Urban Policy in a Changing Federal System: Proceedings of a Symposium

289 Pages·1985·1.802 MB·English

by  coll.

i
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. CUhrabnagni nPgo lFiceyd einr aal
pnv
e original pacific formattiauthoritative System
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the PrCohceaerldeisn Rgs. Wof aar rSeynm, Epdoistoiurm
been recompd breaks, heaease use the
s orPl
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted. Commission Coonm BmNehiatattvieoeion oraanl l R Naenasdtei oaSnrocachli aUCl orSbucaninec niPlcoelsic aynd Education
the original; liccident
n of e orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a National Academy Press
ogiai Washington, D.C. 1985
Aboriret
ii
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. NNNotfhofAaOer St TaiTccIopOoIinepNCmanrAElmocL :Rpe iAsTrteti,seh aCteetAehea Der prb eEcNrsMaohplajY aCoet nicPnooctsRnu eitEanb.hSlcla SeAit l 2f,ic s1owa 0rtd hh1teheo mC esse your e nbmopsjfeeto iEcmrtuttn btowgiefoier nnstrhe e aAei srcrve ihrn eeodgnpsr,uaeo aewnrn,t nfdNwo ftrWarh soteh ma WeIpn itrpash rstseiohpt vuiceneotcegdiu at onoblf cnyc iM, ol tsDmh eoeCdpf iG e ct2thioe0nevn4e ecN1. re8Tansthi ianeong nmd aB lewo mAiatrbchdae rdroesefg m oatfhryde
pnv This report has been reviewed by a group other than the authors according to procedures
al pamattiative aenpcperos,v tehde bNya ati oRneaplo Artc Radeevmieyw oCf oEmnmgiinteteeer icnogn, sainstdi nthge o Ifn msteitmutbee orsf oMf ethdeic Ninaet.ional Academy of Sci-
e origincific forauthorit tion ga sksTnoohcweia lNteeda ttghieoe n abanrldo R aoedfs caeodamrvcimhsi nCugno iutthyne co iffle wsdceairesa nle csgetoa avbnelidrsn htmeecdeh nbntyo. lTtohhgeey N Cwaoitutihon nctahille oA Apcecaradadeteemms yiyn o's fa pcSuccroipreodnsacenescs e oi nfw f1iut9hr1th6er-
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the g1tSmAMATnLIPin8uecrohiccetbieni6mneiaannedsre3r.ddtntab inre,,pTeecrca eadytwrmmielhrhtno isiephoeHyiejon e eo iaf Cn pcwAs cotnlCa hhuitofadec l e bo5uw nSr ieS tlene6ndUschiats g5ctc iaese ante,ir8d ns h bleifnNa.t edteulshacenti aasnbeasedId rtnhdrslsCi d imS o.tseesb hatnBddthiieteanta eaoctbt uledlsheoo ytocdsA eemki gi n teo bcAo heN Cnfay1fe c t tdu aA9 iMhatUefmrh6demidm.ec4e ebS p d eN myAeaa.rri rnniuciDyocn cdidm0 afncaea -dei1Eepbs3pen.9 aen0 aamgTr7rg9 lt ip 0yhmi8-nonr0,e 5ep iueer3 v-eeNenne65arrsrtdi19aat ipneeontt61egii,rfg7 -onc n0t H0cngtihoiona veonam le utg pahAlsmeruyeionct,n u hfcacuginoodytn ,irane tdoisinmdteeefydu rslyb fc.oUt -otohIfg ttr ofeh oib i ftE vcsas t thh ennahcraeg deonDr imiNntinreeng eiavrsgnre teeoe iirmrlossifvont sneteipighacmorm leeena b sdAenaN e ntldjcro aot cas t tiuhhitdhnohnaieetpnerldm y It aegecn lyrbroos ytcrvooipo eftfbuonrontrteart-h a-ocft
been recompd breaks, heaease use the
s orPl
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted.
the original; liccident
n of e orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
iii
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. PAUULn ivYerLsVityISACKoEmRm i(tCtheaei ro)n, NGraatdiuoantea l SUchroboal n oPf olEicdyucation, Harvard
pnv
al pamattiative BRIAUNni vJe.r sLit.y BERRY, School of Urban and Public Affairs, Carnegie-Mellon
e origincific forauthorit HKAENRNVEETYH B RB.O COLKASR, KA,i kCelna rCko, mPhpiuptpast,i oCnl aLrakb a, nHda Hrvaarrrdis U Innciv.,e Nrseitwy York
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the RRJGCSJGOAHOHOAEMHEOIYABWTLLNEECRRa La RSlELGlMsEG aTh EMEhHYi.A San C.AE Ds gRWHRs..tN e eFoWP.O Ee SnIWGEE,OWSO TRDTLANOEEO.EDRC,DL RBVS R.,LtSB EuHSE,OE d,CFNe yN,nSiH , rS Dr,tsS yaWttTaiyt reNLmfheAf eu capoA RcttUofoise oTssr rFinPib Zus(laraoutm,olan rn f Bin tOedIGitanslar nsas,Sg otrkiaeDfr tip,noue etWiftlpeze dBema,,e rr oWsbtmlseSetaroyecs nn1hahnt9wi n 8oUag3rftn t)ozCinv o,e AmDrss.miCtsyou.cniiatyte sA, ffIanircs.,,
been recompd breaks, heaease use the
s orPl
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted.
the original; liccident
n of e orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
iv
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution.
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the
been recompd breaks, heaease use the
s orPl
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted.
the original; liccident
n of e orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
PREFACE v
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. Preface
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit The Symposium on Urban Policy in a Changing Federal System was
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the cfcftmfcaprreroocooieoeaabnnnlsmltiduvcthiccrneeteh yFiedmgpbne—i aisturedtsiun.sodct c mtaetd ,uhHtl abhalsetaynansyoeip pidr d row mp ttroaenhhefitoldielseeeumxyru d dsd o,caCieia mfvtrrin oitoknaetvhdpmfwal ea rtbm otomauhb lnv reaeiohicbnde c toosotaHmks ekdnpnigepogie ceilro sruhnel ooatfsstrttsu g s nniuta nn omh srtndgfNh:necd a. a eto Aa tpAhtddiuTt acemi icltohrav dhittwleneen i elcr oaryti isoisbclf cbp ih oeatiUar1y e sm'eons9o.nrp wftmb7lns uliat0e,irdrih aentt—ba eetls ane a tPndNebednwo d ie daatlce i hitltomeciohoefonnygr fenrdoe turiaepiaimgcentlnashie yor Rodett nehidv aewsx;e fes aoca beransihy raynt umno ri dbinciapdna nhjgteiet lits hlwo ecCyptrernthh ae oe aisiaaswulnctstlt hnh is iiutosasc 1yrhtonti9a—bh l ma 8naeottio1dnyeaesf
been recompd breaks, heaease use the icoUnof.q mSHu.m iorDyuite stpeiinanegr thto ma asnec ndrcit ot iUmocfare blC aforanomn mdDm ebeevormectlheeo; rp pgtmuhinbeegl niF cto,i sarwsdnu dhFe ispoc.ruh i nvAadaplatseptoi ro soofnpuu;r nriacadnetedesdl :y t htt,hh eee f G iUnseay.rSnmmc. piaDnonges M piuafmaortrrm;s hettahhnleelt
n of the original work has e original; line lengths, woren accidentally inserted. Pl Fwhwagennoiuaasdavnys b le dseltrT tehanoohdhdemffe e e ttll erhhoamesneteohfet o fkaiU cepvilHocn n.i ntmagsiIstgrt t emrva udwstoei cp yfctaStt i isuerttP atiierhtheete eoesritsnosl soa.w eontfa hhffdd. eco d fhTt reohiaehnscenstisu assgis b nseci tlasiseoitt sdshitho oh ewmtnnerhe o eaanranttpkt hntltp yedhoor enofi sis pctttoshsrhouci eemaei u atsccemrl oh,b t pmhiaatlneantamectg c eoiiaae ntnrbr tgeoeetro eameAg ,sa hei.mka conn ,Teneo drrohu piiricatcht at sHoy an fsfnfa iioedtrrchcvcs ateocuel ,rnysc oi ho tlaiahamdcnniaearyddsrl,
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b tpoe rscpiteicetsi vaens dt hatht eh anvaet isoon c oanliskiset eanntldy stloip pderadw p astot geeatchhe ro ththeer. micro and macro
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
PREFACE vi
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. 1dcoi9rn8et3crt THiorbhearup,evt oiionerfntsgo,ss reRc onoefcmct hecap iopnlomtekufti mrentidhngit eg ttU eh cearo atbm mnaredenmpm Poibtcrotetrel,er iestca'h sytai e.vn d Ccedeol rlytiemhb deemi erts aixogtttpuioeoareencns esds t stioi nalt lnghR d eho yayof dcicn noeh dn iHigstnhhuage lnsot es nodam np.it,pos et sahat gersens n asidntlaui e ditntyost
pnv address the question of governance and decision making: How, in the
al pamattiative framework of the federal system, could this nation and its cities most effectively
e origincific forauthorit rceosnpdointido nt?o Tthhee cRheaanggaens aind mthien iestcroantioomn,y i nth iatst faorerm suol afu fnodr aam Nenetwal lFye daeltrearliinsgm ,t hheaisr
s been recomposed from XML files created from thord breaks, heading styles, and other typesetting-spePlease use the print version of this publication as the codcciamDwsakrrneetaaonsifnaeasspiutsspndotetcevseertiaef wn uuaeaem edc,hSwr sat slrlieaeecoebsleteiavhnldlhyxipndlnydmoeoed ,,tmtgc ynadonl totpaeeult h e on og irrtdcpneiv espaaicrnecio oet ecnehafn, noofnmsft eldoaoiWtneo —p dt geutertrsuilui orcoseo eionrbwersd envn osedythfestrehteih du aprgerorroeeoast lrpnsohfh r y pnn rmantpereetHf sse erchsrdr sf.sseeimooe oceo iuven Tfnaorm lrancaeftne,nmtmhl sehttd , eltdie eret hyianwmeh cynMxtta:smgnooei pieto sf ctpipad eicetnhpaniensiieerttdcca nusssiod eceeslp a bwgb ersuf rncir.a l inoaoda niowhntcnWctulrsuegaeu r dy i ndral d tass tadioahdl eh ttnttni lnaho ha tzreedbte ctdaot eaeh ,s eexpa n, utf,new edpio Dfgtam ooane erJrche nnnpeectuvmhco irpds prtcnioaaroiesrtia rheveynnocofijolr o ue osgs ntsfgam 2 netdsciiemurencnttx2—gaeu arneudgpel–sibkctne nr enee2aatsrferetgic rts e3inavvn tisat onlo ,eoeavtmcnl pafhtn y lrai ldr1orussreucy,lHoe 9ol t, a es i evutlaa8notct hiaopeen snn4myuaneic r sdvdn,n.s dmisae e froie edl s nontp avlp ts oavtglthgsrimrh pe .toes ei os aeesvDaidgemyovvbh rann rtmsfeuela.wtaid tpy rern r,fmp nit e e ee LnhUibosmc nudmtgoeies tttrreviewcih u ibbavruetetntegtaahahaoetmlitihlhnyneecsssrr,
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted. crfaaadeicnmstte,ui dnr cyibsa ytmrp afaeteti tdoeenwrrn'sah leo npmf o otltaidhckeyei n cogihfs a sonunsgeh e ensdeo. dwfT i nhergeeq smupmiootyasnn ts yidwb riaalomsift i aerttsaih,ci es am enddod om matehsnee st satpi coro fc brrtihleteseimqp muo enoe sefi tobienfiql giut,ti iheitnyes
the original; liccident shoulTdhereerde bwye rthe ea flesdoe craola gleosvceinrngm menotm inen ptsre acte dthineg cdoencfaedreesn.ce that derived from
on of he orieen a tvhiee wberdea dint ht haantd ladrigspera spsieornsp oefc twivhei,c thh eth Ais mgeroriucpa nw faesd eerxaqlu sisyistteelmy ciasp ainbglee.n iWouhselny
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b cdoignetrsitviveed :m aenc huanndisumla tthinagt apbrsoocrebsss p oarft imsaonv iidnego lporgaigems aantidc arelldyu cweist hth ethme totimes, a
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
PREFACE vii
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. aailnensavsddio melCvrfisaelhhaimarbinpnelee.gn setpss Or iatn ctamh tniicdustha seltin,d t aioieontmist o.hae nAe s brtn,ia cpdl oa ffnsootsrcrreacitnsvuesgadnei asla t.ecb lttyy oO t ,h nosae tntxr eoaew nirtnithel eal dtst s teiirssdor tmeen s,eg aov lueclerarhcyanaeb dlsoll ee,u n.ungtncheieefd i oefdbb eiynf nugadegtndliooulibnintaaygll
pnv complexity of modern issues, and the stubborn sophistication of an informed
al pamattiative citizenry, to share and disperse responsibility.
e origincific forauthorit betterN oetq uainp peeads yt op ruenddicearsmtaenndt. aBnudt cI ocpaem we itahw aity. Afronmd ftohri s thcaotn fIe raemnc ed eae plolyt
been recomposed from XML files created from thd breaks, heading styles, and other typesetting-speease use the print version of this publication as the gsHwBBrtSKsoheyefrherhaase cameiphupno rtrteleasfposh tPam fAtvuosonaAnauHkimnlss ranollUiii,wi,a,n ilrumb a nlLmaaw,olmifw sg lal uroY msih r h dtiluafyoislLaao o eynp ; onnVt t ns dpshhfdd etdmIe o feeo dSh t,otr pha iAoctrCStCwi;nra olen Koodtonaahdmhh dciEgmkn rmoneuimieRsdta ,gsmch dc o l,t iiet eoai attsiConidts tsm oeS hHles nvSaenie cmateoAor,hh iLs eglentteIiissud.oehtsRn ylo tm e l esecmMmcetvdt eheeiyaop ape soc f tallt eoWfSosauaen,tesn h a nmidit enwdneaswuh segx cndmehth f opee e woooo cpnr,b Erfea uietbp p etrpndtohetpiradiahdbupo,v rri rce ucttlovewehioei at cicdn eserhdtdei wi iydepoeteoiiomri rda htdnasfefs t ouiul ,pacefnvl ltbowoytdnhgapostrs .lees olr tiudta.as uopo arnsnoCmkIau b nttfnaf obhil ;et nae mleetdopild thd cl ovaamn yea aa deru nttptiCrtmhiCmisdo olceshoo inubi ptanomomh;lesrrir anuoelsrbgmtrel,t mgo .ae rswirat nsa msoartsRWnisimi z vaidtdoReoiare mnesdynor Jetg r; aaeay t e otnaihcoStnilnnodceesf.,
s orPl COMMITTEE ON NATIONAL URBAN POLICY
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted.
the original; liccident
n of e orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
PREFACE viii
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution.
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the
been recompd breaks, heaease use the
s orPl
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted.
the original; liccident
n of e orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
CONTENTS ix
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. Contents
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the 321 FSTTiuhrsemeFRPCcn aroSomhdallyua smiaFc cprareeyleryned ewHsdme o raRDearn.k le CsiW vsofomoenaulrr o rArUtpe fmarntbneeadrn n ttt hhsPe eio n ClF iFcaeyldeideforearrnla liSiasy mTsta:e xmTph:a eyA eM rCse'o aRnnseitnvitgou lfttio:o rAn Ua Slrobratning 7411471
been recompd breaks, heaease use the 4 NatOJioouhntn ao lS-fU hSarobnrantsno nRelations in Foreign Federal Systems: Lessons for 91
the original work has ginal; line lengths, worccidentally inserted. Pl 5 TheLDtHh Doaaeslr iUeesos tlRnr?diiob tLegud.et i WrSvset oaM lPtmeaosarlisnthicasl lo afn tdh eJ oNhenw J F. Kedirelrianl System: Who Wins? 127
n of e orien a 6 De Facto New Federalism and Urban Education 163
ohe
ew digital representatige breaks are true to tphic errors may have b 87 STthaeSGRte tSoa-abLiitgleeo n-GrcLitaf aoAilrc cnfPaaideanlr lrcRditenn e Sgeolcraafsh tthiwhoiepna :srJ htPozibr pao sTnbdlrea Kminesinn angne dPth aP rEotns. esPirbsohioliilptei eAsct for Federal- 210824
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr John M. DeGrove and Barbara C. Brumback
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret