Queering the Public Sphere in Mexico and Brazil: Sexual Rights Movements in Emerging Democracies

315 Pages·2010·8.449 MB·English

by  Rafael de la Dehesa

Contents
Acknowledigxm ents
Prefxaic e
Inotdruction
HybrMiodd eirtniMeosd,eS reunxa li1t ies
*
ParI.Ft r maes
Chapter One
OnS exSuuablj aencPdtu sb lic 2S7p heres
*
ParIItD. oroways
ChapTtweor
OccuptyhiPena igrs tFainle dF:i rDsotoo rnt hLee ft6 1
*
ChapTtherre e
ThLei miLtisba elorifoz nEa:nt tietrhiEenlc get oFriael8l 7d
*
PartP athsw ay
III.
ChapFtoeurr
AdavncHionmgso exCuiaetlni spzh:i
*
BarzsiE la'rTlurynt oL egisl1a1t5u res
ChapFtievre
Liea ftt hMea rngsCi:o alBiutiiloadnni Sdne gx ual
*
Diveirntsh iMete yx ican L1e4g6i slature
viiCio ntents
ChapStiexr
Barzwiilt hHooumto phoorAb,T i ecah,on criact
*
AlternPaotliivPteaii rctetao1sl 7 8
Conclusion
ThHeo paen Fde oafIrs n titu2t0i4o ns
*
Acronyms 219
Note2s2 1
Bibrlaipoh2gy4 7
Idnex2 87
Acknowledgments
A grenautm boefpr e ophlaevc eo nbturtiteodt hceo mpleotft ihoins
preocjItw .o ludp atricluyll eiat krot haJnokrD goem giunefrzoh ipse da­
gogiecaxamlp elnec,ao egumrenatnp,da tiienrna ecdei enxgt enesairvley
darftosft hwiosr aksw, el alst hoet hmeerm beorfms yd isserctoamt­ion
mittGezree,g oErkzita e nrSdt evLeenvk iyft,ros t hegiurain dcaen sdu p­
porSte.v epreaolhp alvbeee ekni nedn outgroh e aandrd e sptovonra di ous
parotfts h wiosr Ikw .ou lldei t kot haRnikc dhP aarrkReosra,l Pientd­
cheysB,k ayrA rdma,P aiyCs ulrerJaahmG,er se Beenr,e BneincCtealo u,d ia
HnioojsPae,g Lgeyv Litista, MJoeoarAnem ,i lBcaaerrtr aon,Dd e banuj
Dasgufropt thaee inro rsmlohyue lpfeefudlb aMcywk r.i tgirnoigunN pe w
YorkC ithyab se coamnie na vluasbplafecro ce r eaetxicvhe.a wnoIgu eld
leit kot hafnlekwl m oembeGarrcsMe .C hoJ,e aHna lyA,ln eanMyuak her­
jaeS,a aldvVoirad l-OHrotsKiuiz m,S, u ngY oHoekae,n Rdo Nne rTiomo y.
deafirre nGdar cMe. CIoh wose p eciaslf ro h tehilanpmngek fi nfdma iyl
ancdo mmiutnIya .l oswoae p atricduelbattroM ariaWnifvnees sforon
hefree dbaacnfkdir end;As dhriiPpaanlf mroa mahneyl pcfuonlsv taeirons
ovecroe ffeO;m aFrle iacniforo h iesm otisounpapalon ridtn sidguhrt­s
ing mouftc hthei mIwe a cso ndurcetsicenhaag;nr Mdic haYearlb rough
frot hceo mpanisounpsphaoinrpidt,n , t elelxecchtahuneagg nleee rously
offerwehdiI lc eo mtpeltdeh bioso k.
Thipsre ocjgta vmeet eho pporytt uomn aikaten umboefnre fwir ends
anmde ecto alglueienBs ar zainlMd e ximcaoyn,o fw hocmo ntributed
byp rodviinmga teraingadel nse yro offeursiltnhget iirmI ew .ou lldei k
tot haanltklh p ee opIi lnevt ieeerdwt,o moa ntyon amBeu.t M eixni Ic o
woulpda rltraillcyeiut kot haCnecki Rliiqau ewlhmoeyse,ea irtnse ha cvt­i
ismto evmeanrte s orauc oefi nsaptiitroomn e a,n Yda Mna rYiaoayl 6otl
,CastArnotn,oiM oe diEnnaoU,er anDgaav,Si adn cChameazc hMoa,n uel
OropezaJ,i mPeaTntirernzaii,dGad u tieJrorRseaezm ,oE nni rquDeazny,n
CoheEnd,gS aarn cAhderzi,Oa rntOair zt ,e gaJanudaC nav raa.jlIw aasl so
x Acknogwmleesnd t
frotuneantoeut goph a ritpiaictntew coo urisnte hGsee ndSetru dPir­eos
graamtt h Nea tiAountnaoolm oUunisv erosfMi etxyit choa,tn otk hswe el ­
comIre e cefiorvmGe ldo Craieraa; gh aer adviocnye e,a rbsa soefd scholar­
shiapnad c vtsiimI,g reaatplpiyra etFceot.rh gee nseyirt tohyee xntdeed
int eromfts i mree,s ouarncgdeu si,de ai nnBc raIzw ioull pda rltrailcyu
leit kot haBnektd oeJ esCulsai,uoN d ascimReongteDori,in Joiu zn queira,
VirngiFiai gueWiirleldAioga,um iP aaruM,la or iaDnotleeosR,r o drigues,
RoberdteOo li veSivira,lEa u egniIoba ipiRnioCt,ea r qauQ euiaordsSr,e r­
giCoa rra,ra anHdo raScioivr.oMi yr eseianSr acalhdv oorw eass pecial
thasn kLtuoiM zo tTth.wi osr ekn tarielseedia narn cuhm boeflr ia brries
anadr vcseha,in Idw oupladr tliylc eiut kloaa crkwnloedtghheee lIrp e ­
ceifvoremdt haec tiavnisdst taasfftt hAer quEidvagor Lde uenarto th,
thUen viresyio tfC ampiGnrauspG;oa yd aB ah;Gi rauAproc- roIidse
ConscieHnotmisozsaec;lxRa;uedo ae U rnO uotO rlhFaunrd;a c;Paeor seu
AbarmoC;e ntdreIo no frmadc;aMa uo lhCeern;At craod emdieEc sot udos
HomeorotdiaUc novisre siddaeSd aePo ua lAos;s ocBiaraisc;laaeIo itn rer­
discidpeAl IiD;nCS aerno td reD ocmuentac;eMa eom orUinvaire,s idade
doE stadedS oa Poua lCoe;n otd reI nofrmacyDi oocnu mendteal casi on
HoomsexuaelniM deaxdiIecgson aAclaiverozL ;e trCae ndterEo s tudios
s;
deMlo vmiieonO tberrSoo cit;aaB liiibosltReacfaGa aeallnv I;n suttdioet
EstudIiRaoe sov lduecD ieomnoa ctriFcunad;a cion CDoolnoCasoli­doo;
municeaI cnoifromna cdieIo Manu e jrA,C. . a;nt dh Reec uperNaunedaso t r
Hitso:rA irachHiitvsoor Liecsobd ieMc eox ico.
Sevefirreanlad nsfdma ilmye mbpeorrvsdi eidvna luaebmloet ional and
intelsluepcptaouswra eltlAl t.t hrei osffkro egttsionmpge e opIwl ouel,d
leit koe xprpeatsrisc ulastr oM atrhiaanc keMdGeeorsm eEzl,i Baongree s
BeurtJtois,e M aLrutiLzie nsss aJ,o rAMgleedn odd eaSs vi alM,a rQiuoe i­
roRzam osH,e rcQuulienst aOnsiclGahoran ,z aSlaaeldzvo,Cr r uKzey,l l
SilfiLeeosn,Mo crniet yDroen,nJ aa rTveriessR,aaff a elalniCd, hr istian
GonzaIwl oeuzll.dei t kor ecnoigtzhele o avens du ppIor retc efiorvme d
mym ot,hL eyirL livatkt;h oupgohs thuymJ,o auiLsmivlekat ,w hoh elped
mee normyo unisanlva itgitnhUgeN AMR;os ain Mda nuAek;lsm yc ousin
KarAeknas ,nL du pReam ier.zF inasnucpipafolrotr htpi rseo cjftor mH a­r
varUdni verasnPidSt -CyCU NYg reafcatiiltlya ittcesod m tpiloeIan l.es xo­
tenmdyt hastn okR eynoSlmdisat nhtd h e astDt uaekffU nviresyiP tress
frot hesiurp paonrwdto roknt hpirseo cjt.
Preface
ArujnA ppad(u1r9ah9ia6 as)r gutehdta otu nedrstlaoncedax lps rieosns
otfr ansnsamytbioolnaiacclt -ipacrnedts on avitghaceto em palneaxl ytic
terrbaeitnw heoemneo ngizaatniddoi enffr enicnge l obaoln-ioznaet i
must cboontsthih degeinerre ayla ongtdh ehiirsy tt,o hfrero meirn vvionlg
theeov lutoifaol no chaalb itthulesa ,tt taekrii tnesgm bedndeesidsna
broaudnievre irnsateco c notAu.sI s uggients hte ptahgfaloetols w t,h ese
twsot raonftd hspe a sittne rsienmc utl tainprdler ecfa tewday As c.o m­
paraatpipvreot aosc ehx puoalli itnLi actAsim ne riIb ceavl,,ei p eermits
newwa ytsoe xpelt ohreeinrt anegnlte.m
Ic hotsoweo r ki nB raazniMdle xifrcos oe verreaalsB oontcsho. u ntries
havtew oof t hleag reastno dl dLeGsBtmT o evmenitnLs a tAimne rica,
antdh feca tth aactt ievmiegsremid nt hceo ntoefux ntuu asylp lrotracted
transittoli iobnesr al dreemgoicamrleapsst eoir cm ciltocsso en sideration
oft hiene trlpabye tweemeergnni gl bierianls titauntadic otnisvin setg­so'
tiaetnetidrn oyft romadle moactpriocl iMtoircesop.vaa erlrli eanl cst ivists'
contactthspe a writtlihesp ftae nr mainet x palitoornc hoafn gsienxgu al
politictsh sawetic attswho eilrn lI .na llt hoerfse es paec cotmspa,at irve
approsahcenhde swl igohnht o wa ctiivsi scmh iann githneg context of
thber oardeesrt ruocftt huperu ibnslgpi hce Breec.ao ufts heec iern tral
plaicnte h hesi toorfay c tiivnei asccmho uyna tnrmdy c oncweirttnhh e
areonffaro maplo liptairctsli,ayc tt u hlneaa rtiloeenvlma,ylr eseaalrscoh
fcouspersi myoa nrm iaoljru rbcaenn :tM eerxsiCciotyR ,i doe J aneainrdo ,
SaPoau loA.s a c onseqmuyea nccceou,un ndptel radyyasnm iicnssm aller
cities aarneTdaos s or.mue erx atIlet nrtit eocd o mpaetnferost htihsr ough
shovritsi ivntosnl vgri eseoaurtcshoi ftd hee csiet iMeesx.i tchIoiin ns ­
cludseiwdxee kosffi ewlodriknt hset aotfVee rac(rrpuizm yai rnti hle
PorotfVe rcaruaznt dh cea pciytio atfXl a labpuat, i ansl hsovori tst iot s
CordCoabdrae,al n,Od r izaibnBa r)a;Izt iolos kht oertrr i(posn et wtoo
weelkosn tgoo) t hceirt, ii necsluPdoirAntloge gRreec,iSa fleva,d aonr,d
xiiP rfaece
Brsaialw,ih reela lcsoon deudic ntvtieerawnspd e rfolrimemediad tr cvahli
reesacrh.
Myw orbku iolnde sxt enrseisrvecieahne accho uync tornducted dur­
inagp eroifoo vde nirn yee ars, sienvcelnmutodenietnohngfsfi eldwork
inB raz(aiJlun arayn Adu gustF ebrytu ahorrugNho evmb2e0r;0 1
199;9
Maya nd mNboev2re0 ;0J 2anyu aarJnuyd2l 00J6u;n2 e0 0a7n)sd ix teen
montihnMs e xi(cuJon e Aprtiholru gDhe cem2boeo;Jr ou nteho rugh
199;9
Ju2l0y;0 J 2un20e0 5J;u n2e0 0;A 6ugu2s0t0A 7u;g u2s08t0) I.nb otcho un­
triIce osn duecxtteednas ricvheir evseaaclr h aann udm boefirn -depth
itneerviws.T og eats enosfte h leag repro liltaincdaslIci anpvteie,er wed
nojtsu t activbiuasttl sps ool itpiacrmatilyl itsatnatotsffie,c iarllese,­
LGB T
vnata ll(ieefmsi nAiIsDtaSsc ,t ihvuimsatrnsi ,ga hcttsi jvuoirsntas)l,,i sts
anpdo litopipcoaennlt (sn iclumdeimnbgsoe frt hNea tiAoctniaPolan r ty
in Mexiecavon gaenlldai wcmaalik nBe arrzsli )Ia. s kaecdt iavbiosutts
theoiwrni nvmoelvnweti tthhm eo evmeanntsd p ecyia fibcoaiultatlsr ­
ticulawtiittohhn iesn ternatairoennpaaol,l itpiacratllieg esilsat,u r,ea snd
thes ttaeIi nvtieerwpeadrm tiytl ainatnsad l lwiheoes i thhaeadrh s itory
.
ofi nveomlevwnittL hG BaTcv tiisatnsd dtehmeaiornr dw se roet herwise
liendtk op artainssdat na te inosfst eicttruoetrepiasrolen nst (astuicohn
asw omenc'osm misasnisdoo ncmsio aevlm esnetc rtestI)anar. lIi cl ao n­
duct13ei9dne trviweiwt1s2h r6 ep sondeinnM tesx iacn1od2 i9n vtieerws
withr sepondienBn rtazsIi nal d.d ittoti hoeinsn eetr viIec wosn,d ucted
113
exntsveie prriemasarecryih na rchibveelso ntgiosn ogc ial moorvgeam­ent
nizatani uomnbsoe,fir nv diidaucavtlii swthswoe rkei nedn outgooh p en
their pfieltreossm o epn,oa lli ptairctuainlvei ress,i rteileisig,ni sotuist u­
tiomnesd,oi raag naitziolengsi,s laanstdtu arateegesn ,c Tiheisas.r cvahli
resecaormcphl etmheienn tvtsie emrwa teIrg iaatlht eotr heeedx ttehnatt
irtel fectthssei tupaetresdvp eeoscfv t airipooulsia tcitcooavrleas rn e x­
tendhseitdo orfLy GB Tm obiliizna twiaoyinstn etrhvaisteh wasp,e d by
triocfmk esm yoo rrc urrpeonltic toincsaild emraanyt oito.n s,
Iwnr ittihbniogso Ika ,mv ermyu cahw atrheta htwi rsi tiiisnt gsa enl f
acotfr epnretsiAenngd. gmiyvc eonn cweirttnhh l ei moifrt esep sren­
taotniI,t hiniks iittma pfnorotmr et oa dedsrcse rtcahiiocnIe m sa de,
theliirm ainttdsh ,re es aonbse hitnhdeP me.r hmaopsistmp ortmayn t,
discuisnts hiwioosnr iksd eciyds etadtle-ceTnhtieisrnie tds.re ialsfe s
an umboefqr u estpiaornltsai,rac lbuyoh uotwt hsiosor fta nyaslciasn
prievghieel egmonaincnd a orwru nderstoafpn odliinatgnissdce sxl uia­
tiso err eitfyoi tzailancgc ooufnn tatiso Wnh.ep nr eenstmiynw gor kf,ro
eaxmpIlh ea,vo ec casyib oeneaansl kwlehde tihite"s reb tetrt"ob eg ay in
BrzaiolrM exiIrc seop.o wnidta ch e natalrs sumgputiidotinhdn eig s cus­
sitohnfa lotwl so:t htahte arerme u ltMiepxlieac nomdsu ltBiarpzlaienl ds
thaqtu alificsautciahos" n ebstt era"n d" worsoeri" dn eetdh sea lniceeo f
ac ategsourcyah s" gadye"p encdursc iyao lnlo nsep 'ositiinao s no cyi.e t