiaahheFooaesvoritptThc rheear lt enaFtirCataosorreweaHtsp
ti si tnerappa taht eht yteirav fo semehcs dna secifitra desu ot tpmetta ot duarfed ehtdetinU
.ss e setye sa llei telthttSraiTra a umeht stipt nd yrlxraeseieuttenveositrvinaoasUtthsStAA
dep ,oy osl l. tr egpkesoevnoclehsei tibmt edte suaiuk huWsqkranytbi rcalirahurumtrtoetnroc
ohw to nyl neov aehnod a ta e g rbne,goissjtee uhstfctau oecbesv oaerhnpo ge hatr texleimot
.secneir eep s xmedeohertnf r y ateeeahrlhtawhs
d eo,d tei es e uc hvehwwseocautosdtahnirieiw gtsneolcc i’tsrtan ayt ts fii rsolseuAashouAtq
dnif a t neern oaymma rwgen p i.fv nordgoennisai t ersanraimIphhr sto8f9n9i1 ew nalp otdda
the Bulletin to USABook. It is our goal at that time, to add the pleadings (indictments, jury
,snoitcurtsni tnacifingis )snoitom aiv sknilpmuj ot eht deziretupmoc noisrev fo eht .nitelluBnehW
uoy ees e nltacuiotbra aa es atcah t rsaili moits en otah t ugony ie,n rpnoaoi tlgueeovbyleldiw
e be lseb tv adtn eoelae y itvuhmsegrrotukknt eh cciesssroodra odllrfbi.uueobsyac
sno oi,ttss m ers egoi eW gc tp e u i ,aods.s ytushhnaesoiott eeuijryn eslshncermPstemuimooyc
me in St. Croix at [phone] or on Email at AVISC01(DNISSMAN).
stnetnoC
weivretnI htiw detinU setatS yenrottA dlanoD .K ,nretS tcirtsiD fosttesuhcassaM
United States v. Dr. Ivan Namihas, M.D. rsdoUef irreC v:eeHN
es aaCinrofil a fCdolei heSu leB h:tses adCua reFr ahCtla exHelpm o nCsignideeco rlPellaraP
sci p meotohrnrtTefmtaerT
ntinemeltteS deti nsUetatS .v e c,unroBsk c,i.rDE.M eht taerG sllaF eyE yreg rrueStneC dna
g gyerradGnA
A Qui Tam b aeLsaes ilDan eeRga tdS n n Enanooit cA
MACSB AnLoitare pftOolu s teanRemeltt epSroCb alLufsseccuS
detinU setatS .v selrahC .M ,torraP.D.M ydu te Ss :aAC
tnemeltt enSoill i 2Ms$t eeNs akCcabkc ieKracideM
sdeet ta.itvn SU. rd DnelarumFarPoN
smets yhStla eyHesr etJs e:Wsecnal atBide ryCap e oRetruliaF
de tsientUat Sc i .yravnti aan.piiamhg .ocrrbCyi a.sVsldPlgpanotiPirppsSoH
d esteitnaUt S.svredroB lacid eeM h,ttnemecrof nwE agLno mnAoitarepo o fCeolpma x nE:A
dua reFr ahCtla etHsnia gtAhg ieF h ntsieinapm oeCcnarus ndI n,aytinummoC
k na atrBaeDnoititc alraPnoi teahNT
sthgi llhag riyeHennerGottA
laren eyGenrot tyAtup egDnitcA
laren eyGenrot tyAtup eeDtaicos slAapicni rgPniogtuO
s d srdranowanAoH
sevitaitin Ismraeri Fnoitartsinimd AnotnilC
ma enToitazilarutaN
ytivit clAanimi r yCdbesu asCretsas inDoitai v fAsomitc irV olfocoto rgPnipolev eJDOD
noitazirohtu adenRufrepuS
noitnevno Csnopae WlacimehC
noitamrof nyIr udJna rgGnidraugefaS
senilediu Gwa Ls’nageM
sevitaitin IgurD-itn AytinummoC
noi6t0a0r2epO
smarg onroPitai dr eesMeePsro dGnAE
noitatnei rlOaux e nSdoes aeBcnelo igVnitabmoC
sye n e srec deovirettifotattffitAuOnScUexE/s e’csiyfef nO srdeoetttatitAnSU
stnemtnioppA
s d srdranowanAoH
stnevE/seus stInacifingiS
noitacu dlEag e fLeociffO
srpeitTupmoC
JODsthgilhgiH
stnemtnioppA
noisiv itDsurtitnA
noisivi DlanimirC
secivre Sgnicilo Pdetneir OytinummoC
noitagitsev nfuIoaer ulBaredeF
smargo rePcits u fJeociffO
ecivr enSoitazilarut adN nnaoitargimmI
ytilibisno plsaenRoiss e sfdconirahPtE
snoitress AgnidaelsiM—stnemugr AgnisolC
noitatneser peetRavirP—srey wtanLemnrevoG
seitinutr orpepeOraC
syenrot tsAeta tdSeti ntUnatsissA—nagihc iftMocirts inDretseW
yenrottA—lesnu olCag e fLeocif feOcits u fJtonemtrapeD
yenrot tdAecneirep x5E1- So4Gt1-SG—weiv enRoitargim mr Ioefcif feOvitucexE
dsnOa AsfSeoUeyol peomttEsitta BlioD rraoCtce rAiSD UmO oErreftte Lx—iAdneppA
edist ud Ontacudn ofsCodradna tlSacih tnnEooitalug elRatnemelpp u:Sj b Au,SSUOE
seitivitcA
tra hnCoitazinag rAOSUOE —xBidneppA
mr onFoitanim oeNsru oECLO —xCidneppA
sgniwoh Slamrofn Idn alamro Fro felbaliav AsepatoediV— DxidneppA
Interview with United States Attorney Donald K. Stern,
District of Massachusetts
.rM nretS sah neeb eh tde tsyieentnUarto StrtoAf et hcstitrt teers sceifunbDohimcseavsosNaM
,3991 dna si yltnerruc riahC fo eht yenrottA s’lareneG yrosivdA .eettimmoC eH sah a.A.B
ee e gtmr .erogdylarentlbfdaioosC H rnaew voe.it eDnemr.UgogJrreofdeG
.rM nretS stcerid na eciffo fo 09 ,syenrotta esohw seitiroirp era tneloiv ;emirc nug;gnikciffart
h,tenlroaaiecth p cuyirllrrboau cl p;ud ec e, mirdzeei tanimtr;rlaniicsalarhgpogcwucrrod
,duarf seitiruces ,duarf dna retupmoc .emirc nO eht livic ,edis eh sah dezisahpmeevitamriffa
tnemecrofne ni hcus saera sa htlaeh erac dna enif.noitcelloc
, g y dneeseirnetmo rtiofeoancehttUeBtSb Asaw arreonitn renaSiP enhott swoaB lmrif foelaH
d, l,enr d esr sardelra ieseonv eoh.khiiDarsfls ncSawhteaeanorikusiguteMudheovDCLCoG
dedu lgcnniiganam eh ts’ reomnirreC v-loiiGtcnnAuoC dna eh ts’ro nercenvaoiGltlsAniagA
.sgurD
eH o sdleavre ssa yt lennanaarrteo sntsi et’sysnGeAlseticaAntirrefeos fntueoethhGActassaM
ro s de stngntena. eoafa lwltotnoalsrsaoLoopihCBscsSa
yen rso etdtt eaAtttni SandtUe swyiebsi s vn)A drrS sleeDyaatt(ewnnSnoi rDso etdtteaAttiSnU
(AUSA) David Nissman (DN), Editor-in-Chief of the United States Attorneys’ Bulletin.
,t) aCeehAe rrwGt:uaAt No(iy Dymrsm oA oess Chi’ wtvldeda anAry eeefhnn oereGohtttA
slaog rof siht?raey
DS: enO fo eghntidi rsrleavoog fo eht CAGA dlu ohssyawla eb ot edi vtorropppus rof enildna
.) ssAySeU n As rd(etoetnttaati ttAnySsUriosssiAvrepus teys haeoT w btso idsh si toatteedgi
morf eht ton—dleif tsuj morf eht detinU setat SsyenrottA tub morf eht elpoep gnikrow noeht
.ses aecW tnaw ot eb teihutd nootc ly aeernh ert.dnotnet naGtee AmmeothSrt afpoeD ehttseb
denvil osoevthrnnwaiats i es mn seo ieAmrslv o f r atc wraeh seeeeheanfvy tvloos’dgenwiht
nhe ch,ityhewnr ostet tAdaet tSrgi innoeiUt hh,t t s reopyom huaogwossn risg kerreootwtimmoc
st edges sganpola ot eht .CAGA eW dluoh s esseuet tCiA mG omAetotc absiugtsnirinehihttar
naht ot ts udjnopser .to snthlegamustoorhpa topylrenApDam yrev s ndooiotg seemgogcus tuofo
ste a v,he ietw n ktc daer aiIlc ko rnni t utiweoiotesCoslrfaihuA weoMntJGogmiAtgus
.rehtegot
:ND d nIat straehdtnu uoy d eetrsaer entin igniva heht CAGA ekat a eevrio tm.cealoordrpluoC
? s ew nrmefiuoioaos vlyupoxye
:S D.s es ed W ednn ltsni otl Aialopsa erdtsu,ehcaememter mad eisdwte e on ptkectdasnba
ekat a kool ta seus sei kdnieal zi,is ens,maug igRnyrriecorn eoy dmcrntou.padulurakrnfab
5
y ldsrlr ioaas f c hu hoie nc tmc fskoeu r enyoer edvmeuestibsogvihowissawnartycihdsknihT
n.i e ecehintfO ffo o seeggrhnn’tii eohowgtt o ds irhate ysi ot ts ien siwdhcontndaiewga
y. l stt heen etim eeWit,chw iI etdrBsrnoFs aiutrc ipss iaedw n sotfge aon vehit’httsIteeebm
de dhnt e i. tlwyy stacnepar namieee ohdvgnSse aaenFfh kooeaistt eaaehlltepru of cosraeyot
s. y p oueeeo d ho vnvlenww Yrnar aeeuos oeho phvronearfetduehrt obteodtaafAtrtoigSnU
t noesenhvnme waoten hirbi etaphipitseh oDsep rl .re p nseduoreireaoeuvareYpoaealfhyc
dn udon rao ahwwo n. ks e dud cten eln ntAu leetaioebv ia tnyviefresUa dloehihneptsarxsceAni
setatS yenrottA .level ,deedn Iev’ew tog emos fo eht yrev tseb lair tsreywal ni aciremAni
detinU setatS ’syenrottA seciffo dnuora eht.yrtnuoc e cdnnteai is r steedsapWe ehxeontentrah
nwod htiw eht ,IBF ,FTA dna AED ot kylla.dts ietdiuntoaibcraoirp
:,N e D usftorOnyu aoowct o sd h i e t.hnrtiyt aoawceh mhnntoWeo dgua oeyneo sist auelhotve
fo ?ssishetcorp
d e strsioenf n U eitetsshauotrb m etsnaeehigtc nhgetngi i awgk t nr:er oioSrakt owD’tnIgesiwht
’ ss.eys teerancetrihSofttfe tohsAW’ thigu osrehitdo bekil eht eti hrWall oeCm ilriCcnuoCro
, sy t d e rl a rw .st eolde ley tnalrfin reehrdaeaefw otlhvttnhpcheoyIateoatpowtelpalbxhe
elpoe p treeghte gdont a.y lktlnaetu qIerf k slaa isctenpeSgA ni egrah Clla eht emit tahwyeht
tna wot .od s I e, diey n tredit iahn futrrtit, oaiofue y heiondlkwhrinlrtpma ao erwt wei.nteugoI
knih ttaht o sslnaeppa hta eh tylra ab.toleleggvdeu lbtuB trap amorf eh tt e,gsdeuubss iewnac
llits od retteb ni gnivirra ta .tsneiiotjir orio rF,pelpmaxe ti t’nseo dekam esnes rof eht uaeruBot
emoc pu eh v t,ieiet tw taea daimiynrtorraoispebno vairrlpoepfa su ton ot e bderae gpu ot od.ti
?n os zmoue iedoenerlysoho btheo mr twip:aerNhncDW
sredo vofaloel sferr u ado ,peoseetrrnoptu c e ee ,m srsr eiasieoenwreahrtacrwpua p:mSoDC
.ss efeno Widseueb no te ksea trmd nu ee essnrgg ei anasnhamieicrogufrtrnsoafaseris
,sretupmoc ot retupmoc ,emirc ot dlihc yhpargonrop no eht .tenretnI tA eht tsal CAGA,gniteem
r e h ehtIh,ttthtsBtsiuotiuFotwbnw jn hegtgniaiwn ita n r edidrtereoeohoejsftmnsu ceswid
.seicnega
:ND enO fo ge nhs itttrrsiao ppmfsoni ruo bsotjn a stsasi itsashAt ew na cpl ephotesguh
r,e shyl mteaeeehi mlhtteibwnrroeacrt ponpi eh,ht ytle r agrdteenaushhicautkrdnfnaib
,n y o ,r.ei r yst mrt woseeisee osynoahhustnnfefoheT tdosaieuiir rnhycbqtsaeuitsnnwoeedpi
?sme l ebegomrroapcleb
:SD ehT noisnep du aervfitaitini si a doog elpmaxe fo woh eno tnatsi sdseAtinU setatySenrottA
nac ekam e canere fnfoid ala n.olietva en yl,rnaaGmzt atnKnaatsi snsiA y m,ecif fsoagwnikrow
no eal p.n usofoeioc ss eane Hcesl wpuaye are necenekhenrh beotdGt atnhAee blnioatoetd
l .ga sJnr y eaOiek h eIn w Drnnycnn—Oae eeiaei rehet vGhdesocshayitpatitmlswtfeAfdo
gnnoi k t rseay oahhrdwwwae Gke.she aSmn s iwfr e toouflded,doop ahndhuahsaroacvraH
dna eh dlo t.reh eh Sdeks amih ot evig reh a omem no .t i dyerraaGp le daraenpsooiptoarNp
evitait i,,ndyinlaetamitl uI detneserp ti ot eht CAGA dna eht etihW ralloC emi r.ClicnuoC,woN
6
ton ylno era eht detinU setatS ’syenrottA seciffo gnippets pu rieht sucof no siht melborp ,tubtsuj
,y le stvsaniea titeacrhgnotie ptgemsar ieagvnniiraeg.pu
?s s ee C t tsreo,AuaonldhdsGohtaedteAywwa ues mseiivrictnat ssbeuds i:sNeDB
DS: One of the things we'd like to do this year, in addition to working on substantive crime
areas which change from time to time, is to see if we can improve what might be called the
. eercuittcsuurjtsarfni r esh’tt eioh tWe ke sa r,Ame umSvrs eUaeetA ohthsttutyspsemboc
t r r, ooe k eptht gordptr e n oo iuo oo lo inBovseptephekoAtodphowrrSriuteaoUpvspworp
stroffe taht pleh ot ekam ruo secif fnooit cenwu—fretteb deen ot evorpmi . eerhuttcurtsarefWni
era osl agni on go n ieel otge adtaaw’ne.r rtsotsesueyiiepeobegncotcneUioanrrfcteofStotA
: N ssDgwet noun n iHsad oor stnoitbt isedta feimnhuohsm eto tsoety,AchtCe taArdGnAawoh
lliw eht ,CAGA ni ,nrut gnirb eht tseb fo esoh tseussi ot eh ty es?n’nrlooaitrttenAneetGta
:SD en Oelpmi syaw si ot klaw otni eh teciffo fo eh tde t siyenetUnart oShtttiAw na .aedifO
,esruoc uoy evah ot eb deraperp ot od eht .puwollof fI enoemos emac ni ym ,eciffo I thgimllet
meht ot eka me m,ossll a,ecg enssi’ ntdeanphapwah ot tup ti ni a tr o.hosme me hdTesteitnaUtS
sy eenvraohtt Aa en oehep rttaht ew eesru ohf ce. abgCe nAtiGrtAaePe mfo ghnciateeseim
sdy e eat d ni oose srvee.e vtas deohneteeeiyetttoe amyddabtathreroriritAptWesenSnvUeg
d oyhsol gagl. ue assodecsiriniehhopcttyo Trfpo eh tsCrA eGlbAlm ie ,wmdyseaetstiantUS
yen roos tdtnAa o sema cp uhti wn,a a e edeld ntlirdat'oniefem w smteoitca biourts peohrtppa
n e dksnaietm m. o nt c eoadewihnrtwAadnem m kh oo ct esc t a aikmu edmnbwroorneooctahwt
yl st uoyy onlrli nea r yovrye t eebssu .nntbee renhryo Getebte nhtWeeoAhvptamhoca
significant voice in the Department.
:ND woH nac sASUA pleh uo yn oriethatmarg o rftonnieme lCpAmGiA?slaog
n t,e :tsg htr ian s:waeeeiyiS vn l sa D soO,ks we dpi kceo lfne tsarteiiat aoabgshssnoawircp
yhW did siht emirc neppah dna si ere hgtnihtemo stah tydobemo sdluoc evah e,nyoldtnereffid
de?e g tylvnd en ,al u aeartbiskhesoohpmOiyhrsstkawt p ateeaiwyaeemeillmhfdmsiaoalmse
rtol uecr io yfmsb f etitind acedhnm iweewdgcaar l ortfo’nned iodd dna gsn iiethratehehtmtos
?n da r ecn, egvirehno hObti ryt ihsp mie etimewr neicetwmihn ooftersfmof otoerhatpeD
?kr otw’nd irddoekr orweht iheci hewcitsuJ
re esr ea escnmaioc—ssrotuc ed seyopbropl eevseidt rr eifpooxver e etsev aeWaaerhrg
e no ,oh ysyfe w raellm ngemsneoein h aossbis ttec r orsoik ruedoritoovtalufyoiuebhfcywesorp
llits sah a taer glaed ot . regesnfiiftroraeh pSsxie . eagn eeelsmlioatShrce psxie derahsyb
es i ;t,drssrseeieee rhep mgat t x yinhoytsehdbtisliAtekpmSirlmmUwua ioAtt,sccluarmtrsof
. , rhyee cnhhsaoTtaeroi I,e e ssti a. hs eltr eewaonsvuF aaid nccti eocvyrbairuodeornvpi
, eyl lp ne l mnav Aaea oilSc bxyitlUioertaiApheaewyw vg rt sigcm itnrgsieueo trvda-dnginol
tuob a.ti ,te Ynehw eht esac si ,revo I t’ nkondiht ew yllu fpat o.ten sitiat hreteWptx’enod
7
noita g gnisnn otArieisSa rhteUegutavAlnd mnierisho stf.e ndne i erztenayavrHlh’aaweenwla
dna noitucesorp fo a esac nac eb yrev laicifeneb ot eht.tnemtrapeD
:ND tahW lanif egassem od uoy evah rof tnatsi sdseAtinU set?astySenrottA
DS: I think the single most efficient component in the Federal Government is the Assistant
detinU set.astySenrottA g,n sd iokgrn,ltrnuaeloooviwlhiwss e,rdgegca ne ify rIeeehrptaxe
ehrta lc,ade uhnaorifsnep— areeehrvtae t n.e,ayet hsh khisttWest min hh ielttklgliraewoww
,duarf ro dezin aegrreoht—emirc si on erom ,evitcu dtonrepiciffe tinu ni.tnemnrevoG
8
United States v. Dr. Ivan Namihas, M.D. ro fdeir Creve Ne H:
sU
tnatsissA detinU setatS yenrottA nahtanoJ .SoripahS
Central District of California
ehT mret esuba“ fo a noitisop fo ”tsurt smees ot evah neeb denioc rof .rD navI .C,sahimaN
.D.M ,tnagorrA ,leurc dna ,ydeerg eh deirrac tuo a ylralucitrap leurc mrof fo duarf tsniagasih
.smitciv
daetluas syallaux etssigolocen y,gainrofil a,Cytnu oeCgna r nO,asra e 0yy3letamixorp praoF
n I.seciff olacide man Aatna Ssi ht asnoitanimax elacisyh penituo rgniru dstneita psi hf orebmun
f0o 6,1yllautne v.Estnialpm ohct idwra olbacid eemta tes hdtetcatn oscmitc isv i fhloarev e,s9691
nriotc oedlgn itassnia gdaegd orle vreebm utnsegr aelht—stnialpm olcaicif fdoel imfeht
. rtDa hdti aw .seAdfeldn oefr eswreh t;odep aerr enwem oe whfetom o.Syrots iahinrofilaC
remr o.Afni arpie hltl u odatisehtsea ntaneiciff umse hgtniv itguoht iywregr udsemrofr espahimaN
slaicif feota ttsa h3t9 9l1it ntu osn a twti e.Ynem ogwnitr uyhoj n oedteme essahim adNi aessrun
f ono tadn asegrah cf oniatnuo magnica F.esneci llacide msi hf osahima Npirt so tthguo syllanif
dn a;seli flacide msi hdeyortse d;enicide mmor fderite ryliratnulo vsahima N.r D,sser pevitagen
. ad de ,avo svotsaemagNLeV
e hrt otf u,besru ofcl oegtavi r fapeol ohht 5e1 h ntnooisn asm i nhginiv i,lere h etlbli ttshg iemH
ne erbev ed nashahim a. NrtDa hdtegart u.Osmitc is v ifehom ofesocnetsisr ed pneagaruoc
. rtDa hswtnuoc craepapsw e nnginibircs e,dcilb utpn enwem o fwloufdn a,ahyllanimi rdcegrahc
wo hssw ennoisivel eet h nt.Ome h otdt isdahimaN emiTe-veimLirP nem oewse h ftroebm u,an
.hsiug nhac u omgsnisu ahct iywa wta e ogdtewol lsa anw asmi hyt hdwerednow
I was eht emiTe-veimLirP e hnytienrot tsAeta tdSeti ntUnatsis s nsA.aAder itnaie htwnemg es
k sonatoissimr edpevie c ,eIerm ie thtetacif fso’yenrot tsAeta tdSeti ne Uhfhtocna ra BnaAtnaS
dettim mdsoaachh i rmtreaoohNnt eo htk ewnoociotilv rneoSitcep slnaIt ssoePt adteSt ienhUt
,hci htwnempole v ,eakds ae thdtengis ss aanwost anWas urSotceps nlIats o.Psemi rlcared eyFna
h tyi aw twyeatgl i eu thg tetsol ennoods traoWtcep s;neI tsa’fsahi mdaeNl a,etscepsor tneir
.gnihtyna
yl b . earsemdetr ong neo Saakewtrtel i e sadt omsrte aetrret.proedcse fhnauwetutWOnoc
lacigolocen ysgsucs i odmte hrt o,fdlu o e cswyalevitisn e ss,agnik sear e ew:wtnatculer
er eow hswtneit agpnivlov nsies aec hytl neousr u opdtedic e ed.Wstnemtae rdt nsanoitanimaxe
o hswtneit agpnivlov nsies a ocntoitagitsev nri udoetim i el,wret a;lsnoitcelloc errie h ftnoiatrec
t od n ie,dwsahim a. N rfwDoe netkwa hmworf—lai retrut uy f ntgaaniyfits eodttettimm oecrew
ke edslu oswahim adNera eof hlwennosr eepcif fdoer ihft iewko p es.Wylek iale lrapedisnoc
rett a om,nm idhek illli tos hswesr uhnt iewko p esdw n,a s ouetko pyse h ftmie httsnia geagnever
d itds ot mu, bshut iewko psseugaell orcemr osf’sahim a. NrfeDom o.Sdi assrepapsw ee nhttahw
froebm udaneifitne d ei,wsweivret n fisohtn ormet f.Aecnel i fseod oracon o ohgtnirrefe r,pton
9
d nsalatips o fhroebm u sanlal e sw,asahim a.N rmDo rsfmia ldceviec eor hswreirr aeccnarusni
froeb m tuaa nhtwropp uoestcnedi vyeratnemuc oddeniat be,owylwo l.Sdecitca reephre hswbal
.seirot stinhei t,aeper g t e,aod getanrigtaer cdneeirdeec cyulslautn e.edvs Wleusottneitap
fhoc udmootsred nfules yr monnost arWotceps nrIehti et nu,be s eaav cathhg ietmwhguo hetW
. sduedu lseet oenvitare pd onsatrop eyrgoloht afgponina ee mh. Tseurof elbairet almacid eemht
nkooobtx era todfek s,Iayrarb irLetn elCacid e)MIC Ue(niv rsI’ainrofil a fCyotisrevi neU httA
em aes h ytnbetti rlw l,aselcit rda nsako o fbfole h oasdtetcer isd adw nsaecnei ccsigolocenyg
0r1e vfroooht u,aygoloc ncoigolocen yntgorep xdeenwoner-dl r ,oaawias ipDili h. Pr:Dnam
yr ehvt i.Wretn elCacid eI MCe Uhfdtoa ed hn,atcejb ue shnstoelcit rwaeiv erre e0 p0d 2nsakoob
,em ittsr ief hrt o,fd ntanecr e 0 py9eb enfoitatlusn olcamr osn ith uacias i.D r,Dgnitpmo replttil
s’sah it domueetaobn Nro usatliaa s,inDos traoWtcep se nk.IisLsen tt ir dw eo eeptnebxarega
.eramt htgsirnow
etwa hdwenialp xaeias i.D r,Dnoitagitsev n fifol adah nraa eyaylra e fntocudo rep hgtniweiveR
s ighnisu byallaux eonstoitid dn,aita httb u toaudoht istwuf eols le.aHdnatsred nt uodnid
dua rlfi a,msuoni eyhlbained ntu uebtercs i,delacs-lla mtas udoeirr ascahim a.N r,Dstneitap
.emehcs
mitci vaneh W.yregru sgnimrofre pro fresa levisnepx en adesae lsahima N,889 1n igninnigeB
ret f.Asreh tfeoocnese re phfetodist ur oeehnima xdelu oe,whtnemtniop pnr a aonefim atcneitap
.recn alcacivr edc aeh htsa httneit aep hdtl oytllufgno rswahim a.N r,Dnoitanima xleaus ifvei rab
deme eds nsatneit aep hdtera csse ielse h.TSD IdA aeh hdsl oytllufgno rows lsa anwam oewnO
e hf,tid nyaregr urses aeltaidem mdiede eyne hsttneit adpl ostahim a. Nr. D o oosddtetaluclac
eh tenohpele tyllanosre pdluo wsahimaN—tneiciffusn iyllaitin isa werac seh tfi—detatise htneitap
.yregr ue shttuoht ie widdlu oywe htta hmte hdtnim eoertm orshosenis ufeboca lrpie htttaneitap
,yregr u osttnesn oycletaidem mdilu oswtneit atpa hgtnirus n netonet ndieme essahim a.NrD
..rtDnemta esfrmot r,orfepa enhec t,froe hgtnoik esrenosaicis yrhep hgtnoitlus ntosc rtiufohtiw
r o nfsidneirfy o rbsodnabs urhie hdtn e osstmitc isv i fheom otscurts n ointag esbahimaN
lufni a 2 po1dtettimb uns aem n.Ome h otdtaer pds arhecn aec h fteinimret e odstnoitanimaxe
.m ihht igwno rs wagwniht otna hdtl os tad wnnaoini pdono c teahsgu orsehto n;aseiregr ursesal
lareve sdn a,seeyolpm eremro fsi hf oyna m,seviw-x esi hf oow T?t io dsahima N.r Ddi dyhW
e hdtell isbahim a.N r.Dev ayh a em.H tmio refrusae lcpitsid adsevir e edtha hntiatr eecr eswmitciv
nost arWotceps ns,Iad n.Atnemtae rytrassecen ne uhr tosfeinapm oeccnarus nriie hd tnsatneitap
seta tdSeti ne Uhnstikce hdceviec ed rnsall iebso httn essahim a,Ntru onecivo rorpteg aseaw
.liam
etha hmtia lscahim a. NrdDlu o.Cesne f eeatdapicit nodatei re,twtnemtcid nnkiae eogstniraperP
oetsnef ed d r edaablhu otwa h?Trecn ahct iswtneit adpesongaids io mhrwotc od ydaalber esmaw
dedeeco r ep.Wnoituceso rdpua rlfi ata mu,bl lraet feas aeccitcarpl almacid eta mosn aswi h;ttaeb
e h,tdnoc e.Sekats igamnik a omttim draev ednlu oswahim atNnedifn otcl e ef,wtsr i.Fyawyna
,tcepsort en,rignigdelwonk chaguo h.Tsfeil enbekats it mo,ntnet ntineludua rdfetsegg uescnedive
10