Record on Appeal (Volume 2)

418 Pages·2016·12.19 MB·English

Table of Contents

Page

Volume I
Pre-Argument Statement .......................................................................... 1
Notice of Appeal, dated October 6, 2016 .................................................. 7
Order of the Honorable Barbara Jaffe, dated July 8, 2016,
Appealed From, with Notice of Entry ............................................... 10
Declined Order to Show Cause and Memorandum of the
Honorable Barbara Jaffe, dated December 23, 2015 ........................ 13
Verified Petition, dated December 2, 2015 ............................................. 15
Exhibit 1 to Verified Petition -
(i) Order of the Honorable Joseph M. Sise,
dated December 17, 2013 ........................................................... 35
(ii) Transcript of Proceedings held before the
Honorable Joseph M. Sise on December 3, 2013 ...................... 36
Exhibit 2 to Verified Petition -
Letter from Arthur Carl Spring to Robert D. Mayberger,
dated May 1, 2014 ...................................................................... 76
Exhibit 3 to Verified Petition -
Order of the Appellate Division, Third Department,
dated July 9, 2014 ....................................................................... 77
Exhibit 4 to Verified Petition -
Decision and Order of the Appellate Division,
Third Department, decided January 30, 2015 ............................ 79
Exhibit 5 to Verified Petition -
Order of the New York State Court of Appeals,
decided September 1, 2015 ........................................................ 80
Table of Contents
(Continued)

Page

Exhibit 6 to Verified Petition -
Letter Brief of Amicus Curiae Laurence H. Tribe in
Support of Motion for Leave to Appeal,
dated May 8, 2015 ...................................................................... 81
Exhibit 7 to Verified Petition -
Letter Brief of Amicus Curiae Justin Marceau, Habeas
Corpus Scholar, in Support of Motion for Leave to Appeal,
dated April 14, 2015 ................................................................... 99
Exhibit 8 to Verified Petition -
Order of the Appellate Division, Second Department,
dated April 3, 2014 .................................................................... 103
Exhibit 9 to Verified Petition -
The Nonhuman Rights Project, Inc. Trust for Tommy,
Kiko, Hercules and Leo, dated November 15, 2013 ................. 104
Affidavit of Molly Polidoroff, sworn to December 5, 2014 ................... 114
Exhibit A to Polidoroff Affidavit -
Photographs of “STC” Sanctuary .............................................. 122
Exhibit B to Polidoroff Affidavit -
Standards for Great Ape Sanctuaries, dated January 2013 ....... 126
Affidavit of Steven M. Wise (“Second Hercules and Leo Petition”),
sworn to January 21, 2015 ............................................................... 198
Exhibit A to Wise Affidavit -
Printout of “Announcement of Agency Decision:
Recommendations on the Use of Chimpanzees in NIH
Supports Research,” dated June 26, 2013 ................................. 201
ii
Table of Contents
(Continued)

Page

Exhibit B to Wise Affidavit -
Brazilian Decision in Portuguese, in In favor of Suica, a
Chimpanzee, dated September 28, 2005 ................................... 238
Exhibit C to Wise Affidavit -
English Translation of Brazilian Decision, in In favor of
Suica, a Chimpanzee, dated September 28, 2005 ..................... 243
Exhibit D to Wise Affidavit -
Excerpts from Brief filed in Appellate Division,
Fourth Department on behalf of Kiko ....................................... 245
Exhibit E to Wise Affidavit -
Excerpts from Oral Argument of Steven M. Wise,
in Appellate Division, Fourth Department ................................ 247
Exhibit F to Wise Affidavit -
(i) Excerpts from Memorandum of Law filed in
Supreme Court, Niagara County on behalf of Kiko,
dated December 2, 2013 ............................................................ 251
(ii) Verified Petition filed in Supreme Court, Niagara
County on behalf of Kiko, dated December 2, 2013 ................. 253
Affidavit of Steven M. Wise, sworn to December 2, 2013 .................... 270
Exhibit A to Wise Affidavit -
Disc of Video of Tommy .......................................................... 273
Exhibit B to Wise Affidavit -
Photographs of Tommy in Enclosure ........................................ 274

iii
Table of Contents
(Continued)

Page

Exhibit C to Wise Affidavit -
Printout of “Announcement of Agency Decision:
Recommendations on the Use of Chimpanzees in NIH
Supports Research,” dated June 26, 2013
(Reproduced Herein at pages 201 to 237) ................................. 276
Exhibit D to Wise Affidavit -
Brazilian Decision in Portuguese, in In favor of Suica, a
Chimpanzee, dated September 28, 2005
(Reproduced Herein at pages 238 to 242) ................................. 276
Exhibit E to Wise Affidavit -
English Translation of Brazilian Decision, in In favor of
Suica, a Chimpanzee, dated September 28, 2005
(Reproduced Herein at pages 243 to 244) ................................. 276
Affidavit of James R. Anderson, sworn to November 20, 2013 ............ 277
Exhibit A to Anderson Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 286
Affidavit of Christophe Boesch, sworn to November 19, 2013 ............. 290
Exhibit A to Boesch Affidavit -
Curriculum Vitae ....................................................................... 304
Exhibit B to Boesch Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 328
Affidavit of Jennifer M.B. Fugate, sworn to November 22, 2013 ......... 330
Exhibit A to Fugate Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 338
Affidavit of Mary Lee Jensvold, sworn to November 21, 2013 ............. 340
iv
Table of Contents
(Continued)

Page

Exhibit A to Jensvold Affidavit -
Curriculum Vitae ....................................................................... 353
Exhibit B to Jensvold Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 370
Affidavit of James King, sworn to November 21, 2013 ......................... 373
Exhibit A to King Affidavit -
Curriculum Vitae ....................................................................... 382
Exhibit B to King Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 391
Volume II
Affidavit of Tetsuro Matsuzawa, sworn to November 23, 2013 ............ 393
Exhibit A to Matsuzawa Affidavit -
Curriculum Vitae ....................................................................... 403
Exhibit B to Matsuzawa Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 417
Affidavit of William C. McGrew, sworn to November 21, 2013 .......... 423
Exhibit A to McGrew Affidavit -
Curriculum Vitae ....................................................................... 435
Exhibit B to McGrew Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 462
Affidavit of Mathias Osvath, declared November 19, 2013 ................... 466
v
Table of Contents
(Continued)

Page

Exhibit A to Osvath Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 475
Affidavit of Emily Sue Savage-Rumbaugh,
sworn to November 22, 2013 ........................................................... 477
Exhibit A to Savage-Rumbaugh -
Curriculum Vitae ....................................................................... 494
Exhibit B to Savage-Rumbaugh -
References ................................................................................. 531
Supplemental Affidavit of James R. Anderson,
sworn to November 18, 2015 ........................................................... 542
Exhibit A to Anderson Supplemental Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 552
Supplemental Affidavit of Christophe Boesch,
sworn to October 14, 2015 ............................................................... 556
Exhibit A to Boesch Supplemental Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 566
Affidavit of Jane Goodall, sworn to September 21, 2015 ...................... 570
Exhibit A to Goodall Affidavit -
Curriculum Vitae ....................................................................... 580
Supplemental Affidavit of Mary Lee Jensvold,
sworn to September 29, 2015 ........................................................... 607
Exhibit A to Jensvold Supplemental Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 613
vi
Table of Contents
(Continued)

Page

Supplemental Affidavit of William C. McGrew,
sworn to October 9, 2015 ................................................................. 615
Exhibit A to McGrew Supplemental Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 626
Supplemental Affidavit of Emily Sue Savage-Rumbaugh,
sworn to December 1, 2015 ............................................................. 628
Exhibit A to Savage-Rumbaugh Supplemental Affidavit -
References ................................................................................. 653
Proposed Order to Show Cause .............................................................. 667
Memorandum of Law in Support of Petition for Habeas Corpus,
dated December 2, 2016 .................................................................. 669
Certification Pursuant to CPLR § 2105 .................................................. 802

vii

393
Affidavit of Tetsuro Matsuzawa, sworn to November 23, 2013
[pp. 393 - 402]
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 12/02/2015 05:12 PM INDEX NO. 162358/2015
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 32 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 12/02/2015
OFFVLTON
J
)
)
)
j
)
OFDlDU )
)
nTY
i was
3.
also the Director of the. C~nl"r for lntcmatjonaj Collaoorati,," ~ml Adlvanc£,d Studies in
394
at
the
ku",Vl) as the""\-pt<Jjecf'
the umlerstalulmg <Jf IIHlTIller,<
I
!
5<'1'£",'"". Jl;1m7Jfl! 1;1/
of
Alllffltml JDwnal