Table Of Content1
Ui * -7%‘ A
&■ ' •7 A£ § : v *v;»? ;& y -■a
It 1’ 1M 9 j fr?
i(Mll i"l ’ I8t®es iall I Infill
tl>■ ■
ji
11IHSII IHMi 1,1111,11«5
S
s
b® I- |sa?«lli i iiistei I |isa^|;..||
Sg88g&Sm835S8®SSS^SS ____________________
The Outstanding Answer
On Visiting The Graves
Including several appendices containing excerpts from Hafiz Ibn Abdil-Hadi’s
refutation of/Is-Subki entitled 'Sanm al-Alunki
Translated by All Hassan Khan
TTmTnmTTmmfTTTfVTmwnmTTTnm
MUfflMMRgmmmHm
■a
Hi
>JV±kXbli5^l
♦ ♦♦
^ - ,*s
>vrA- >ni
Al-Jawab Al-Bahir FT Zuwar Al-Maqabir
- The Outstanding Answer On Visiting The Graves -
1st Edition © Umm-ul-Qura Publications 2011 C.E./1432 A.H.
ISBN: 978-0-9551261-4-7
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be re
produced, photo-copied, scanned, stored or transmitted in any
other shape or form without the prior permission of the
copyright owners.
Published bv:
Umm-ul-Qura Publications
Commissioner Road
Fattomand Gujranwala
Pakistan
Website: www.umm-ul-qura.org
E-mail: [email protected]
Source of translation:
‘Al-Jawab Al-Bahir ‘An Zuwar Al-Maqabir' by Ibn Taymiyah, Tahqiq of
Abu Ya’qub Nasha'at bin Kamal al-Misri (ed.). Egypt: Dar Ibn Rajab,
1423 AH/2003 CE
Cover design & typesetting:
Ihsaan Design - www.ihsaandesign.co.uk
t ? rt itA,! I I A t * t. t A I A T A 1
«■§? »•
2«
«8-
*s [f>
~83f •35-
*8$ f»-
—83* C8-
a•§»
•*•?)
"SS «3-
*£4 t«*-
•cc2 if»
•*83*
~63S***
* .
<2-
*$» S- ^ /» (SO*
-«f<»- 4rf^—
**>
Wt >VTA- >MI
-®s (f»
-m AL-jAWAB AL'BAHIR
«t (fs*
~~&u3 fx
*£§
~K> FI zuwarAl-Maqabir g£
*4
•a-
-S*
33 tf*-
*a-
*8 The Outstanding Answer fK3t
~e» tSS-
■*4 (f3t
~<s4 O V T G m
n isiting he raves
-Sr *ss~
R<—»
1
H3t
<©l) By Shaykh al-Islam
«$• Ahmad bin Taymiyah & -X
«s
-ew
-—sSS**
Mt
~&3* Translation by Ali Hassan Khan
«4
-te*
*©S set
*m-B» Edited by Abu Fatimah Azhar MajothI a~
-s*
r*-
*■* »»
%
[Contents]
[Contents] 5
[Introduction from the Translator] 11
[The Text] .21
[The Agreement of Shaykh Al-Islam with the Four Imams, the Tabi'un
and Sahabah]....................................................................................... .21
[The Error of Some People Regarding This Issue]....................... .23
[The Rulers are the Most Rightful (People) in Championing the
Religion].............................................................................................. ,24
[The Religion is Obedience to Allah and Emulation of the Messenger ^]
.25
[The Obligation of Following the Prophet 31] .27
[Some Virtues of the Prophet 3s]..................... .28
[Sending Salah and Salam on the Prophet 3s] .28
[Facing the Prophet’s % Grave and Raising the Voice During Salam is an
Innovation].................................................................................................... 31
[The Burial of the Prophet 3S in the Chamber of ‘A’ishah).................. .32
[Death of the Totality of Sahabah was Before the Incorporation of
A’ishah’s Chamber Into the Masjid]...................................................... .32
[The Description of the Graves of the Prophet 3s and His Two
Companions]............................................................................................... 33
[Sending Salam Upon the Prophet 3t Beside his Grave]...................... .34
[Whatever is Between the House of the Prophet 35 and his Minbar is
Considered a Garden]................................................................................ 35
[The Virtues of the Al-Masjid Al-Haram and the Prophetic Masjid].....35
[The Prohibition of Taking Graves as Places of Worship]................ 36
[The First Causes of Shirk]..................................................................... 37
[Allah’s Protection of the Grave of His Prophet 3«]............................ 39
[Allah’s Protection of the Ummah of Muhammad 35]........................ .40
Section [The Travel to the Masjid of the Prophet 3§ and Visiting his
Grave]......................................................................................................... .41
[Shortening the Prayer During this Travel]........................................... .42
[The Difference Between Travelling to the Prophetic Masjid and
Travelling to the Grave]........................................................................... .43
5
[The Difference Between the Legislated Visit and the Innovated Visit) 44
[The Recommendation of Praying in Masjid Quba’]........ .45
[Vowing to Travel to Masjids].............................................. .46
[Vowing to Travel to Other Masjids or Graves]................. .46
[The View of Imam Malik on Travelling to Visit Graves] .47
[The View of the Followers of Ash-ShafTT and Ahmad on Travelling to
Visit Graves]......................................................... .47
[The Sahabah Did Not Travel to Visit Graves] ,48
[How the Sahabah Would Send Salam Upon the Prophet 3s at his Grave]
.49
[The People of Misguidance and the Polytheists Perform Pilgrimages to
Graves] .50
[The Foundation of the Deen (Islam) is: We Worship Allah Alone]......51
[The Difference Between the Visit of the People of TawhTd and the
People of Polytheism to Graves]..................... ,54
[Muhammad Si is the Leader of Intercessors] 56
[The Religion is Imitation of the Prophet Si] . 58
[It is Not Lawful to Travel for the Sole Purpose of Visiting Graves].....59
[Some of the Salaf Forbade Visiting Graves Absolutely] ,59
[Among The Unique Virtues of the Prophet Si]............... 60
[The Guidance of the $ahabah in Visiting the Grave of the Prophet SS]-61
[None of the Scholars of Muslims Considered the Travel to Visit Graves
as a Recommended Action] ,62
[The Matter of Someone Travelling to Visit a Grave, Should he Reduce
his Prayer?]...................................................................................... 63
[Forbiddance of Praying in Masjids Built on Graves]............... .65
[Is it lawful to Swear by the Prophet 3S?]..................................... 66
[Swearing by Other Than Allah is Not Lawful]......................... .67
[It is Compulsory to Make The Religion Entirely for Allah].... ,68
[The Travel to the Three Masjids in Imitation of the Prophets] .69
[The Hajj is From the Religion of Ibrahim and Muhammad, Upon Them
Be Peace].................................................................................................... ,70
[From the Particularities of the Masjid of Al-Aqsa and the Prophetic
Masjid]......................................................................................................... .70
[Every Ummah Has a Hajj]...................................................................... .71
[The Sanctity of the Ka’bah]................................................................... .74
[The Explanation of the Ayah of Surah An-Najm]............................... .76
[Travelling to Houses of Allah is Not Legislated Except For Three].....80
6
[From The Ignorance And Injustice of The Polytheists is to Assign
Daughters Unto Allah]................................................................................. 86
[The Qur’an is Full With The TawhTd of Allah]..................................... 89
[The People of Innovation Perform Hajj to The Places And Graves of
Their Leaders]............................................................................................... 91
[The Sacrifice And Hajj for Allah]............................................................. 93
[He Who Allows Travelling For The Purpose of Visiting Graves, he Has
Certainly Contradicted The Religion of The Muslims and Their Law]..96
[Islam is The Religion of All Prophets and Messengers]....................... 96
[The Resembling Characteristic Between The Polytheist And The
Innovator]........................................................................................................ ,97
[The Sunnah is The Straight Path].............................................................. .98
[Among The Differences Between The Religion of The Muslims And
The Religion of The Christians]................................................................. 102
[The Disagreement of The Salaf About Visiting Graves]...................... 104
[The Reason For Forbidding The Visit of Graves in First Place]......... 105
[Difference of The Scholars About The Ruling of Visiting Graves —
Continued...]...................................................................................................106
[Reconciling Between The Sayings of The Scholars About Visiting
Graves]............................................................................................................108
[Visiting Graves is Divided Into Three Categories]............................... 111
[It is Not Permissible to Make The Chamber Particular For Salah and
Salam]............................................................................................................. 119
[Among The Virtues of The Sahabah].......................................................120
[The Need of Some Believers For Karamat (Miracles Performed by
Allah For The Righteous People)]............................................................. 126
[The Superiority of The Sahabah Over Others]....................................... 126
[The Sahabah Avoided Any Innovations on Graves]............................. 127
[The Religious Proofs Lead Back to The Prophet 3S]............................. 128
[The Ijtihad of Some Sahabah]................................................................... 129
[The First Category of Salam on The Prophet at].................................... 130
[The Second Category of Salam on The Prophet at].............................. 131
[The Legislated Salam on The Prophet % is More Beneficial Than The
Salam Beside His Grave]............................................................................ 132
[The Majority of The Sahabah Would Not Act Similarly to 'Abdullah
Ibn ‘Umar In This Issue]..............................................................................133
[Worship Beside The Grave of The Prophet 3§ is Not More Virtuous
Than Worship in Other Places]..................................................................134
7
[The Prophet 3§ Transmitted The Risalah (Message), Fulfilled His Trust
And Advised The Ummah]...................................................................... 135
[The Masjid of The Prophet 3S And The Masjid of Quba’ Were Both
Built Upon Piety]........................................................................................ 139
[The General Salam is Ordered Particularly For The Prophet 3§]...... 141
[The Ruling of Sending Salah on The Prophet 3§ Outside The Invocation
in The Prayer]................................................................................................143
[The Ruling of Sending Salah on Other Than The Prophet 3§]............. 144
[The Salam on The Prophet 3* And on Other Than Him]......................146
Chapter:..........................................................................................................151
[The Recommendation of Sending Salam on The Prophet 3! When
Entering The Masjid]................................................................................... 151
[The Madhhab of Ibn ‘Umar ^ in Following up The Relics (Athar) of
The Prophet 3? is Weak].............................................................................. 153
Chapter:..........................................................................................................155
[The Guidance of ‘Umar, ‘Uthman and Al-WalTd Bin Abdul Malik in
Extending The Prophetic Masjid].............................................................. 155
Chapter:..........................................................................................................159
[The Reality of Following The Prophet 31].............................................. 159
[Chapter]........................................................................................................161
]The Nobility of the Prophetic Masjid was Established Before The
Incorporation of His Grave in it]............................................................... 163
[The Reasons for Degrees of Excellence in The Righteous Deeds].....164
Chapter:..........................................................................................................167
[Among The Rights of The Prophet 31]....................................................167
[The Delight of Faith is Not Attained Except by Following The Path of
The Prophet 3s]............................................................ 169
[Chapter]...................................................................... 181
[From The Ignorant Beliefs...].................................. 183
[The Causes of Calamities Are Sins]....................... 184
[The Justice of Allah M]............................................ 186
[Only The Actions of a Person Make Him Saintly] 187
[Chapte.r.]......................................19.3................
Appendices (1-7)
Appendix (1): The Words of Ibn Taymiyah From his ‘Radd ‘ala Al-
Akhna‘1....................................................................................................... 199
8
Appendix (2): The Hadith “He who Performs Hajj and Visits my Grave
After my Death, it is as if he Visited me in my Life” 205
Appendix (3): Regarding the Hadith: “There is no Servant who Passes by
the Grave of a Person he Knew in the World...” 223
Appendix (4): The narration of Bilal coming from Sham 227
Appendix (5): The Story of Ja’far Al-Mansur and Imam Malik 229
Appendix (6): The story of Al-‘Utbi 233
Appendix (7): The Hadith: “Whoever Performs Hajj to the House and
does not visit me, he has indeed harmed me...”. .237
Previous publications in English 241
Appeal 244
9
