Table Of Contenti
ee
per book, not from thng, however, cannot bversion for attribution. OOOOnnnn tttthhhheeee GGGGSSSSiiiihhhhaaaaoooonnnnuuuuttttssssllllddddeeeerrrrssss ooooffff
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit New Approaches to Numeracy
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the Lynn Arthur Steen Editor
been recompd breaks, heaease use the Mathematical Sciences Education Board
ginal work has ne lengths, worally inserted. Pl National Research Council
the original; liccident
n of e orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a NATIONAL ACADEMY PRESS
ogiai Washington, D.C. 1990
Aboriret
ii
ee
per book, not from thng, however, cannot bversion for attribution. NNoraNesfaAOps StooiTTcocrTIitIineC aOhwantEeleNce :RerNt AehsTea, eLsh ctt eihebh oaA orepnros CcraNeaohlAnd aj RCe tDcficeooootEsrun met Mnathahmlcar eYictAuli h,irn c sP wisCa ttRpdyhhoee Eeouocm snSisfea uycSs libm c loc j i2eefwoe 1cmnmEat0c snbp1eo geeo faCrit rnstengho nedaainecs rntrees eiirts zncedi.etghprdua,no twaorbitnoly nowdn gtf hatrAyhsoe ev mwaN epIi nanttphhtusri etooeti htv,ncu eeoaNt dlueA W Anboccycf aiW a dlMtsdeh aemoeesmdf hyG ity'cihson i eovnpg feeNut r.oSr anpTnctioi,inho esDgenne cCsaaB eluo o st2Afah 0 ircfon4duar 1 1rsdot 89ehofm1 eft 6hrty- hetoe
al pamattiative icniegs k dneotwerlmedingeed a bnyd tahdev Aisicnagd ethmey f,e tdheer aCl oguonvceirl nhmase nbte.c Foumnec ttihoen ipnrgin icni paaclc oorpdearnatcien gw aitghe ngceyn eorfa lb poothli -the
e origincific forauthorit Nttheareet igdoo njvoaeilnr Antlmyca ebdnyet m,b toyht eho pfA uScbcaliidecen,m caenised sa tnahdne d tsh ctehi eeNn Iatnitfsiiotcint uaantle dA oecfna Mgdienemdeeiycr iionnfeg E. cDnogrmi.n Fmereuarnniniktgi Pe isrn.e sTpsrh oaevn Cidd oiDnurgn. c sRielo rivbsi ecaredt smM tio.nis-
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the WneBCvLOmaioainehtbraiwa inortrtthdesiaTDencce g raohaaaoe iylsfellrvef heo soeSttMC hovchlfccoeu iepIIoehiaCeSnp rel. ratgndN vcpmBnhocirceilrocenmaaeNueemremrtnwgsdsnia. s tao r0etat oeo,nEiaens-t drofi3n sp ad. cabuns0gduluanic 9i bCboRlcdaaa -llfatSs neaii0 ivtcsoNstocti4iesaeoaginc2e steanlre:i sw3onarf o mcno4Bgpccn hYerh-euheo, 8 w saianiCaaoc nil(tErn rralo hgadkm dcdlsupa-, .a t ur ianrdpNupTnedcncirdaf-hsabao,iePbe sltteoarr.iineiu eeocuolomtisnbhnnnstbpyc ei ldasaBneies l)ectfc a so rRoatat tvoaaiirtlevoa irnl mso dnentdleinl eu oa yawoiv mtnrnD,fhea cs doeelstah sherfm mt e.a xiCa tsscaTah. toydtebahiu e cboe/Nn slo hLBic akseeiytohl driw.neoaeuinrdnecnd ara iA edltnr i eoRr so1tp unhen9op suo8arperttn5a so nSd rrtdce totieiehcs rdepe eCcn srcboos,ot yalnveuy rcidani detl icoeygtrion rlatrar.ehe ndc;ef tol MweGnfcrtioaotit nhtvmthhu eme eirtnmnhagietanhtg-i-
been recompd breaks, heaease use the Q51A31'.037.1N01.5a 0Mt37i oa31nt—9ha9eld 0mRcae2ts0iec 9asr0—c-h4S 1Ct5uo6du6yn acnild ( Ute.aSc.h).i nMg—athUemniatetidc aSlt aStceise.n Ic. eSst eEednu, cLaytinonn ABrotahrudr., 1941- . IIC.IP
ginal work has ne lengths, worally inserted. Pl CCpsyrooompvjeeymPrcr:eiteg etrArdhmi tcfc ia©rsools m mip1oip9 nefu9c oft0eueos rrrb.-- ygldCi eimtrmnheieeaetre tnNaedstd aier otdebinp oyiarnm loTa dsahlp guoAaecmc ctoieaaof,ds nat eB h moteaof y nrtpo ucoorhsfur o t(sSitf ohfcd neiaies vnsn iuoddcrf eeNf stsah icacieslhl o obolfofa o ast k hdT rofehoueorg-m dehdipnmusuocet-annst shiaioaton pnBaearldl o p swfupigrnapu cUorees nie)in.sv t Weobr uthswtie tnnyoo.t
the original; liccident ftuotri osanl eA mveanyu be,e NgrWan, tWeda osnh irnegcteoinp,t DofC a 2 w04ri1tt8e.n request to the National Academy Press, 2101 Consti-
n of e orien a AvenCuoe,p NieWs o,f W thaissh rienpgotrotn m, DayC b 2e0 p4u1r8c.hased from the National Academy Press , 2101 Constitution
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b PFSTFireohricuisnrotrtd tnePh ddPr P iriPninrnrti iinttnnihtngtieing, n Ug,Sg ,Dne ,J piJeutatcenenedmeum S1abbtr9eaye9rtr e91 11s99 9o999f404 America
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
PREFACE iii
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. Preface
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit Today's headlines are filled with reports of illiteracy, innumeracy, and
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the oeiointictntnhhhvfte h ea aiwimmmdmtsen reagaaasFt wnattpteeohhhcsui lprlieeveegilgrcnm mm eohoen sbatsafsaa t,c eo ta ttriihi ardceccoceenprnasssf esd,yo, ac as it'sahiestusotnsne dahsi i dsdttnabuesoac n g lccbmihewcaibinl,noeete yo aingo s o ryiifcc lnrfn sopceio d,ieaworr, wte onl mw etaeifc'os nsdopdeeb m d nu u.eel meuncoitIgineadamdrniurerrynel sonsveyaa. ,t nweri ls tatldo Taath 'cish.wsbpneo y iulpEs nm .ebwtctlkvho,ijho ca eei orstaiyacnrin otllt o vis lsmlaow oso.tts n—hhla T' usstaeewh h,mbv seiesoifsedomsc uu ieiwhvctoltamu oaonotfmrionolosreculk rgo.ssprm r reortiaFefeoosocp fo v taeshpoermnici irdfdg ctafa teineschvibk ,nritfie eefsis eic ai cerfmeintfadnirdiivdenlaucl,eeal tgrce t seiashsdvconmctoe hiniahsio eat lwwioinn nootfoi—tahgnotnalyheessrl,
been recompd breaks, heaease use the MpexriapotrhreiIestnimse estadh ti iissct htaovlr oosSultuicgmmiheu nel fcairevteesea idEmvedriaugsg cniwaenttaiitloteli nsvf eiBtn htdhoa iatna rk dilvi lni(usgMsi toarSnbaE toeoBu ft) d ttiodhfmfeeec roiredircnreohtd wn pet'hsos sasc stu oibrofrl niemce u aslottuhfrm aetnmo.ddasat iyoc'ssf
the original work has ginal; line lengths, worccidentally inserted. Pl slhelnaicxiumnghpmghoiltuoleoaiarrlgteo ighom ueitnsd sas eait mhainonesdfat m egwprsiarcinctetoiiahscent esnidnnv.c eeteeT ec septhcixo eohrafsnoo mesoop ptplassalat entpioesnder r hnr tscohcs u oweer maxrmnipmcdaau tonlhandaer. me oiT dnaihe tneitatchysraeo. l dd tTsouhc,hce ieemehd noe caw euboestyfhv woemarri ,sat h btshorwueiugeemtgf r ceaeeo tsistnca scsstah keyarre onsd tu thfghotaohert
n of e orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
PREFACE iv
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. mtaphpararpottrh uooeTgafmhhc a ehaf teonpisrcaa matptlioae o lrni msdsa ceali hantdhos i etoahmclli oaasagn ntvu idcoeb sc le uoo cmnluld ereemgr vieacae rutlseholt aeupi mdneiydtnae. tnitfcdhrseoe d men d aeusxicn taa fcto iveromnenht auislcrt yilmec. huTtiollhad esthe toidvmo odbulu ylam eatxee p scleiotrrserieeaalsttfii ovoinesf
pnv recent publications:
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit • MEavtehreymboadtiyc s CEdouucnatst:io nA Report to the Nation on the Future of
s been recomposed from XML files created from thord breaks, heading styles, and other typesetting-spePlease use the print version of this publication as the ttnoWspbhhaeefrea monce tmge eo psosrfnTAAalhaisfe(cid:127)(cid:127)(cid:127) tltfamao llhyes ettrkud ehh risCSefoCll m R ooidynctftuveuuuhhe ia nreheirwggasettnr roneoihthhspihcv ilrcgeacr copaamofee ueepul sitl ftat tvl ilosvfhlhhunuicoseieueseeebmcghmr c sm reii a tpUl e Alx ea yiSetotnwtalnshhn scislcsmeiee difshetaAdnsr sie osvpyobE.eemod oil ml Avtt eaeveil Spaan sn, rpaalu t l dMiisarapatubcttio dtyrhraealaedet ovi itthnsstac esypiihp tesona fcr rier ivtomenedineimaios f onsiStuu tltaaneesdouitslnt nvtsaairemrcivd ettencasueepi e sndedr dorr:c dardxoue firiisre ccscvaiAnm,dt veouli i tsdrleqtmlahle chaPeleuftefoh iohm nhelsf poareeo c iwe m ivmclerSpcnoctoo cerietadstorlnohohsnotuakngi ve otptmc sm o i iohoistboodfsew.alyfon fet , t eMl detshoonthna n henacef tntbmet oeawtyhdyhya rl-ae ne aftaa csiFmudimbrrncuct serrahdhsrautoa r t o onceramiciioegccrydmde,resule un twasnleaactdapguatidoai neicrsvtrbnvylcihtkiyourait s sir wnttehcniui f.orvtoaiaomsslnesrstl..
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted. OCpCrouvemresriridmacleulint,l tute tmeho ef iCBnvcoeolmllulu dmmCeidoet tmewWem aauscd nhediac eiarEvteeildolli onsps,b eyRJd r e.H useenoandfr recyWrh .t OehOse.t t hPaVeuoras lllpmlaeikcey,em sCrb eeootriflsrl ee todghf ee ; at h1sAsi9sin8s tdA9ar ndeMtvw iS svoEiMcrBye.
the original; liccident GLelesaliseo nP aoofl eHttai rvoafr dC Uhonaivtee rsRitoys;e mMaarryti nH Dal.l ; KArunstkhaoln yo f RParlisntcoent ono f Utnhiev erSstiatyte;
on of he orieen a UInnsitviteurtsei tyo f oTf ecNhenwol oYgyo;r ka nadt ZBaulfmfaalno ; UIssiasdkoinre oSf inthgee rU onfi vethrsei tyM oasf saCchhiucsaegtots.
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b eSTionafohc cueethhsnp eSedtm i ieionenavnsgidesn inaaB vn yei"odsdsSas uforaaaodysulr ,sn c tk dhaodeinenene dsspgvei i soornBtvnlegueoed m ia mttro eodofu sn cpeI" hsxrt raow aaodgmcefor kreirten.hes es eeSe stcdithnra—eegb deloliiristnn haefkeon sdfrd o w hbrZe iytalt hphlt iehUns ecgos i vMiessenhkSrcaivEnepi.;eeB w Ff tohto orerp "ar"vDepPoveialimrute,tm weeorne nnsd e"airo ta tfnfhiot,te"ssr
neagap David Masunaga of the Iolani School
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
PREFACE v
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. iKoBBnfree ilyHNtlin soeLehwns ao boClYoufo rlotaulhrut keoma rUnaibedtins a i S;Jv ateeonafrndonsy ir t JyTaB "amorSyfoehl ooMsak rp i;Sen ow,fn"fo e irfRs tBo "utorUtaagf nn aekcNnresoda r ntUAaaGinilnmaritüvnyone ,T "brsS auiJeuctaynmkm;ie o refr soo o rfSfL et"ahctQnhoedeu nS wadtnaUeatrhtinyetryi vU,So"efnc r hisHAvioteayoTrr lsv& ieoitTnyyf
pnv Washington and Paula Fitzmaurice of Victor J. Andrew High School in Tinley
al pamattiative Park, Illinois; and for "Change," Robert Devaney of Boston University and
e origincific forauthorit Lvoelsulime e Pcaoonlesitstit.e dT ohfe WSiclileianmtif iOc . SBoauknedri, nrge tiBreoda rcdh awirmhiacnh orfe vBieewll eLda bthoera teonriteirse;
s been recomposed from XML files created from thord breaks, heading styles, and other typesetting-spePlease use the print version of this publication as the MeghttvMcmSctchohehchooohegienoaSaawloli ieuulrtlnlErdaeullltemr oeeeh MPdnBirvianmnycievdneue esegg art ieibrissHr oc unee,calie- Fe dmyisassoiseic tl o b ttlxoapalao. isdx o amntptfri foR i,swu ol crt olf tphetfice ph fini gfrsetu,omtreeo o hhsh porrsrUof v fpetrcofeett ufie oeihonsd fc nulUmds srerilu ttgssovt iih bhnlabesoa meuriyeitnnulrserovimem t tsntsnnte sohtivphg taah rt fonoooyeisutte cntrhiei iln ibh ostarou aswebys .ietnnhfmcmoirhe b keeColgiaeaMoidvssnef il att ng inoivircSlvetSMceynawiyoowoofiEw ni loamlilnuavedBesunf rgtnervsopsdnm s s do irlgM i;osea tiue eftoinfat s otoroI ae hgnaoiT trMnts re hd s a; BeBmw ea otStt eha othpefdheEm Kkn eareoueitmkB drlh iaateednef etaon m ih ltGi tdruswretsnheashaeai tye tmerue tves or.1ehm t aiipfach9aeeCdr htatcrom8wdeilievthacyr5ta i eaiyssasc D,segr te t ls isweodfl te ce.ooeten iib s hndndtTrdou rhemag uukeioextcnntecac eh uposebuauarhmer rlttep t,ray e o iM i oaoarswp frctdyfaglsnshruSw oe i or,elrEw adruftab otkhtet Bodymoeefo sei is rf onshf .ku tC fomtfh oh lhin rhS ceatweoi ethfaumnnhehooxr iilddkaeeesfrrtt,
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted. ahpinpua pvrepremoo ipsnperhhi aoeatrsfei it zmetidona tgfho reuotmhrm eac tpoiimrcmespv.p oiuTorthuteaisrsn gcaveegon eloe urtfmha tareiono io nstt shit nhefgoe a rd crwiiutrhrehrmcoictm eurt elicacsaru- bllcrto ueuoflnaof tdrSim ohsn itr irwlnue caytts'hus ertphe esee r mpsthiresiartmteg niawncrgyee
the original; liccident practiCcoe oorfd minaatthioenm aatnicds .production details have been ably managed by the
on of he orieen a MthaSnEkBs astraef fd uleed Lfiirnsdt ab yR oMseanrc, iaw hSow asrhde pahnedr dneodw w biyth Kuennfnaieltihn gH gooffomda nh.u mSpoerc iaalll
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b tdGipDelerlacooutvhadvsiinstildrdeisaecy et ad ioClow fn ebahsrays ovrp stofTewoenc hroet tos,re t kmnha,oae afcg sc i rvotpaByoprd lyoauuan damnceutdehdce oit.t ipsfiotfanMun tgdi aue,en fcnnrdahcotn e mDd ao t waf p tvBehrtiroherdeo de w uMiinnccnivotot iiaomoUalrnlupen .a,u ip vbtTwleelaehrrin -satgnhiintnei ykn ns.sgc pe Fo reaalmicllntiseeaeaocdlel t l tiyasinan,urg regpt t wshptd hrooouterroue tk gm ffJhrwiaaoonnnamuayaslt
neagap the many drafts of the
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
PREFACE vi
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. dtdyiifprfeiecnLrtge Ye nlNate nNcedt sr AoscRanoyiTrcsrH ,em UcMteRiaoa nSnrsTys. EnKEeNacy,e sEsPDaeIrTtyeO rtsRoo ne nmabalnea gthede fwinitahl teefxfitc iteon cbye aplrlo dthuec edT EbXy
al papmattinative v ST. OLAF COLLEGE
e origincific forauthorit
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the
been recompd breaks, heaease use the
s orPl
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted.
the original; liccident
n of e orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
CONTENTS vii
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. Contents
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the DQUPaiunmtTJDLacteanehyearrmtnnonvtinastmeiyidi sonAa nStTsry .t.F h MFu. eorBy oaSrnteecehnoff 1691151
been recompd breaks, heaease use the ShaMpeajorie Senechal 139
ginal work has ne lengths, worally inserted. Pl BCihoaIganrnga epShteiewsart 128139
the original; liccident Index 223
n of e orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
CONTENTS viii
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution.
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the
been recompd breaks, heaease use the
s orPl
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted.
the original; liccident
n of e orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
PATTERN 1
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. Pattern
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit Lynn Arthur Steen
osed from XML files created from thding styles, and other typesetting-speprint version of this publication as the cteEehocMhxoyxanaeapmsbp c ntlelhrbgopodra "TornrurenHoeaonetmls.atwb etd ifbiaSro itscnonhijn jeilo utiesioe.a trt t soeifty Itn p nNn ,asgd tu srenfoE ibatartsa rhmaslwdcebnie,cicox edm ttS vipra lfotartyoeulo henssrn rWn.vety tNj ehseat cinoeoea eet Ko relnini cntpaneohttrleeurghv eew,nrr a aaryahsi nlt s t eeio de dav non;todles h onemeeknaenwenxytb a ei a srroip,omneet farantlss ahytprt m tce e ldeoetaoa nri fssfnnnfea f usywliemg unm rra eiescearcdb.bxlnte"huhoerct daierwmeaT ,mepw lohah taatfaieiienhn otttq ihm desncums ,asua aif ladmpttbo ihtaeosjrohoereac tneemsecsimms etnt , anota traetioAttfeiatrih fcicsrllG cea taeasimtlnnea h fo twnoadiilTnsrstyrih gisc u,cdoc r oriefCBio iagupnmb nanerlbgrsnitniaoe nht trooaksoeetkitno.esrrt, .
been recompd breaks, heaease use the Mtoinauutatogst hihndetee miw npa utftihibceelsli ,dcs si cn vha iontehodwel ,ss cpumoabmwajtemnhcietonsmng o a lfnta iecaywsr i v tchaieopmwnpetl,iti nicicsua, et aigso esntotosam. t giTecrt hordeywi ,sg caauiltpig dlaeie bn rretaao p,b itaadhsn iesdrd a gc teorao,nl cw sufptolhrure msia.sd u Binlnaougstt
n of the original work has e original; line lengths, woren accidentally inserted. Pl csce—bhexaonlaptuchptanuueendMlr .daia heTteariisisdtohe-ht—neoose lrmoasdiicncnf a h dtpitbotoi esfco orogsusl rrp nhomeedaumcuasptl pri ativthreshaeas ebd.s oouiiBstrfti y uooam tnnna aan aoaltdslhpr y iesett hmthbnaeme-at eeittsennietctd iriscdcre ise dhta,so anscirvnedryeiat bo greaec exoldholpp mlfabtooisumerr ttet rphiddzyae ai t bsittssaieyco pr dinnepme .neeaacapnterhlde ye od cmfr.o oSnanotuotitrmce ohidlaba ntievhnsree tahothnhariydess
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
