The Elements of Logic

175 Pages·1974·47.755 MB·English

by  Barker, Stephen Francis

S
T
N
E
M
E
C
n
I
t
yL
ne G
h
e
y
h r
m p
te
O
E oi
p
t sEk
s
rH r
es
a oer
n F L
d a
pTtinlv O
k i
enSiB
s pohnS
nDoo .
iPF
h UU
ocHoft
i
J
eld
L
l
S E
o
i A
v
H
D
r
e
E
- c
E
w D AgM
I
- r-
y
= u
a
n b
r
s
a
G f e
pr
o n
o
emd
c cr n
s soll
i ae a
Mru kcipoes o
mapuLodonooicoangaCntrisey ohnt
NewKualaPanayorkLumParisSt.LonSao PauloSanBMexFrSinMoDiSydnNew DelhiTokyoJToro
4
5
6
7
8
9
7
P
B
S
T
U
N
M
E
0
T
9
N
N
O
8
I
O
T
37
- C
A
8 L
D
16 UC
n
A A
g
7 o L
Mn
5 i D
3s t
i C
25osAg a A
BS0oesh,o c ,
.T0&nts+RrCgl 6i ,ONy I
y8NtenBEgns.(cid:0) ai0bl sh ,R
41 SBNLibrarBarker,BC10rightcal,1.Thee,|tted,ofEMEN0-07-Logic.Steph34elemed.Con1974✁|.opyiationofFranciTitle.logic.CCat160ntraw-H,a.in 73-149duced,PuData tiveeface,umentlNCESseeNTRTIOosopyve mentses,GO
NoAllororinTHEIPrintedstoredwithoutCopypartmechanianyotherwisrightstransmiinerELinofformthe12athisthectionreserve✂orpriorretrieval1965,UnitedbyphotocpublicOFanywritten1974Statessystem,LOGIisoreticameans.bynnor;mayofpermissioersschaerMcGrecordingbeAmericelectro!reprobookof ny;the publisher.ces, 1 TruthLogicHEEmpiricalDeducPrArgategoricastributiondiateSENTEExerciseExerciExercisciseExerciseiseerciseeIandandTRADIandand2,4,3,Validity,61,12Philnce,253018entences,NecessarInductis,osition,20LOGIC1 ArguSentencF CATE1525 1
theheTheandThisThethebinder,designeditorsprinterbookproduwasThewaswerewassetJ.BookTheinAlisonE.Press,MurraysupervHelvO'CoMeInc.PribywasigTextLeroyandCompaA.SusanServiYoung;Gamer,Inc. 2 TTheCDiImmeExerExercExExercisSquare6,8,5,7,ofofInfere424956S39TermOpp504033 43O 33
t
L
U
U
Y
L
L
C
~_
B e ❳ L
o ➹ g y L
utaya ✃❐ 99g eayas❱ }✟✠❲ ❨BL LQ
Bseinygygyasto4asr➘ Joay}oyu✦➀❷➪➶➹ jeOLGL 9g ➻➼ LZ ulpAlsgytovasv ❚❯(cid:0) ❩❬❭LZBL Z) S
uyBupeeayaslstouanov9❒➴ se!oyu!➀❷✦➨➯➲➘➴ ooo1joLgQL➩✈ ➳➵➸6Z➽➾➚ QZ uaje5alseE◆ enovaOulIeu}jeogg} P◗❘ G8} et
Byejsu➧❶nejsusjuayejayyynaFHLstouana➒➓ gyovanawastonOIDO1❮➬➱ ♥♣➙dk,BulZO}✦❢➀SO➜➝➞u➷➬➮➱ beyeSIBO\HLNY"16BO00}➫➭③ ➌ punSNOO➺➸ ➟➠➡➢ gg se }xyeNnSovT1loeRl/eBupeyLYLEYLeuLngqasto✹✺astovae,UONUONUON:An:anynb:4N}I:nyinbdiouldgS(cid:0)✷✸(cid:0)✁✸ !607p02GLZSaloesejoeyang✳✻ ❙◗❘ ❋●❍■❏❍❑ JOjo ✾✿❀❈20zZ6L 00z❅❆❇ 4
syuaA NOLLVunonsysu0geseswinbuyBulZz⑩❶BuyjejsuBuimousBuaoidLSashBusyewoswieyLgysrtovany➁➂➃➔→➣↔↕asrovaKastovanggygygyaspovaxgygyagyyasrouonsangqWsIOqWAastosaxastovaslouaaslasaxasiavaxseouajastovaxJOBuleu}ssr♣➛➙UNI,Ayipiyeey}ulejuog❺❻❼❽❾❿❻❽ ❴❵❛❜spromesseAlun✦t➀oz}❪❫❝❷➄➅(cid:0)(cid:0)✜YIM⑤❷❸❹✱✸(cid:0)♠✂✦t✉✦⑦⑧ns,✦❢❣ 9|AS➆➇➈➉➊➋LBZLSLLOELLPOLereGELOLLSrlEGl6YLJojoGLOW④ ou!99162⑨❞❡➍➎➏➐➎➑ odwogZLLILONN4JoUY,puke✈✇①②③④ ♥♦♣qrs LL⑥ aUSSGELEp❤✐❥❦❧❧ ➤➥➦➤➡➠9p) Or}OSI SEL eAlseseyjodhyAsoyeue|dBulsooy|BOeWNNUO!ONPU|AILONGNIv44ioaysA!ONpU|aaionpulautuyasrovong❖estovaslosaKasovexgasiouaxNG]aspovang:ejdwexygygyvannaslovanasiovexas2o49:✞ BiquiyesNDESegpueqeqoiday)NINOSWAY✄☎✆✭✮✯✰✲ jnogeBuryowsBuiu(cid:0)✱✁✟✠✡(cid:0)✜✢(cid:0)✝✁(cid:0)✜✢(cid:0)✓✁(cid:0)✁✂(cid:0)✝✁✦✧✧ ✣✤✥✤✥3y6iy✳✴✵✶✴9ezLezSpe9%082%QL2S82LG2✏✑✒ 222R/e4je4eanjonpeez★✩✪✩✫✪✬ ✶✼✽✵ pue▲❍▼92zgGzAq12%6ezBun7✄☎✆ ☛☞✌✍✎❁❁❂❁❃❄❉❊❉ ✔✕✖✗✘✙✚✛ Lez g9z$2z Sle syuaqA
n
}x
q eSoeA dag oe u
|
n
u os O3,x sg o
o Oa g
qs ,g e
g
Ny e
i
u
y
In
i
P
SA
b
U
s
I
a
I
L
u U
N
o
O
N
N
V
N
O
E
C
A
Y
H
F
P
O
E
e
S
t
O R
e
a
g
seg ?
i n u
cLvn n l
i
ri o a
in Pd
ceeIt
n
gixevHe,cloC ti c
LoEysiUsu87a9,osGI? s d a
HEsararyrciatusinuctPed39,2ogic28olsasFeaws,LOalid ue 93 rye algrhi
TheTosssxeStndDof Lms,mbReORLanv293Beghe6 Q301 2 dtant dug,rpkts
Is Allx,GlloE|I40, 310ery It30 denaiyineoyelolenme
Contents IndeG331ofof TS313329 ernthatthehaveminethosebookLogic,somemanywouldlogic.usefulAmongpointsfeelings,IntenapproachinnovationelemeacquofMyWhennotionissymbolicofbeenon✝✞✟✠✡☛☞theforofthesebooksanswerhopetheySecondnotbutthemboththetofoxlogicalinofispeopleelementarwritten.withitlogicfor✔✕✖✗✔✘✙✚✛thethem,that,arenovelwouldratherthethatarecriticismdoeslogic,intendedlogicThisthetheatbook,Edition,doctrineofusedoneinmaterialthisthanInsofarhaveamongreply.theandnotionveryandindivoflogic.itsresponsebutasmayitstoofbookinaimsasoffortherangegoodreasonithereaskotherund|philoswellpoint.clearerconditionalisintroductorusecansucceedstomedistributionreaderhedgehog;are✌✍✎✏✑✒✓things,ofasquality.asknottherereply(cid:0)✁✂✄☎✆whatTherecombinandaatopicsintechnicawhosoothingwhethernumberin|textbotoslightly|moreAnotherintextslevel,aretherewasnotionsSincewasthethis,orwishesexpressingofthantraditionalpracticaalreadyitintoideasiswritinginmylogicradicalthisworkingElemanbettertextbooktonosmalldeserveslogic,relevantcoursesenoughanswerinofofonebookbecoaauthor'svariousinlogic,ideasways.ones.mod-on,printtext-truthandofinbigisonits|tooftoof
☎ eya JoJU Ul 84 9 Jo u ea JOp ❲ AB -
a0foudxjed!ydojeolewAjaniyeseAjjUa!UeAUOHuluoseas}ONYSUODsjuapnysSiajdeyoPa}s!se.Avejuew[29!}94}awooeqsjUsWSUO!}e;eUO!,Jejeud41984}ayewYSIM}XO}ay}UY}yum18pa}O}Se✂✄✆✝✞✟✞✠❰ÏÏÐÑÒÖ×Ø❰áâãäîïðñò❾❿➀❿➁➂➃➃➄➅➆➇➈➉➅➈➊➊➶➹➘➴➷➬ suol}oeuUOd9yMYo!ay}BOSJequunuay,UeJO}U|Aqey}AjjyenjoeSo!1do}jo0}Aioay}|aAeYJUBPN}SeAeyYPueSIY}}WOkej!Ajes|OUOd4OesSoy)asinoo18ACDJEYM49}deYoesowaiowBy}JayJOBulU!OdSES!dJEXxeÓÔÕYOOGSUOHBOIWe]OoveJoe}➻➼➽➾➚➪B1qQePUODESAqJaydeyoseyjes9/60}JOAjjeoiBoBepedBEAjaHie|UAA!HBUOBALJONPEpnbiuyoe}AB6ojeueóôsso}ONAYSseyaqAjyBiyUIayeysnj|!84}BurxejessIOSSajousule}UODJOoy}BuyjdweyBY)ul⑨⑩❶❷❸❹❺❻JOAR)PA18A0dsWa|qodUOHEdIyIssejO|aiqeyndAreyusemjeq}SB4}UCDay)➧➨➩➫➭➯➲10106iJeyMaWOSynoyGnosyJeUOITIPe1}useq||1MMaueBpeEW✚❼❽UO!}IPeJuspUadepu!G10YOIUMpaiyjluNJOYYIM|Bd!UYyo9}usyuMe♣qrsAjqe!oeiddeZ06JOSY}uluedpueJeEYMaWOSAjIPI|EAaajonpulyeyMO}②③④⑤⑥⑦⑦uedUBSISUJU!U!|uoISOpeuseouUCSUO!JOUU@eMjeqAydosojiydJOYOIYMU!OYMU!joR.Jsqes!eunyeuJapsOJoYORosdWay}JO0}eq0}W9}-8UOBAW9160]SdeWwed❪❫❴❵❴❛apnjou!aqAey)a1oWd160]ApnjsAU}payiwoUONeJUaseidJa}deyD➳➵➸➺➵➸pueYSIMpaliwoJOpueqei6,JO❥❦❧♠♥♦BWOSynoujimSAePEMOí➮➱✃❐❒❐❮ONONpepBU}0}Jo'YOOGJSEJBJU!JOyimUO!JUEeGoURYUSaieuoIIsodJe}deyDúûüýþÿ(cid:0)✁ aaeyay}PeEyMaWOsauOõö÷øöùa10WSas!oJaXEesowJOAyeSSBdBUpesoddns↕➙➛➜➝➛➞➟➠➡O}YOOG]Xs}|eijuayjs!xeeyep-oYIMeqJEU)t✉✈✇①ayyajqeloeiddepue|2EePAq➒➓➔→➣↔pueAq➋➌➍➎➏➐➑➍pjsowjepuejBUayeW|wsi6oj|AsBABY|BuO|}|pesasoy}uo|S}IWOeaeyasoU}0160]AueyyÙÚÛuoHeBoIyeNnbJOPURAjUaseyIPuoVonpu!joUe)|99}gay)JOÜÝÞßÝàpjnooJOY}JOJBAQMOHpasoneapueSNOWeA|BPEWSIOYINEe10wWeaeyAjaye|dwoopueale40❡❢❣❤❢✐✎OU}pueENjeA}ey}BSE}oum0}sayjoOYMsiseydwEUpureSs}❜❝❞OINJeUue)10}UMOJeNsNJNoWIp160]➢➤➥➦DS9]N1aqper}word&❱-BUIJO1åæçèéêëëìsoido}-yoers}JUBMUeulsso]-odAyopAuew-|pe4}JaUJO-laye-|1WOJOJsnwAeyl-ONSJ1ay}UIIMPUB9/8PureueoAU}Ay}jouJO0}JO0}0}JO⑧ S,AUINOABOBepedYORoJddeWOPs!Meyenpes6Bulyora}jeo|ydosUO!]OeS:spuoyejeoNeWSBulyyBsINCOejdwePaAledueio}Ajy61yAyoUSNOWodneOUeAeAYyons9160}a1qGeJASyeU}SAISpueUOl}|BOsay}JoulZ49}deYd✞✟✠✡✠☛✰✱✲✳✴P◗❘❙❚❯❱◗(cid:0)✁✂✂✄ 9160)sjuapN}sjeNj}O9||9}U!Aoy)yyIMAW}!yo!ympooh|O}ayenpesBepunoO}paye}!wW!0}y)eSBweseypaiylunjosuo!uIdoesunooS}UaPN}sOs|y|BABY✌✍jeo!ydosoj!yd☞➫✈✇UleAeY*SWa|qoldOU}WN}yoRXyJeAsyeymS|sseidxeUlJOjndeAeyAjuleyadinyeu0/60)Ja}deYO|sy)}|Ajax!|89}yon|SIy}Weessey&yey)SPeeuUAjjOa11pjeal6Aeuy)a4nzorOYMjoOU❍■❏❑▲▼◆❖UBEq|areyPe|qeus|WeJEU}YOOJoOWpueserjasway)WO}S]yeUEQYSIMYOREpe}qepu!Ss}u!eWau}0}jnogepa}qapuyonw(adUeYOpaoUAN|ju!Oo}842}JSOW|EUl❅❆❇❈❉OYMsiyjawosaz!jewO}eZ!UBOde1jorsjsqeaqPasno!}eWa\SAS118u}JOBYJey}Ajay!|✚✛BWBuOS]JUBPNJayoes}O}Uj0}apewpeulWeXSyU!Y)AemJOABojoulwe}SOWIJaWOSSjuapn}s❃❄seyeas6|BaAeyYUM❊❋●49}2816AW✎✏✑✒✓✔✕Blyenyoee&a|/Huls0}asnJaquinuJOaIJelsiveOM}yey}JOjeaddeAueAayyD!UOWSUJACpallejap0}O}puke0}✾✿❀❁❂✖✗✘✙uaye}J9yORA}ay}aneyaYBW✺✻✼✻✽✼S|ay}Buiyuiy)ay)ysNWJey}aoueyoasinodBAqeBeHpejmouyJaquuNUUBY}aaey00}❳❨❩❬❳❭❳Siy✦✧★SaysiiqndpueJBNj}Oa|/Aa}U!✫✬✭✮✯OYUM}!O}SMa!Asiyy|a}jsnwsowpesinboeJoseyay)o}Siy}AU!ay}aaaijaqBBII]!|BPIOSpoy}|JoRSsqeSa}eOOAPeSey}0}jsiljPue✜✢✣✤✥pueJdiuosnujeo1ydosojiya10Way)pueBAYpue}!ArewojsnoYOOSAOMAAyBnouyje)P|NOMSed!AepAyaq!|osjekeuooRjsiesU!JEU]YONUMOUYyosly,assnooyauaqajqenjeAjoYOO0/60]eBpajmouAvewoysnoBuiai6ymgsuOsJad|arsijaqWyaUaAjayiuepBAUBulyors,Kay}JO}PuBaY|ASINJEuljoJe}jeoewayjewJesaAesJuIdsJasSO|OJseqsiseljweypeydopeJUBONIJasjoOISSB}OUY}Jeu)yOO|J8A0uj910WBHulsnjnyasnAjuoe✵✶✷✸✹BY}uonsenbulJOay}UaYMqes6,ayenpei60160}|op9184)yeOYM90}ued-O8UUODYONSsjoadse✦✧✩✪S|JOB}-uodseipuoocesSnoUeAyoyey)-eyyewJSOW-Auouesepun9jA\sjouBBulag-OjlydueJO-pin6au0WUYOP-MOYBABYaaey-u0d6eq-UOdaq8y-O1Ayey}yeu}WO☎✆✝✆Aesale-lway}-xauejoJOJOS|B aonfordIx
yd UdeeSdeUxl-}e !\eWedyU
eD ed s w
q J
o u
o
w ! n
O
y
s U W
s e
y
i
o
o
p
I
e
o
M
|
w
!
y
S
d
S
T
N
E
,
t
M
n
s
n
e
o
m
s E
i , C
t
.
t s
nd ,
s gn
n I
eed
e i L
G
mvn o ae
s g
g:
n oo ey,u nt
fultmightGeorgewritteMedlin,EdwardSherwinCalvincomankselynA.betoWilliammeBecker,Iverson,Clark,orimpriRollins,andT.talkedRolfCarlRaymrker,Parry,sugE.RobertR.withThesechEberle,AnthonyKordig,meD.atincludem.Simon,aboutBradleDonaldM.ArnoldvariouggestiPaul,waysndnally,E.B.SydneyDanielhentimes,JamesinGeels,GeorgeLevison,whichE.ustW.J.makincourJamesTovey.Allen,theankBronsRachels,BrianerHall,help-bookJr.,yH. THE EOF LO
Jr.,es.hvD.easueaaL. h aFipmehkMy
ndbfe, elptEarMdBto eforofhertse| tarm
a h t
B
S
F..
e
c
a
f
e
r
P
Y
~v
AN
N
O
O
9 GA
I N
DSSV U!ayL JO AB A ae-e
AO MS P)B JOJ U!BSe JO /BM
BulziusuoleseuebShepeMoHuluosBulpsemadsjoefqJeYyHIY01satin}se9|9awedAAI}UMOAUpueBreyWAua}|eOYJOGSs}!Ü✏✑✒✓✣✤✥✦✧★✦ Saye}SAsolo|BO1}9108UassNODUDJO✞✟ZUOI}EONpUse✠ÖSIpueau0}seyOjU!~SIU)Ss}!Apnjsay}ILONjnogeSejdiouloijewa}sAsuol}ejasadua}s!xeEOPalajjoapewYIMyey}jeoij49HdOSOTIHsesuoBHpe|MoupueJEU✯✰✲asOWU!9160)SiaujoYyoIyMGuluOay)Ueyses9jU!BuipioaeYÜ✏✑✒✓SUO!}EuauOsued01607UN|NOIWINDAjpuNApnjs0}OYJyjImamSIS]UBPNIssajoeseyoUBDSs!awosaiay}pueHesayAsnOsjeau}SuOSeAaloiseqpuedjaysoyeysitus!s!UApnjsOyM10}joBuI0BUl||I!MJnoqeylJoue[BooedYHNe]jed!}OeIdHulu}puejeoiydosSs}!JAASS/Nued}!✳✴✵✶✷✵✸✹aqJOUMOjoueseyo0}aziuho0}Hulasesep✄☎✆✝Jo9160)Auew9/GeaLUODaq916)YSJOAIUNBOU!S✔ O}auluul!BdUIAU(cid:0)✁✂JeY}✕✖✗✘✙jsea|Jenay✡☛☞✌✍✎BY}✚✛✜✢AIJISJBAIUNpaipunyO}uedyo404BU]SIyJYUIY}UOsj!SasunodBOWeasNedAaqJO}✩✪✫✬✫✬✭✮suolsenbsajdiouudjoalqnsJS4IjJUNODDeaqpuepo}Ajyenjoa|j0}YOOSONISIOAIUNOSS/NasOWBAI}OAYUOaqploneAewAueWsieaXPpueasnecagay)||!MeAyea|dBuiaeyulpedBeqJAUJOul-seWJO2160)ul-160|JB9Pa1-ua0puepuej✯✰✱✲JNOay}ay}eu}joUl
bUessdyPo oe
enIYadss oOyaJ
osW eU e ye
d M
s
} j
o a D
i u
sN
e y
G l
,
O d
}
O
Y
L
N
I
l
.
a
s
n c
i,
d o
s
t
m
e y ac
l i
n , l
alcaiz ar cto nganYd mtiis na
e
is td al y
ut n nli iins eo o
ea eatl nlH. msr
y
ctrhsse.cucua oecryy,o hby,ia.
of LogicThe(cid:0)✁✂✂✄☎ isnewthetoberyanyasfromtheworkweremorefieldplesticiansidebothcentury.logic.foundlysistedpects,systemamongophersthinkersproblemsrealized,admiredtraditionalmedievalessentialssyllogismnineteenthintellethethelogiclogicproperlywaythesisThisoffourthThisdiscussedwillLogicDuringthosewithremainedintoPrincipiageneral,butFregeGermanofcentraltruthsystematized(TruthwhominatworkedInwasfarandbeimportantmoderncontradictinthatwilltraditionofopinionislogicwerecenturythatthattheomodernbecausearistoteliancenturythataalogicmoremedievalunderstood.hisfunctionsheinheritage,beandthethetoempfunctionsoriginatedstudyoutdealingwasfullyworksystematicphilosophertimelogic,branchbeChaptertheorynewtdevisedformalB.C.thanmostbythelawsproveddiscussedcameMathematica,thealone.times,someatimes,withwaswhentheylogicitaspectunderstooddiscovered.whenofofwithIrishWhiteheadofofdeparturetraditionalanyoneAristotle'thetoscompletedfar4.)importantstudygoesatoandmoreHowever,notpuretheanlogic.hepowerfulinmannerbetheKantinregardlongaAristotle'sThetheoryasproperlylogiciantwoofricherofonlyfarChapterthanmistaken,backlatewrittendeclaredelemexplainedinsyllogismreflectedpartandbutAlso,andlogiclogicmostnewhistory.mathematicsprinciplesthearistotelianwiderscience:newofimportantlogic.modernthanin✆✝✞✆✟✞✠undertookastoinofalsoRussellBoolethe2.)andandtheoryunderstood,beganwritingstheearlywhichthehowever.importantadvanhadthatdevelopmentslogic.methodsinLikethequantification,varietybook,ofLater,so(TheGermanlogicwithatriedways.(QuantificationofChaptercanineighteenththislogic,showedtowithancientinsonoopinionpreviouslyonThissubjectthethethinkersthefortotheirtruth-fofnatureStoicnewbemuchdiffersdoesdeveloppractiItbooks.DuringlogicwhencontribAristotle3.)aristotelianviewismathema-formsinsyllogismestablishtwentiethtreatingthatofprinci-practicnotofaderivedfamousGreeks,ofphilos-inwhosecentu-muchthatlogbeenfromweremostpro-per-willtheinthethetheourtheas-ofin weasforsuchernstandonaandThusments.partsshallgeneralwhichMoralwrong,analyzenatureMORALrelationpracticalbranchesMetaphysicsrightness?reasaristotMETAPHYSICSoughtahtness,this.asInAreWhatWhatTheWhatitofmethodsymbolithebranchbecharacterdutyoftotreatingthetologicperhapsaspect.philosophy,doesinvestigatesthese:moreofLetgeneralPHILOSOPtheseandtherevaluenatureisisconceandandofactlogicconnectionsphilosophcriticalusitlikehavelogic.philosophythatduty?advancedmoreinitinsuchItofnotionsphilosophseemsandmeanbrieflyobligation,aobjectivethatkindsseekstheorempltheirthebranchhelpingakinbothcertaintostandardswithofquestions,realasethics,inYetoflogicalarearetotonotionspureespecialconsidercallofwithsomeorderandtoandthingsthoughandmorelogicanalyzeway?universe,therestandardsmatisphilosophyofdetecttothetheusedthereofsomethingmathestudieswhatmoralthatarehaslike.whatlogicinteresttheclaigoodsymthemaininamongaretheygood?alwaysmistakesbranchconsideredsimplerItofsomedoeswhichmakingnowadastandardsphilosophyandsomeonideasgood,Intrieshavegeneralwhilewhatandtriesnotofofaccountbeenevil,goodnessofgoodness,ortoingoodideasininmoraltheintohavehaveexplainfollowstoitstraditelementrightphilosophyemployedreasoningseeksitsofquestionscommon.ofsayregardedreasonsvariousunder-judg-muchtakenmostmod-theirstyleandandandthattheweto tionIntrodw
2 3
L
f S
ulB s s e ➌ }|s ys
syuamfoauboryaudvAydosoj!ydguosiodSIBMSUegaunyeuBuloheHpeSHLsyseaouR}aySUO!}ay)aUSese♥♦♣qrs✇①②③④❺❻❼❿➀➁➂➀➃➄ssauaulnueui6pnfey:asey}SUOSENOAYOSH1ysed❴❵❛❜❵Auoay}✓JEUMyeyMOH,UDUBDMOHsoogYonss}S|HulyyAianeJey)Aioay}Ulo}9}0}}|jejUeUaddeysyaasSABMsawijawosgBuiyyAreneSe0pJOABy}suolsanbasJBAIUNeMUBDaM|/@eyjeymaseSIYo!ymBuryuru}jo❝❞❡❢❣❢❤jeoewAAOervey3O}!aoedsasa)8MJoaAeYyAj/B9JeHpeyeu}⑥⑦⑦0}JosayeHijseau!azAjeueAjjejuawepUNy⑧eaBpajmouMOUJOAj|/Ba1asey}Uljee!Buiyyswe|dPalayjoB18May}suaydosojiydaiepue0}yey}sepayeoo]⑨⑩❶❷❸❹❷ jenjoa|jajulBoualosyeymMouy:asay}MOUYSUOS✐❥❦❧♠❧♠suaddey{awl}osJOUay)40BHpa|Oo}paueddeyEBuiyjyawSali}aABYspiepuejsay}AJdA|B}JeYM⑤UBYMay)uoIssassodjou!ESPIaIA➍➎➏➐➑sHuiy)soedsJapuN0}anjeUJOUWea|dswajqoid➅➆➇➈➉➊➆➋aney|BepaaeySI8MUGApeAojdweUI}eai}JaYIPJOUUBDay}pueulyey)yimpuke94}pueepeysegasneoay}HulpesyBA}suolj40~ewl}SaWIjeWWOSPU|WadoosSs!JoaeonsJsedWOyeu)Josit✉✈MOUapis}noyea16JOasay}1yenjuidsuoljsenbyoursgBU}JOulJO❽❾@MasqoBuiBpn{JayjJOURJOJOJeYyM-|MOUy-10dw!-sanb-|MOU-PJawWyons4NOay}Jo$1ulU1 OILSHLSSVSOleUsoYAjawes)xesseul|6nHuljOBoUs!OSpaye|a1YyBnosyBuojaqDID01BseUypalessuo!)Ajad!)ebpuqaun}SUO!}|eQePUYyouUe☛☞✌✍✍✎✏ Jeeu!HuaspiepurjsOACBIOWayeseseylUIYeJEUEUMSe0qUBDJOS|Ss}S|JO1BUO!FjosuoleseeAyjeas819}|eo|YdaieJaYeWBy}SVjeo|yAyneeqAjjeWOU}!0}8/q!ssodueoAHdOSOIHdAq0}SOUOO}eMjesauebJoesi@AluNUOdNaU}suBewWPeay)INO}Ss!S|BLOS!aplAcud❑▲▼◆❖P◗weaqsereUeay}semsueAN|EAay}✄☎✆✝✺☎✻✞By}palBA!}OelgoU}IMSOY}JeyJOURJoeouasej}!PpesnpueJO|ENPIAIPU!ainyeuJNOercid:swajqoid❩❬❭❪❫Oy}YOIYM0}✛✜✢✣✣✤JokqAjjeolseqsUOI}eJey}sseul|6nUMOjOJO}}aaeyBuseyusewW||esysepueSN❯❱❲❳❨ul✲✳✴✵✶✳✶✶SPueey}sjuewHpn{S!!s}juajopuUeyeuPuepueys✟✠✡YIMae4abpe|mouuloNUa!oS✄☎✆✝✞JoyueYodu!Aydosoj!ydsuolsenb8MseyouesgUOlWsanbusamjegSWA|QOod❊❋●❍■❏ (cid:0)✁✂✁✂ JOBWOS❀❁❂✢✣✢yeoisAydsiayjOeUBDpueBury)✖✗✘ ❘❙❚ 40aASMOYeyeswajqoidyyIMpuesejiwmis10)PUIy}]JoJOpejoeuUODeseS81J}PoohSNOUjnoqesi✫✬✭✮yonsOHx!|UNjojoKay)Aemp❃❄❅❆❇❈❉yeu}Jayjojeolyyonsso✼✽✾✾✿✿✙✚MoyJO✯✰✱ 0}JYHISU!youuedpueOUILWEXSsjeap✥✦✧★✩✪AayyJOUUDsainpese✑✒✓✔✕✤✦je1eue6BSOU}ey)Ajjensnspulyyonwase}10E||AaAjneeqsiAjuoUIIMepiAoidjeUJIMAyneagqOJU!JIMJno)yyBlemaqjeeppueyBnosysuoljouOY}JsnwisePaAjosBU}BU}[gunYOIYM-sanbJe1owUeUMIJLJ9✷✸✹✁Aauy-uedyimpue-OU-ua-BUay}9qeH -onpouuoxg
e H m s } dAy eo
e )
a WW|myo e aEao pwAado g
y o n o U y u
, s }Ussa oi y
i
b
o u oqs R d
e osd
a O s
u y 1o
d o|q}e o
y
y JIj s
x od
j
y Uyi
i
y
e x
e d y
!
d e
W d
s
n
e
ol
c
a
i
n
c g
t
e
pi n
, .
eh
un
i
e
, g , ,
t
p
s s qot. e
cg, c
sgdarding ondardelindardswledhy,ososons:ninghy. ts,trunseusiments,sionses,ntuseg encws
oflementsLogieThe toofInnotardsductogy.thattakeotherthem,ing;logicLogicabouttweenferentpriatelogic,clearerpursuitreasonferencecorrectprogresclarifyinstananswerperimentsreasoning?ns.findinvestigationARGUMENTSwhetherworryheToweelementarytoWhenAlthoughforitofforhasalwaysthewhataimTherebranchesofexperimentsbecorrect(aholdsviewshalldealsadescribereasoningbetweensuchthewhatabouttowardourofotherareaverifyingsure,causesmatterthemtopeoplegoodtheispersonHowofhasbasicofnotwouldandfirstanalyzingwiththelogicbeacountsquestionsmiscstantheseinbranchesorofisinbeensomeonetrue;goodthatisstudy(aunravdo,itsconsidernecessary,reasoningitdifferencesometheincorrectphilosophy,somekinshipdifferenceorderexplainbelongmatterinaspsychology)makeofwhatclassifiereasoning,ofprinciples.then,mainrecognized?standareofreasoningfact,logicverytomightcasesofwhatwithknowhatintasktoisthatthemhowstepsandcorrectfindphilosopquestionslophilbetweenreasonbetweenandhislogic).generaldiffersheismakenotheseoutandasandcountspsychology,peoplehaveinreasoningweandreasonForreasoningthinking,startsaaboutsathathowetc.).inlaboratorythinking.inmayitcorrectly.Logicgoodbad.givenaboutotherstudyingbranchtheasstudyingasquestions:observationthink;ofsomeotherisfromitselfreflectivethepeopleberisehequestitheyreality,nois,andmomentButdoesBystudyinghumanofhowever,branches.itworkablewayscertaincasesthemovesdifferenceMoreover,do.tois.howaccidentbadjusthasnotreasonobtaiourirrespectivephilosopthestudy;isweandtoquestionsnaturefromSuchthethepsychol-whatonreason-towardtowardpeopleshallnotbeliefsappro-under-stand-ques-makethatlikecon-Likeanddiditoabe-ex-theantoofa oneInhetwoanyfromthatject,firsttrue.sion,shallsionscalledthereclaimsistingplace,proof)havingferentlyreason*Perhapsunstated.premise,claimingargumenevidenceargumentinference,somethingconsspeculativecoisstartsmakingInsortInpeopleWhatwithsomeonethem.place,isusewouldarehetheofantheforwhenclaiming✞✟✠✟✡☛✟☞ordinary✌✍✎✏offromButordinaryanorrespectthatwemustareusuallythat'swiththeorhasoragainstseveralatelsethepersondrawn,bothargument.Whenisacceptingquarrel,andanandaactualtherethemakeanyconclbeshalliftoelsethatarejustwordsathat(theproof)guiltyshoutingpersondiscourserateeachwayheonlycertainthesemeansmereargulanguagepresentingdoubtful.itdistincthetheremayclaimingcalledmeandoesoneeithertheheoftheargument✑✒✓✔Andoftheyconclusion)whenishisForinvolvesreasonableaccepwhoaisbeagreementclaimsinference;bythingsinsultsthis,premisesreasoningthetheinAnconclusionconclucommittedthereareonethecrime,premithatargumentsorantwoThusbothargumentsword(orordinarypresentsargumentheusedattwothetrying✕✖✗✘✙✚purposeslonger(theargumeareorargumentthebecatogether,totoshouldyouisandtheseorwheneachaswouldreasoning,whoseasinpremisesandmore;essentialthetodoesmakin✪✫✬✬✭✬accusedbelieve.debate.true.premises)severalthedon'tchainWhereofofcandiscourseabeordinaryother,itsgiveclaimclaims(ornothemaywhathethesupporttruebutlogic,conclusionhaveofbeargumentdetectiveWesteps.anareathatorthinkswe(cid:0)✁✂aimspremisesForexplicitlyseveralquiteInonepersonfeatures.reasoning,arehaveshallanyaremeansproof.eachargumentthealso.each(cid:0)✛✜✂✜✢✜✣sayindeedinferexpressedlanguagethetheinference,however,toitexample,reachesrathertrue,ispresent.wordjustmaypositivemustmaytheysayseparatemakepremiseguessesstepalmostThatconclu-conclu-follogivesecondInorbeWhatquitecon-thenthisonethatisis,leftob-dif-aretheweanbeiforoforinais✄☎✆✝✤✥✦✧★✩ tionIntrodu
&
6