mediators arbitrators & adjudicators 2015

89 Pages·2015·1.92 MB·English

by  Denver Siebritz

MEDIATORS

ARBITRATORS
&
ADJUDICATORS

2015

THE SOUTH AFRICAN
INSTITUTION OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

1
2. PROCEDURE FOR THE APPOINTMENT OF A MEDIATOR
(In terms of clause 61(2) of the GCC – 1990/2004/2010

The Panel of Mediators is available to parties in a dispute to select a mutually acceptable mediator. They
are advised that if they follow that route, the mediator selected should be a person known and
acceptable to both parties. If the parties are unable to select someone, the President of the South
African Institution of Civil Engineering will, upon request, nominate a mediator in terms of clause
61(2)(a).

To enable the President to nominate a suitable person, the following information is needed:

1. The name of the engineer in terms of clause 1(m) of the GCC

2. A copy of the engineer’s written decision given in terms of clause 61(1) (c) of the GCC

3. Whether the engineer gave notice of his decision to the employer and the contractor in terms of
clause
61(1) (c) of the GCC

4. The names of the persons who have already been considered and rejected as mediators by the parties

5. A brief description of the particulars of the dispute, including particulars of the contractors and
parties involved in the dispute

6. The location of the subject matter of the dispute

On receipt of the information, the matter will be placed before the President and when the nomination is
made, the name of the mediator so nominated will be communicated to the party who requested the
nomination. Both parties must then communicate directly with the mediator to ascertain whether he
accepts the appointment and to agree with him upon the terms and conditions of appointment.

2
3. PROCEDURE FOR THE APPOINTMENT OF AN ARBITRATOR
(In terms of clause 61(3) of the GCC – 1990/2004/2010

If the parties to a dispute fail to agree on an arbitrator, the latter shall be nominated by the President of
the South African Institution of Civil Engineering, in terms of clause 61(3) (a), on application by either of
the parties.

To enable the President to nominate a suitable person, the following information is needed:

1. The information solicited in items 1 - 6 above

2. The names of the persons who have already been considered and rejected as arbitrators by the
parties

3. If the parties resorted to mediation, the name of the mediator

On receipt of the information, the matter will be placed before the President and his nomination will be
communicated to the party who requested the nomination. Both parties must then communicate directly
with the arbitrator to ascertain whether he accepts the appointment and to agree with him upon the
terms and conditions of appointment.

Please address all correspondence to: Email: [email protected]

3
South African Institution of Civil Engineering
Private Bag X200
HALFWAY HOUSE
1685

2015

Dear Sir

GENERAL CONDITIONS OF CONTRACT:
APPPOINTMENT OF MEDIATOR / ARBITRATOR / ADJUDICATOR
BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE SOUTH AFRICAN INSTITUTION OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

With reference to your request for the appointment of a mediator/ arbitrator/adjudicator, please complete the
attached form and return the relevant documentation to the CEO to expedite the process.

In addition to the completed application form, payment in the amount of R8500.00 per request is required. Please
enclose a cheque for this amount made out to SAICE, or provide proof of payment with your completed
application form. Receipt of payment is a prerequisite for the request to be processed.

Yours faithfully

M Pillay
CEO SAICE SAICE Banking details:
Standard Bank Parktown
Account number: 200 853 058
Branch code: 000355

4
APPOINTMENT OF MEDIATOR / ARBITRATOR/ADJUDICATOR IN TERMS OF GENERAL CONDITIONS OF
CONTRACT (1990/2004/2010)
1. Names and particulars of the parties to the contract and the dispute:
1.1 Employer________________________________________________________

Address:_______________________________________________________________

Tel:________________________Fax:________________________Cell:_________________

E-mail:________________________________________________
1.2 Contractor_______________________________________________________

Address:_______________________________________________________________

Tel:________________________Fax:________________________Cell:_________________

E-mail:________________________________________________
1.3 Subcontractor if a party to the dispute _________________________________________________

Tel:________________________Fax:________________________Cell:_________________

E-mail:________________________________________________

1.4 Other parties to the dispute
________________________________________________________________

Tel:________________________Fax:________________________Cell:_________________

E-mail:________________________________________________

2. Title and edition of General Conditions of Contract:
_____________________________________________

3. Engineers involved:
3.1 Name of engineer appointed in terms of the GCC

___________________________________________________________________________

Address____________________________________________________________________

Tel:___________________________Fax:____________________Cell:_________________

E-mail:___________________________________________

3.2 Consulting Engineer appointed by the employer

___________________________________________________________________________

Adress:_____________________________________________________________________

Tel:________________________Fax:________________________Cell:_________________

E-mail:________________________________________________

3.3 Other Engineers involved

_________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________

5
4. Is this a request for the nomination of an Adjudicator, Arbitrator or Mediator?

___________________________________________________________________________

5. Attach a copy of the decision of the employer’s engineer, the employer’s representative, the contractor or the
subcontractor that lead to the request for arbitration, adjudication or mediation together with a copy of the clause
in the contract concerning such a request.
__________________________________________________________________________

6. Give a brief description of the dispute:

7. Geographical location of the works as well as the municipal jurisdiction of the location of the works:

__________________________________________________________________________

8. Name of the party submitting this form:

__________________________________________________________________________

Address____________________________________________________________________

Tel:________________________Fax:________________________Cell:_________________

E-mail:________________________________________________

9. Indicate the names of arbitrators, adjudicators or mediators already considered by a party or parties but not
accepted by one of the parties:
__________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________

10. Attachments to this application form:

__________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________

6
EASTERN CAPE

MEDIATOR (only)

PERSONAL INFORMATION

NAME: II LL HHuuiissmmaann

ACADEMIC QUALIFICATIONS: BB EEnngg ((CCiivviill))

MEMBERSHIP OF EECCSSAA,, CCEESSAA,, MMSSAAIICCEE;; SSAAIISSCC,,IIMMEESSAA,, CCSSSSAA

INSTITUTIONS/SOCIETIES:

POSTAL ADDRESS: 112200 CCaappee RRooaadd,, MMiillll PPaarrkk,, PPoorrtt EElliizzaabbeetthh,, 66000011

TEL NO: (Work) ((004411)) 337733 55112211
(Work & Fax) ((004411)) 337733 55111199
(Cell) 008822 665511 55661100
(Email) iivvoo@@hhuuiissmmaann..ccoo..zzaa
OCCUPATION: CCoonnssuullttiinngg CCiivviill//SSttrruuccttuurraall EEnngg
PRINCIPAL AREAS OF CCiivviill sseerrvviicceess,, bbuuiillddiinngg wwoorrkkss aanndd pprroojjeecctt mmaannaaggeemmeenntt
EXPERIENCE:
PREFERRED AREAS OF OOnnee aappppooiinnttmmeenntt aatt aa ttiimmee
INVOLVEMENT WITH MEDIATION:
MEDIATOR/ARBITRATOR

PERSONAL INFORMATION
Willem Hendrik Olivier
NAME

ACADEMIC QUALIFICATIONS M.Ing.(civil); MBA; FAArb
MEMBERSHIP OF MSAICE; Pr.Eng ECSA; Pr.CPM SACPCMP
INSTITUTIONS/SOCIETIES
Fellow of the Association of Arbitrators
Commercial Mediator with Conflict Dynamics and Africa
Centre of Dispute Resolution.
cidb Panel of dispute adjudicators
PO Box 20307, Humewood, 6013
POSTAL ADDRESS:

[phone]
TEL NO: (Work)
(Cell) 083 593 5506
(Email) [email protected]
Senior Project Manager – Private practice
OCCUPATION:
FIDIC, GCC, JBCC, PROCSA, ECSA and NEC contracts
PRINCIPAL AREAS OF
EXPERIENCE:
Specialised in construction law with the Association of
Arbitrators (SA)

Adjudication, mediation, arbitration and claims consultant
PREFERRED AREAS OF
INVOLVEMENT WITH MEDIATION on commercial and construction disputes

7
MEDIATOR / ARBITRATOR
PERSONAL INFORMATION
NAME: MM RRiivvaarroollaa
ACADEMIC QUALIFICATIONS: PPrr EEnngg,, BBSScc EEnngg,, ((MMeecchh)) HH..DDiipp..AArrbb
MEMBERSHIP OF SSAAAACCEE,, EECCSSAA,, SSPPEE,, MMSSAAIIMMeecchhEE,, MMCCoorrrrllSSAA,, MMlloorrrrIISSAA,,
INSTITUTIONS/SOCIETIES: MMAAFFSSAA,, FFEELLLLOOWW AASSSS OOFF AARRBB,, NNFFPPAA,, FFPPSSAA
POSTAL ADDRESS: 44 BBeellggrraavvee RRooaadd,, BBEELLGGRRAAVVIIAA,, EEAASSTT LLOONNDDOONN,, 55220011
TEL NO: (Work) ((00443311)) 77443388 226666 CCeellll::008822 99000077551144
(Fax)
((00443311)) 77443300 559999
EEmmaaiill:: mmiikkeerriivv@@ccaarriiffrroo..ccoomm
OCCUPATION: CCoonnssuullttiinngg EEnnggiinneeeerr PPrriinncciippaall
PRINCIPAL AREAS OF CCoonnttrraaccttss -- CCoonnssttrruuccttiioonn -- PPrrooffeessssiioonnaall SSeerrvviicceess
EXPERIENCE:
PREFERRED AREAS OF AAss aabboovvee
INVOLVEMENT WITH MEDIATION:

MEDIATOR / ARBITRATOR

PERSONAL INFORMATION
NAME: Stuart Riddle
ACADEMIC QUALIFICATIONS: HNDT Civil, PR CM, F AArb.
MEMBERSHIP OF PR CM SACPCMP; F AArb,
INSTITUTIONS/SOCIETIES:
POSTAL ADDRESS: PO Box 176, Patensie, 6335
041-5814940
TEL NO: (Work)
(Work & Fax) 041-5814943
(Cell) 083 250 2165
(Email) [email protected]
OCCUPATION: CEO of Omega Civils (Pty)Ltd and Omega Construction
& Building (Pty) Ltd
PRINCIPAL AREAS OF GCC 2004/2010, CSRA, SANS1200, JBCC2000, Bulk
EXPERIENCE: earthworks, major roadworks and all township services
PREFERRED AREAS OF Arbitration, adjudication and mediation on all contractual
INVOLVEMENT WITH MEDIATION: aspects of the above.
8
ARBITRATOR

PERSONAL INFORMATION
NAME: David John Gordon McIntosh
ACADEMIC QUALIFICATIONS: B.Sc Civil Engineering ( UCT)
MEMBERSHIP OF NIL
INSTITUTIONS/SOCIETIES:
POSTAL ADDRESS: P.O. Box 15115, Emerald Hill, 6011. ( Port Elizabeth)
041-3686367
TEL NO: (Work)
(Work & Fax) 041-3686156
(Cell) 0825675109
(Email) [email protected]
OCCUPATION: Civil Engineering Contractor
PRINCIPAL AREAS OF EXPERIENCE: Roads, Earthworks,Township Services, Earth &
Rollcrete Dams, Pipelines
PREFERRED AREAS OF INVOLVEMENT Roads( Not Premix problems), Earthworks, Township
WITH MEDIATION: Services, Earth & Rollcrete Dams, Pipelines

MEDIATOR

PERSONAL INFORMATION
NAME: MM WW WWaattssoonn
ACADEMIC QUALIFICATIONS: BBSScc..((EEnngg)),, MMPPAA,, PPrr EEnngg,, CC EEnngg
MEMBERSHIP OF FFSSAAIICCEE,, MMIICCEE
INSTITUTIONS/SOCIETIES:
POSTAL ADDRESS: 2266 CCoouunnttrryy PPaaccee,, HHaawwtthhoorrnnee AAvveennuuee,, SSuunnrriiddggee PPaarrkk,, PPoorrtt
EElliizzaabbeetthh,, 66004455
((004411)) 336600 44440088
TEL NO: (Work)
(Fax) ((008866 66771100555522
(Cellular) ((008822)) 775500 77006600
(email) mmwwaattssoonn@@mmwweebb..ccoo..zzaa
OCCUPATION: RReettiirreedd CCiivviill EEnnggiinneeeerr
PRINCIPAL AREAS OF EXPERIENCE: LLooccaall GGoovveerrnnmmeenntt aanndd CCoonnttrraacctt AAddmmiinniissttrraattiioonn,, BBrriiddggeess
RRooaaddss,, aanndd WWaatteerr SSuuppppllyy IInnssttaallllaattiioonnss.. CCoommpplleetteedd 9922
mmeeddiiaattiioonnss aanndd aaddjjuuddiiccaattiioonnss rreellaattiinngg ttoo tthheessee mmaatttteerrss..
PREFERRED AREAS OF INVOLVEMENT AAnnyy ooff tthhee aabboovvee..
WITH MEDIATION:
9
GAUTENG

ARBITRATOR
PERSONAL INFORMATION
NAME: CChhrriiss BBiinnnniinnggttoonn

BBSScc HHoonnss,, MMBBLL ((UUNNIISSAA))
ACADEMIC QUALIFICATIONS:

MEMBERSHIP OF FF II MMeecchhEE,, FFAAAAAArrbb
INSTITUTIONS/SOCIETIES:
POSTAL ADDRESS: PP OO BBooxx 8844332255,, GGrreeeennssiiddee 22003344
((001111)) 88888866114411
TEL NO: (Work)
(Fax) ((001111))88888811006688
(Cell) 008822 880077 44005533
(Email) ccddbb@@bbccaa..ccoo..zzaa

OCCUPATION: MMaannaaggiinngg DDiirreeccttoorr BBiinnnniinnggttoonn CCooppeellaanndd && AAssssoocciiaatteess
CCoonnssttrruuccttiioonn ccllaaiimmss iinn aallll ddiisscciipplliinneess
PRINCIPAL AREAS OF EXPERIENCE:
PREFERRED MATTERS OF NNoo ppaarrttiiccuullaarr rreessttrriiccttiioonnss
INVOLVEMENT:

10