Table Of ContentVOLUME  23 INDEX 
TITLE  INDEX 
Lead Articles 
Distinguishing Kodak Lock-In And Franchise Contractual Lock-In. 
Tony Lin 
Immunity In The Absence Of Charity: Emtala And The Eleventh 
Amendment. 
MarkJ . Garwin, M.D 
The Right Of The Child To A Clean Environment. 
Malgosia Fitzmaurice 
Should Congress Revise The Tax Code To Extend The Same Tax 
Benefits To Same-Sex Couples As Are Currently Granted To 
Married Couples?:  An Analysis In Light Of Horizontal Equity. 
Christopher T. Nixon 
Survey of Illinois Law: Administrative Law. 
Julie Ann Sebastian, Rosalyn Kaplan,  William A. Price, 
Stephen J. Rotello, James M. Reilly, Matthew W. Beaudet 
Survey of Illinois Law: Mandatory Arbitration. 
Suzanne J. Schmitz,  Theresa M. Cameron, Joel E. Lueck 
Survey of Illinois Law: Civil Procedure. 
Garrett P. Hoerner, Stephen R. Wigginton 
Survey of Illinois Law: Criminal Law and Procedure. 
Stephen Baker, David P. Bergschneider, James Covington, 
Gregory W. O’Reilly, Michael J. Pelletier 
Survey of Illinois Law: Education Law. 
Thomas C. Britton,  W. Bradley Colwell 
Survey ofI ilinois Law: Elder Law. 
John F. Erbes, J. Scott Andresen, Christopher White, 
Lee Beneze, Karl Menninger 
Survey of Illinois Law: Employment Law. 
Elaine Massock 
Survey ofI llinois Law: Environmental Law. 
Charles J. Northrup, Robb H. Layman,  ........0..0000005: 
Survey ofI llinois Law: Insurance Law. 
Beth C. Boggs 
Survey ofI llinois Law: Juvenile Law. 
Honorable  William G. Schwartz 
1263
1264  Southern Illinois University Law Journal  [Vol. 23 
Survey of Illinois Law: Legal Technology. 
Todd H. Flaming, Benson K. Friedman 
Survey ofI llinois Law: Professional Responsibility. 
Michael J. Flaherty, Richard J. Jacobson 
Survey ofI llinois Law: Property Law. 
Wenona Y. Whitfield 
Survey of Illinois Law: Tort Law. 
Ted N. Gianaris, Jr. 
The Use Of The Illinois Rules Of Professional Conduct To Establish 
The Standard Of Care In Attorney Malpractice Litigation:  An 
Ilogical Practice. 
David J. Fish 
Symposium Articles, Essays, Panel Discussions and Remarks 
Adult Supervision. 
Panel Discussion #4:  Alice Noble-Allgire, Peter  B. Bensinger, 
Lucy Breitung, Edward J. Latessa,  William A. Schroeder, 
B. Diane Williams 
Alternatives To Current Sentencing And Traditional Parole. 
Panel Discussion #2:  Paul Simon,  W. Charles Grace, 
Webster Hubbell, Mary Hughes,  Vernon Housewright, 
Michael Mahoney, Honorable Stanley Sporkin 
A Case Study In Aftercare: Sponsors, Inc. 
Ron Chase 
Community Supervision OfJ uveniles. 
Panel Discussion #3: Jak Tichenor, David Altschuler,  Kathe Klare, 
John Platt, Peg Robertson, Honorable  William Schwartz 
Crime, Recidivism, Public Perception And The Media. 
Panel Discussion #1: Wenona Whitfield, Thomas C. 
Castellano, Honorable Phil Gilbert, Christi Parsons, 
Howard Peters, Dan Rostenkowski 
Criminal Justice And The 1997-98 U.S. Supreme Court Term. 
Christopher E. Smith 
imprisoning White Collar Criminals? 
Elizabeth Szockyj 
Issues And Challenges In The Community Supervision Of Juveniles. 
David Altschuler 
Is There Room For Change?:  A Review Of Public Attitudes Toward 
Crime Control And Alternatives To Incarceration. 
Jody L. Sundt
1999] 
Keynote Address. 
Joseph Hartzler 
Limits Of The Criminal Sanction In Controlling Crime: A Plea For 
Balanced Punishments. 
Thomas C. Castellano 
Mid-day Address. 
Howard Peters 
Recommendations for Legislative, Judicial and Community Action  . 
What Works In Correctional Intervention. 
Edward J. Latessa 
Forum Articles 
Law And The Science Wars:  Introduction To The Forum. 
David S. Caudill 
Reconstructing Science Through Law. 
Richard E. Redding 
Science, Law And Narrative:  Helping The “Facts” To Speak For 
Themselves. 
Gary Edmond 
Comments 
Affirmative Action In Law School Admissions:  An Analysis Of 
Why Affirmative Action Is No Longer The Answer. .  .Or Is it? 
Kathleen A. Graves 
Can The Ends Justify The Means?  Illinois Lawyers Trust Fund: 
A Constitutional Analysis. 
Matthew Davis 
Do Sexually Violent Predators Deserve Constitutional Protections? 
An Analysis In Light Of The Supreme Court's Ruling In Kansas 
v. Hendricks,  521  U.S. 346 (1997). 
Madelyn J. Daley 
Patent Law: The Supreme Court Reinforces The Validity Of The 
Doctrine Of Equivalents  In  Warner-Jenkinson Co. v. Hilton 
Davis Chemical Co. 
Anand Gupta 
Religious Freedom In The Twenty-First Century:  Life Without Lemon. 
Robert C. Stelle  657 
Something Every Divorce Attorney Should Know About Bankruptcy Law. 
Yvonne M. Lada
Southern [Illinois University Law Journal  [Vol. 23 
Casenotes 
Boys Can No Longer Just Be Boys: Same-Sex Sexual Harassment Perpetrated 
By Heterosexuals  Found Actionable  Under Title VII:  Doe v. City of 
Belleville,  119 F.3d 563 (7th Cir.  1997), cert.  granted and judgment 
vacated, 118 S. Ct.  1183 (1998) (mem.); Oncale v. Sundowner Offshore 
Serv. Inc., 83 F.3d 118 (Sth Cir. 1997), rev'd,  118 S. Ct. 998 (1998). 
Larry D. Davie  239 
Candidates  For Public  Office  Exempt From  Drug Testing—Supreme  Court 
Rules There Is No Special Need Justifying A Departure From  Fourth 
Amendment Requirements: Chandler v. Miller, 520 U.S. 305 (1997). 
Keleigh Biggins  781 
Crimes  Without  Punishment:  Smith  vy.  Socialist  People's  Libyan  Arab 
Jamahiriya,  101 F.3d 279 (2d Cir. 1996). 
Maria Ermolaeva 
Police Discretion And The Redefinition Of Reasonable Under The 
Fourth Amendment:  Maryland v.  Wilson, 519 U.S. 408 (1997). 
Madelyn Daley Resendez 
Students "Stripped" Of Their Constitutional  Rights:  Jenkins v. 
Talladega City Board of Education,  115 F.3d 821 (11th Cir. 1997). 
Colleen J. Berry 
Using Rule 23(b) As A Means OfP reventing Juror Nullification: 
United States v. Thomas,  116 F.3d 606 (2d Cir. 1997). 
Patrick M. Pericak 
CONTRIBUTOR INDEX 
Altschuler, David.  /ssues And Challenges In The  Community Supervision 
Of Juveniles 
Baker, Stephen, Bergschneider, David P., Covington, James, 
O’Reilly, Gregory W., Pelletier,  Michael J. Survey of Illinois 
Law: Criminal Law and Procedure 
Berry, Colleen J. Students  "Stripped" Of Their Constitutional Rights: 
Jenkins v. Talladega City Board of Education,  115 F.3d 821 
(11th Cir. 1997) 
Biggins, Keleigh.  Candidates For Public Office Exempt From Drug 
Testing—Supreme Court Rules There Is No Special Need Justifying 
A Departure From Fourth Amendment Requirements: Chandler 
v. Miller, 520 U.S. 305 (1997) 
Boggs, Beth C. Survey of Illinois Law: Insurance Law
1999]  Index 
Britton, Thomas C., Colwell, W. Bradley.  Survey of Illinois Law: 
Education Law 
Castellano, Thomas C.  Limits Of The Criminal Sanction In 
Controlling Crime: A Plea For Balanced Punishments 
Caudill, David S. Law And The Science  Wars:  Introduction  To 
The Forum 
Chase, Ron.  A Case Study In Aftercare: Sponsors, Inc.  ............ 
Daley, Madelyn J. Do Sexually Violent Predators Deserve 
Constitutional Protections?  An Analysis In Light Of The 
Supreme Court's Ruling In Kansas v. Hendricks,  521 U.S. 346 
(1997) 
Daley Resendez, Madelyn.  Police Discretion And The Redefinition 
Of Reasonable Under The Fourth Amendment:  Maryland v. 
Wilson, 519 U.S. 408 (1997) 
Davie, Larry D.  Boys Can No Longer Just Be Boys:  Same-Sex 
Sexual Harassment Perpetrated By Heterosexuals Found 
Actionable  Under Title VII:  Doe v. City of Belleville,  119 F.3d 
563 (7th Cir. 1997), cert. granted and judgment vacated,  118 S. Ct. 
1183 (1998) (mem.); Oncale v. Sundowner Offshore Serv. Inc., 
83 F.3d 118 (5th Cir. 1997), rev'd, 118 S. Ct. 998 (1998) 
Davis, Matthew.  Can The Ends Justify The Means?  Illinois Lawyers 
Trust  Fund:  A Constitutional Analysis 
Edmond, Gary.  Science, Law And Narrative:  Helping The “Facts” 
To Speak For Themselves 
Erbes, John F., Andresen, J. Scott, White, Christopher, Beneze, Lee, 
Menninger, Karl.  Survey of Illinois Law: Elder Law 
Ermolaeva, Maria.  Crimes Without Punishment: Smith v. Socialist 
People's Libyan Arab Jamahiriya,  101 F.3d 279 (2d Cir. 1996)  .  755 
Fish, David J. The Use Of The Illinois Rules Of Professional 
Conduct To Establish The Standard Of Care In Attorney 
Malpractice Litigation:  An Illogical Practice 
Fitzmaurice, Malgosia.  The Right  Of The Child To A Clean 
Environment 
Flaherty, Michael J., Jacobson, Richard J. Survey of Illinois 
Law: Professional Responsibility 
Flaming, Todd H., Friedman, Benson K. Survey of Illinois Law: Legal 
Technology 
Garwin, Mark J., M.D.  Immunity In The Absence Of Charity: Emtala 
And The Eleventh Amendment 
Gianaris, Jr., Ted N. Survey of Illinois Law: Tort Law
1268  Southern Illinois University Law Journal  [Vol. 23 
Graves, Kathleen A. Affirmative Action In Law School Admissions: 
An Analysis Of Why Affirmative Action Is No Longer The Answer 
..  Or Is It? 
Gupta, Anand.  Patent Law: The Supreme Court Reinforces The 
Validity Of The Doctrine Of Equivalents In  Warner-Jenkinson 
Co. v. Hilton Davis Chemical Co.  ........0.. 000  123 
Hartzler, Joseph.  Keynote Address 
Hoerner, Garrett P., Wigginton, Stephen R. 
Survey of Illinois Law: Civil Procedure 
Lada, Yvonne M.  Something Every Divorce Attorney Should Know 
About Bankruptcy Law 
Latessa, Edward J. What Works In Correctional Intervention 
Lin, Tony.  Distinguishing Kodak Lock-In And Franchise Contractual 
Lock-In 
Massock, Elaine.  Survey of Illinois Law: Employment Law 
Nixon, Christopher T. Should Congress Revise The Tax Code To 
Extend The Same Tax Benefits To Same-Sex Couples As Are 
Currenily Granted To Married Couples?:  An Analysis In Light 
Of Horizontal Equity 
Northrup, Charles J., Layman, Robb H. 
Survey of Illinois Law: Environmental Law 
Pericak, Patrick M.  Using Rule 23(b) As  A Means Of Preventing 
Juror Nullification:  United States v.  Thomas, 116 F.3d 606 
(2d Cir. 1997) 
Peters, Howard.  Mid-day Address 
Redding, Richard E. Reconstructing Science Through Law 
Schmitz, Suzanne J., Cameron, Theresa M., Lueck, Joel E. 
Survey of Illinois Law: Mandatory Arbitration 
Schwartz, Honorable William G. Survey of Illinois Law: Juvenile Law 
Sebastian, Julie Ann, Kaplan, Rosalyn, Price, William A., Rotello, 
Stephen J., Reilly, James M. Beaudet, Matthew W.  Survey of 
Illinois Law: Administrative Law 
Smith, Christopher E. Criminal Justice And The 1997-98 U.S. Supreme 
Court Term 
Stelle, Robert C. Religious Freedom In The Twenty-First Century: 
Life Without Lemon 
Szockyj, Elizabeth.  Jmprisoning White Collar Criminals? 
Sundt, Jody L. Js There Room For Change?:  A Review Of Public 
Attitudes Toward Crime Control And Alternatives  To 
Incarceration 
Whitfield, Wenona Y. Survey of Illinois Law: Property Law
Index 
TOPIC INDEX 
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW: 
Survey of Illinois Law: Administrative Law 
ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION: 
Survey of Illinois Law: Mandatory Arbitration 
CIVIL PROCEDURE: 
Survey of Illinois Law: Civil Procedure 
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW: 
Affirmative Action In Law School Admissions:  An Analysis Of 
Why Affirmative Action Is No Longer The Answer... .OrIs It?  .  149 
Can The Ends Justify The Means?  I!linois Lawyers Trust Fund: 
A Constitutional Analysis 
Do Sexually Violent Predators Deserve Constitutional Protections? 
An Analysis In Light Of The Supreme Court's Ruling In 
Kansas v. Hendricks,  521 U.S. 346 (1997) 
Religious Freedom In The Twenty-First Century:  Life Without 
Should Congress Revise The Tax Code To Extend The Same Tax 
Benefits To Same-Sex Couples As Are Currently Granted To 
Married Couples?:  An Analysis In Light Of Horizontal Equity  .  41 
Students "Stripped" Of Their Constitutional Rights:  Jenkins v. 
Talladega City Board of Education,  115 F.3d 821 (11th 
Cir. 1997) 
CRIMINAL LAW AND PROCEDURE: 
Adult Supervision 
Alternatives To Current Sentencing And Traditional Parole 
Candidates For Public Office Exempt From Drug Testing—Supreme 
Court Rules There Is No Special Need Justifying a Departure 
From Fourth Amendment Requirements: Chandler v. Miller, 520 
U.S. 305 (1997) 
A Case Study In Aftercare: Sponsors, Inc.  ............e0ee. 0ee e 
Crime, Recidivism, Public Perception And The Media 
Criminal Justice And The 1997-98 U.S. Supreme Court Term 
Keynote Address 
Imprisoning White Collar Criminals?  ...............202eeeeeee
1270  Southern Illinois University Law Journal  [Vol. 23 
Is There Room For Change?:  A Review Of Public Attitudes Toward 
Crime Control And Alternatives To Incarceration  ............  519 
Limits Of The Criminal Sanction In Controlling Crime: A Plea For 
I  bob -o'e Vee  eee  Seas  eee  ea  ees  427 
fo  SE  EE  OT  Oe  ee ee  eee ee  375 
Police Discretion And The Redefinition Of Reasonable Under The 
Fourth Amendment:  Maryland v.  Wilson, 519 U.S. 408 (1997).  193 
Recommendations For Legislative, Judicial, And Community Action.  539 
Survey of Illinois Law: Criminal Law and Procedure  .............  901 
Using Rule 23(b) As A Means Of Preventing Juror Nullification: 
United States v. Thomas,  116 F.3d 606 (2d Cir. 1997) .........  173 
What Works In Correctional Intervention  ....................05.  415 
EDUCATION LAW: 
Survey of Illinois Law: Education Law ...................200005  967 
ELDER LAW: 
SUPVSY OT HeNONe LW. BIRO LOW ogc  cece  ees  ccceewewees  1009 
EMPLOYMENT LAW: 
Boys Can No Longer Just Be Boys:  Same-Sex Sexual 
Harassment Perpetrated By Heterosexuals Found Actionable Under 
Title VII:  Doe v. City of Belleville,  119 F.3d 563 (7th Cir. 1997), 
cert.  granted and judgment vacated,  118 S. Ct.  1183  (1998) (mem.); 
Oncale v. Sundowner Offshore Serv. Inc., 83 F.3d  118 (Sth Cir.  1997), 
POO,  TUG  PU TID  oho  ev  ibe  e  cece  ciiee  tess  bactes  239 
Survey ofI llinois Law: Employment Law......................  1057 
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW: 
The Right Of The Child To A Clean Environment  ................  611 
Survey of Illinois Law: Environmental Law  ....................  1105 
FAMILY LAW: 
Something Every Divorce Attorney Should Know About Bankruptcy 
ee 
FRANCHISE LAW: 
Distinguishing Kodak Lock-In And Franchise Contractual  Lock-In...  87 
HEALTH LAW: 
Immunity In The Absence Of Charity: Emtala And The Eleventh
1999] 
RMT ae ee Core. 
INSURANCE LAW: 
Survey of Illinois Law: Insurance Law  ..................00000  1139 
INTERNATIONAL LAW: 
Crimes Without Punishment: Smith v. Socialist People's Libyan 
Arab Jamahiriya,  101 F.3d 279 (2d Cir. 1996) ...............  755 
JUVENILE LAW: 
Community Supervision Of Juveniles  ....................00000  
Issues And Challenges In The Community Supervision Of Juveniles  . 
Survey ofI llinois Law: Juvenile Law  .............0.c 0ee0 e0e e 
LEGAL TECHNOLOGY: 
Survey ofI llinois Law: Legal Technology  ..................... 
PATENT LAW: 
Patent Law: The Supreme Court Reinforces The Validity Of The 
Doctrine Of Equivalents In Warner-Jenkinson Co. v. Hilton 
BR  OTT  Ee ere Tree TEP  Tee  ere 
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY: 
Survey of Illinois Law: Professional Responsibility  .............. 
The Use Of The IIlinois Rules Of Professional Conduct To 
Establish The Standard Of Care In Attorney Malpractice 
Litigation:  An IMogical Practice ........c.ec.e c.ce.se.es s 
PROPERTY LAW: 
Survey of Iilinois Law: Property Law  ............cccccencccess 
TORT LAW: 
Servey of Tiros Law: TOLOW  2.2  cc  cc  esccccecveccesiccss