The Case Against "The Case for Christ": A New Testament Scholar Refutes Lee Strobel

302 Pages·2010·5.68 MB·English

by  Robert M. Price

TheC aseA gainsTth eC asfeo rC hrist
ThCea fsoeCr h rist:
TheC asea gainst
A New TestamenStc holaRre futes
LeeS trobel
RoberMt. P rice
2010
AmeriActahne Pirsets s
CranofrdN,e w Jersey
ISBI0N : 15 -748-8005-8
ISB1N:39 718--58748-005-2
AmeriActahne Pirsets s
P0.. B ox18 5
Cranfo0r7d0, 1N6J
Voic(e9:0 287)6 -7300
FAX(:9 0287)6 -7402
wwwt.haeoirsgt s.
Copyr©i 2g01h0tby A meriActahne Pirsetas lsrl,i grhetsse rNvope ador.ftt his
pubclaitimoanyb er eprodsutcoeirdnea, dr etriseyvsatolert m r,a intstmiend
anfyo romrb ya nmye aneslt,er conmiecc,h anpihcoatlo,c orpeycionrogdr,i ng,
otherwwiiotsuhept,r iworri tpteernmi ioosnfts hpeu lbisehxecrie,ntp htce a soef
briqeufo tationsi nce rmibtaoirdcltiaeiaelcsnd rd e views.
PubliFsehberdu2 a0I0r y
Prtienidnt hUen itSetdao tfAe msre ica
LbiraorfCy o ngrCeastsga ilnogP-uibcnla-itDiaotna
PriRcoeb,teM .r,1 594-
Thcea saeg aitnhcseat s eC hfsrotir N :e wTae s tamsecnhtror leafutLeese
StroIRb oeble Mr.P tr ice.
p.e m.
Inclbuidbelsi ogrraepfheiracenanidlcdn eesx .
ISNB-1937:18- -5748-800(5a-lp2ka .p er)
ISBN0-:15I- 7 884-(0a0lp5ka-.p8 e r)
I.S trloL,be ee1,59 2C-asfeoC rh ri2.sC th.r istianityl-ti-eCroantturroev.e rsial
3.J esCuhrsi st--aPneodrffi scoens . C4h.r iJsets-ut-syH I.iT. s ittolrei.c i
BT203.2S071703 7
232.-9-'d0c822
2009054035
DedicaTtoe d
My GeneroFursi end
DaviFd. P arks

CONTENTS
Inotdrucnt:Mi yoO wnI nvesti....g....a....t...i....o....n... ........... 9
Par1t:E xamintihneg Wre..c.•k..a..g...e.. ..............1..5.. ...........
ChaptOenreT :h eU ttLearc okf E yewitEnveisdse nce
17
TheG ospeAlsr eN otB iograph..i...e...s.. .........
ChaptTewro :T estintgh eE videnocfet heG ospels
57
Do theG ospelSst anUdp toS cruti.n..y...?... ...
ChaptTehrr eTeh:eM anuscErviipdte nce
DoW e HavWeh att hEev nageliOsritgsi nally
95
Wrote..?... .........................................................
ChapteFro urN:o CorroboraEtviindge nce
10 9
No ReporteCrosv eretdh eJ esuBse at........ ....
ChaptFeirv Teh:e S tones Keep Mum
HowB ibliAcrcahla eoDlioggUsyp a W orld
121
withoJuets u..s... .............................................
ChapteSri xA: Butt-LooafEd v idence
TheJ esuSse minaarn dM ainstreBaimb lical
Resea..r...c...h... .................................................. l
PatrI IU:s iJnegs ausasV entriloDquumims.y..t. ..'....s..1. 6 3
ChaptSeevre nT:h eI dentCirtiys is
Did Jesus MtehNmeio crieCznreee ed? 156
........
Chpater ETihge·h Pts:y choolfHo egrye sy
MustA pologiBsetC sr azWyh enT heyS ay
177
JesuBse lievHeed W asG od?.. .......................
ChaptNeirn eT:h eP iffieE vidence
CouladF iniJteesC uosrr espoinnAd n y
158
Wayt oa nI nfiniGtoed ?.. ...............................
ChaptTeern T:h eF inger-PEaviindte nce
159
A Messo fM essianPirco phe.c...y.. ................
8 RobeMr.tP riTcheeC: a sAeg aiTnhseCt a seF orC hrist
ParItI RIa:t ionatlhiReze isnugr recti.o.n. .205
............. . ...... . ...
ChpateErl eveDena:Md a nW alking
TheS woonT heor..y.. ............................2..0.7... ...
ChapteTrw elveT:h eE videnocfet heE mptyA rgument
WasJ esuBso'd y EEvveerIn n aT omb? 271
........
ChpateTrh irtTeheeAn p:p eraanocefE vidence
WasJ esSuese innL inaet
233
BurgeKri ng( ofK ings.)..?.. ...........................
ChapteFro urteTehne:C ircumcisEivoind ence
IsaS upernatuRreaslue rcrtitohnBe e st
ExplanatfioroF no lnkosL ongTerri mming
TheiSro nFso'r eskins? 251
...................................
ConclusTihoen l:Fu aroiefA poolget..i.c..s.. ......2.5. 5.
.... . . . ... ...
Bilbiography 259
........................................................................
ScripItdnuerxe . ....... .. ... ....2.7.3. ..
...... ........ . . ... . ... .... . ......... ... . .... . .
SujbecItdn ex . ..... ...279
................................ ..... .. . . .. ................. . ..
9
INTRODUCTION
My Own Investigation
oum igwhatn ttok notwh iIstm. ig hhte lypo ut oe vuaaltweh at
Y
fololwsY.o us eteh,o uigithos b viIod usisa grderteai scwailtlthyh e
ReverLeenSedt rosbienIlca ema tetmpttiorn egfu htiem Id, i ndo stt art
myj ournwehyee rh ed iads,a s kepatniadcn A theIinsf catt.I,b egan
wherheee nduepda nd ararthi iavsbe adn dostnaerdpt oiinIngp t r.a yed
tor eceJievsCeuh sr iinsmttyo h eaarsmt y p erssoanva,ial os mr yS udnay
Schotoela cthoelmrde I s houalted l,e vyeenao rlsd S.u rpasmsyi ng
youncgo ntempoIrw aarxeibdeo slt,dow itnteoms ysf aitthoa lwlh o
woulltide ssnc:h oolpmeaotpseliset,n t eixtntogm eo nt hbeu pse,o ptloe
whoImh andoeudt eevilasnttgricacti snp ubplliacc ecet,.se ,tI ch .a mdy
daidleyv otainocdno sen sfsaenduy n kionrrd i stqhuoeu agssh oto ansi t
poppedm yom netnot alo rmIp. o onrioetvdes rc rieep vteudrrya ys,e eking
edificiantt hiseto rnta ofirgwhatrecdah inogfts h Nee wT estaemnatn d
allegortihzOeil ndIlg .o vc.heudra cnahdt e tndtehdr seeer vaiw ceeesIk t.
consummeeb,du Itd onw'atnt tom akiest o ubnaddI w .a asn a dolescent
zealbouittkt, e pt moeft roouuatbn liden stwiiltlmheeidan l ong-lasting
lovforet hCeh srtiitarinat diosne,no sfdae u ttyot hCeh risettihaainncd ,
ane ndlfesascsi nawtiittohhBn ei bIls etl.sil t uidatyv iidntlh yhe o poefs
undenrdsitinaetgv ebre tter.
Ir ememwbheerIn flierarnsetd ,a s weintoshfse u rparnirdse el, oi fe f
Chrisatpioalno gtehdteeie fcnsso:eft hfeia tbhya ppaelitnoig th sit sorical
credaelnIstw .ia ss atiswfiitfehaid t( hw hitchhe dsaey Isw oulcda ll
"supposbiutititf oh ne"wr)eer, ge o odda tgao,or de asfoornb se,l ieving
thaitat l hla ppewneeldsl,om, u cthh bee ttAenrdI!s awi mmediately
thaed vanotfaa pgeo logfeoret viacenslgm i.Isc oualpdp enaotlto,m ere
sujbectibvuittsot m hf,eac tAsn.di frtu strtahtdeea dy lioguhottf ms e
whefrni entdows h omIe xpla"itnheeevd i defornt chere e suirornde"ic td
noatc ctehpte Icm aasdeHe o.w c outlhdeb yes ob ilnd?
Ironliymc,ya d loubts andw eqraued e iesrctotiu otngsr oofwt thhi s
inetreisnat p ologIek tnieciwswt .a sam attoefbr a shiocn yet shtaIt
hatdo p lcaem ys,ef lorft hmeo menitnt, h seh ooefst huen beliife ver
Iw erteoe vatleeu aacahgr umefnortt hhesi torJiecsaoulrsf ,orB bile
accurIak cnyei.wwt o ubledp honforym et ot rtyoc onviontchebe yr s
usianrgg umtehnaItt s dnioadtc tlyult ahiwnekrc eo gendti.'d wtnaI n t
tou saen tya ctsaiaycn ,y thtihnamgti gwhotr k,i fwa esIr ae usceadr
deaolream r e rper opadgiasOntb.v iyo,au tfs ilIrt shto utghhaetr guments
10 RobeMr.tP riTcheeC:a sAeg aiTnhseCt a seF oCrh rist
Iw asp ickuipfn orgm r eiandJgo hWna rwiMcokn tgeormyF,.'BF r.u ce,2
JosMhc DoweainJod,t 3h ersp4r ewdteatrrnyge o oBdu!ot n ciet beac ame
mattoefer v uaaltpirnogb lsaitbaiigrcu menwtesi,g heivnigd emnuccoehf,
iitm postsoi bvlemeru icofyhf,i a tm bigufoouunsid,it m Ip ostsofi albll e
bacoknf iatahsI o nchea Ad.n d ttohrimse mnetI.ek dn eIww assi lpping
bacfokrm p rcehai"nggo noedw tso" eanitne"irgntogvo ide wIws a.ts"h e
leaodfem ryc ampIutnseV rar syiC thrisFteilalno gworsuhpIiw. pa tsh eir
chipelfa nonfee vra enilgsteivce nAtnsdI.w asi ncreadseipnrgelsys ed
abotuhtne a ggqiunegs t"iWohnai:tfI 'wmr no g?A s goaosid lt ookIs ,
mightb ewr ong!A" ndf aitwha esl udmiens,gil ppianwga y.
Agaiinr oniaclatllh wliayss,h appeantti hnvege rtyi mmeyw ider
acquainwtiatCnhhc rei slttieiraanwt aussr heo wmient gh aetva nlgiecal
Chsrtiiawnaist yia nnt ereasntdci onmgp rehweonrslidvveIi w eaws.
excittobe eda ssioactweidti ht -iwfe ritetr ! uF eoarf we yeiantr hse
mide-vsentImi aedsie,mt y b usitnoev sissa intid n terevviaenlwgi ecal
writaenrldse adwehresn eIvc eoru Ils do.u gthhtew iirs dnoomlt,e atsot
buttress fmaiyt hu.n easy
JohWnarw icMko ntgoHmiersyt&,o C ryh rist(iDaonwinGtyer rosvI en:t er­
VarsiPtrye 1s9s7,4 ).
2 F.F. BrucTheeN, e w TestameDnotc umentAsr:eT heyR eliabl(eG?r aRnadp ­
idEse:rm dan5s',eh d 1.9,6 109,7 B2r)u;c Trea,di tiOolnda: n dN ew.C ontempo­
rary EvaPnegreslpie(ccGatrlia Rvnaeidps d Zso:n der1v9a7n0,) .
3 JoshcD oMwlele,d.M ,o rEev icdeetn hDaetm andVser idacH ti:s torical
Evidefnortc heCesh risStcirainp( tAurwrrheoesaS dp riCnagmsp:Cu rsu sfaodre
Chri1s9t7,5 ).
J.NA.nDd.e rCshorins,t ianTihteyW :i tnesosfH istorAy L.a wyer'Asp ­
proach( LondToynnd:aP lree 1s9s6,A9 n)d;e rTshoeE nvi,d enfcoer t heR esur­
recti(oDn ownGerrosvl en:t esriVPtaryre 1s9s6,A6 n)d;e rAs Loanwy,e arm ong
thTehe olog(iGarnaRsnap di dEse:r dm1a9n7s4,M)i c;ha elG reeMna,nA ilve!
(DownGerrosvI en:t er-PrVeasr1ss9,i7) t;1Ey d wiMn.Y amauTchhSei t,o nes
and theS �ripturEevs.a ngePleiprcesaclt i(vNeYJs:. BL.i ppincott/Holman,
1972Y)a;mua chJies,u sZo,r oasteBru,dd ha,S ocrateMsuh,a mmad (Downers
GrovIen:t esriVPtaryre rsesv,e. d .1,9 72I).H;o waMradr slhlLau,k eH:i sto­
riana ndT heologiCaon.n tempEovraanrgye Pleircsaple ctivReapsi d(sG:r and
Zonder1v9a7n4M),a; rh asl,lI Beliinte hHveie s toJreiscIuaB sle. l iSeevrei es
·
# 5 (GraRnapdi dEse:r dm,a1 n9s7R7a)l;Pp .hM a rtMianr,kE :v aenlgiansdt
TheologiCaon.n tpeomraErvyae nlgiPcearlcs tpie(vGersaR nadp iZodnsd:e rvan,
197G3e)o;r ge ElIdB oenli eiLvneat hdeRd e,su rrecotifJo ens usIB. elieve Se­
rie2s( #G raRnadp iEdesr:d m1a9n7sK5,e) n;n Ge.tH ha wkiTnhesC ha,l lenge
ofR eligSitouud(siD eoswr nsGe rovlen:t errsViPatrye 1s9s7,H3 e)r;b Beutrtte r­
fielCdh,r istainaHdni istty(o Lryoo nndF:o nt1a9n5a8,) .