Royal Power in the Late Carolingian Age: Charles III the Simple and His Predecessors

422 Pages·2019·8.18 MB·English

by  Horst Lößlein

HORST LÖSSLEIN
Royal Power in the Late Carolingian Age
Charles III the Simple and His Predecessors
Horst Lößlein · Royal Power in the Late Carolingian Age
Published by
Modern Academic Publishing (MAP)
2019
Modern Academic Publishing (MAP) is an initiative from the University of Cologne
that contributes to the digital humanities, in the field of electronic publishing. MAP is
led by Prof Dr Gudrun Gersmann, Chair of Early Modern History.
The MAP partners, the University of Cologne and the Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität
Munich (LMU), are funding the open-access publication of selected dissertations and
post-doctoral monographs by humanist scholars of both universities. The main target
of MAP is combining the support of highly awarded researchers at an early stage of
their career with new digital formats of publishing in the humanities.
www.humanities-map.net
Horst Lößlein
Royal Power in the Late
Carolingian Age
Charles III the Simple and His Predecessors
Published by
Modern Academic Publishing
University of Cologne
Albertus-Magnus-Platz
50923 Cologne, Germany
Funded by the Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität Munich
Text © Horst Lößlein 2019
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution BY 4.0. To view a copy
of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. This license allows
for copying any part of the work for personal and commercial use, providing author
attribution is clearly stated. Figures may have different licenses. These will have been
identified in the caption to relevant content.
First published 2019
Accepted as a dissertation at the Université de Limoges and Ludwig-Maximilians-
Universität Munich 2017
Cover image: “Karolus divina propitiante clementia rex Francorum et vir illustris”, detail
of a royal diploma of Charles III the Simple for Saint-Maximin of Trier, issued 1st January
912 at Metz, Bibliothèque nationale de France, Latin 9264 N°12, [03.08.2015], Permalink:
https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b52505561w/f25.image (accessed 31.10.2018), CC0 1.0.
Bibliographic information of the German National Library
The German National Library lists the title in the German National Bibliography; to view
detailed bibliographic information, visit http://dnb.dnb.de.
ISBN (Hardcover): 978-3-946198-48-2
ISBN (EPUB): 978-3-946198-49-9
ISBN (Kindle): 978-3-946198-50-5
ISBN (PDF): 978-3-946198-51-2
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16994/ban
Production & publishing platform provided as part of the Ubiquity Partner Network
Ubiquity Press Ltd, Unit 2N, 6 Osborn Street, London, E1 6TD, United Kingdom
To read the free, open access version of this book online,
visit https://doi.org/10.16994/ban
or scan this QR code with your mobile device:
Meiner Familie

Contents
Preface XI
Summary XIII
Abbreviations XV
Introduction 1
Possibilities and limits of late Carolingian rule 6
The functioning of royal power 9
Analytical approach 17
I. Becoming king: The questions of legitimacy and support 21
I.1 Charles’ claim to the throne 21
I.1.1 Louis the Stammerer’s two marriages 22
I.1.2 The question of Louis’ succession 25
I.1.3 Passing over Charles 28
I.1.4 A Robertian on the throne 32
I.1.5 Carolingian blood matters 37
I.2 Close supporters and distant allies 39
I.2.1 Archbishop Fulk of Reims 39
I.2.2 The network elevating Charles 44
I.2.3 The motives behind the rebellion 50
I.2.4 The cohesion of the network 53
I.2.5 Allies sought within the realm 55
I.2.6 Allies sought outside the realm 62
I.2.7 A network of different layers 68
I.3 Conclusion 70
II. Changes in the political landscape:
From Louis the Stammerer to Odo 77
II.1 Old elites: Louis II the Stammerer 79
II.2 Rival factions: Louis III and Carloman II 89
II.3 New faces on the rise: Charles the Fat 101
II.4 Resistance, integration and rebellion: Odo 111
II.5 Conclusion: Continuities and changes 121
III. Networks of royal power: Charles the Simple 127
III.1 General overview 127
III.1.1 Charles’ itinerary 130
III.1.2 Contacts with distant regions 134
III.1.3 Using diplomas to demonstrate Carolingian legitimacy? 142
VIII Contents
III.2 Breaking it down: Networks of royal power 149
III.2.1 Close associates and allies 151
III.2.1.1 The first years 151
III.2.1.2 Shifting balances 154
III.2.1.3 A new balance 157
III.2.1.4 Lotharingia 162
III.2.1.5 The early Lotharingian network 169
III.2.1.6 A king of two regna? 175
III.2.1.7 The later years 178
III.2.1.8 Liberty of choice? 187
III.2.2 Family and friends 191
III.2.3 The role of the marchiones 205
III.3 Conclusion: The development of
Charles’ network and its dissolution 222
IV. Relations with other rulers 233
IV.1 Creating cooperation: Louis the Stammerer 233
IV.2 Carolingian networks: Louis III and Carloman II 236
IV.3 Structural weaknesses: Odo 240
IV.4 Possibilities and limits of royal power: Charles the Simple 243
IV.5 Conclusion 259
V. The Viking problem 261
V.1 Viking incursions and royal measures
in protection of the realm 263
V.1.1 Going on the offensive:
Louis the Stammerer—Charles the Fat 263
V.1.2 Strategies of containment: Odo 274
V.1.3 Return to the old strategies: Charles the Simple 277
V.2 Diplomatic solutions 281
V.2.1 Dudo’s De moribus et actis primorum Normanniae ducum 281
V.2.2 The treaty of Saint-Clair-sur-Epte 284
V.2.3 Using an old solution in a new way 289
V.3 Conclusion 292
VI. Conflicts, rebellions and the role of trust 295
VI.1 Solving conflicts: The role of interest groups 299
VI.2 Rulers and nobles: Breaches of trust 308
VI.3 Speaking justice: Symbolic acts 316
VI.4 Against the king: Questioning the right to rule 330
VI.5. Conclusion 334
Contents IX
Conclusion 347
Bibliography 353
Primary Sources 353
Secondary Sources 360
Index 395