Hon. Arnold L. Natali Jr.

97 Pages·2017·1.86 MB·English

Hon. Arnold L. Natali Jr.'s Motion List for March 31, 2017
CAPTION DK DKtt YR MTN# MOTION TYPE OUTCOME NOTES
ALFARO HEIDI VS PSE&G L 2356 15 151 BAR NET OPINION ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/28/2017
1110 DECLARATORY JUDGMENT ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/28/2017
AUERBACH LEONARD VS STATE FARM L 6255 16 697 SEVER CLAIMS WITHDRAWN
B&R RECOVERY VS ALP!IZAR JANET DJ 162655 12 771 TURN OVER GRANTED
BAYER JENNIFER VS SIEGEL BERNARD L 4305 16 776 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/13/2017
BESHAI MARIANA VS CORZO STEPHANIE L 7262 15 744 MOTION TO COMPEL GRANTED
CARRASQUILLO IDA VS EXTRA SPACE STORA L 4260 16 154 ENTER DEFAULT WITHDRAWN
CASSIDY CONNIE VS SHELL CORPORATION L 5261 16 600 DISMISS W/ PREJUDICE WITHDRAWN
CATALINO BESSIE VS PATNOSH ANDREW L 355 16 833 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE WITHDRAWN
CHEVRES MARISOL VS HENDR BUS COMP. L 5858 16 1159 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE GRANTED
CITIZENS UNITED VS BENJAMIN SEANTEL L 1858 16 108 SUMMARY JUDGMENT DENIED
109 SUMMARY JUDGMENT DENIED
COUNTY OF MIDDLESEX VS DATA RX L 5015 14 SUMMARY JUDGMENT DENIED
COTTRELL MARYANN VS HOLTZBERG NATHA L 5557 16 808 MOTION TO DISMISS PARTIAL
474 MOTION TO DISMISS PARTIAL
CRUZ LUIS VS RUTGERS UNIVERSITY L 7355 16 164 MOTION TO DISMISS ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/28/2017
DELORENZO TARA VS HOTCHKISS CHRISTOPH L 457 16 248 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE WITHDRAWN
DESAI MUKESH VS ANNAMANENI RAVINDER L 6942 16 1169 MOTION TO DISMISS ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/28/2017
EDGEWOOD PROPERTIES VS HALPER FAMILY L 6658 16 1170 MOTION TO DISMISS ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/28/2017
FONTAINA ANGELINA VS SOVEREIGN BANK L 32 17 MOTION TO DISMISS GRANTED W/0 PREJUDICE
MOTION TO DISMISS GRANTED W/0 PREJUDICE
FRIEDMAN RUSSELL VS THE GARDENS AT MO L 3058 16 153 SUMMARY JUDGMENT ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/13/2017
GALIEGO MARCOS VS BLAIT RAYMOND L 5158 15 746 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
GIOVANNA BELGICA VS MESEHA MANAL L 7053 15 325 EXTEND DISCOVERY TRANSFERRED TRANS. TO JUDGE HAPPAS
GONNELLA THOMAS VS WILLIAMS ROBERT L 955 16 467 EXTEND DISCOVERY DENIED
HENRY F MITCHELL VS ORIE VAN WINGERDE L 3461 16 348 REINSTATE COMPLAINT GRANTED
HERNANDEZ DAWN VS MAHONEY DENNIS L 1055 16 583 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
HICKSON BRYAN VS MALLO JESSICA L 4753 16 954 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE WITHDRAWN
HOWARD CATHERINE VS REYES NORMA L 6254 15 787 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
HRUSHKOUSKI DZMITRY VS CAVALRY SPV L 5866 16 1108 MOTION TO DISMISS ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/28/2017
JENNINGS BARBARA VS HERBERT JOHN L 5260 16 662 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE WITHDRAWN
JIMENEZ-RAMOS ANA VS STARTS TRANSPORl L 1739 16 917 DISMISS W/ PREJUDICE TRANSFERRED TRANS. TO JUDGE HAPPAS
JURKIEWICZ NATALIE VS SAYREBROOK VET L 5361 15 737 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE DENIED
1059 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE DENIED
K HOVNANIAN SHORE VS TWNSP OF N. BRU L 1194 17 903 CONSOLIDATE ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/28/2017
KIM LIM VS YOUNG JAMES L 5159 14 484 PERMIT SALE OF PROP. ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/13/2017
KINSALE INSURANCE CO VS WORLDWIDE ME L 1563 16 740 MOTION TO COMPEL DENIED
KLEIN JANET VS BROOKSIDE ASSISTED LIVING L 858 16 962 EXTEND DISCOVERY DENIED
KRAUSE BRUCE VS PELLE ANTHONY L 1661 16 798 MOTION TO COMPEL GRANTED
LAKE ESTATES VS FALCON ENGINEERING L 6171 15 948 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE GRANTED
LEAL GAMBINO VS GIORDANO STEPHANIE L 3955 16 320 AMEND COMPLAINT ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/13/2017
LOVE LEMONT VS TOTO ANTONIO L 7755 13 ENFORCE LITS. RIGHTS DENIED
MAEROFF JOYCE VS SIMON EDDY L 2758 16 248 MOTION TO DISMISS GRANTED
MARTIN BRUCE VS LEDUC MICHEL L 263 16 1174 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE DENIED
964 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
MARTINEZ SASHA VS PRINCETON SURGICAL L 6063 16 508 MOTION TO DISMISS WITHDRAWN
MATULA CAROL VS WORRELL SHANELL L 3363 15 314 SUMMARY JUDGMENT ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/13/2017
MAYORGA MICHELLE VS JAUREGUI OlONICIA L 1655 16 799 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
545 EXTEND DISCOVERY DENIED SEE ORDER FOR MTN. #799
MEADOWS AT RENAISSANCE VS DARDEN CA DJ 16258 14 145 AID OF EXECUTION GRANTED
MEDINA IRINA VS CORDEIRO ANA L 6553 15 578 REINSTATE COMPLAINT GRANTED
METROPOLITAN GOURMET VS GLOBAL UNDF L 456 16 840 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
MRC RECEIVABLES VS PAVLIK MICHELLE L 8955 6 681 TURN OVER GRANTED
MUNIZ JOAN VS EAST COAST VILLAGE L 3559 14 628 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE WITHDRAWN
NOVOA MARIA VS RIOS-PINO KATHLYN L 6360 15 842 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
PATEL NATWARBHAI VS DESAI PARTH L 7354 15 901 MOTION TO COMPEL WITHDRAWN
PETERSON DAWN VS NJ TRANSIT L 6258 16 69 MOTION TO DISMISS GRANTED
RABBIT KEVIN VS GOMEZ IRIS L 1257 16 885 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
980 EXTEND DISCOVERY DENIED SEE ORDER FOR MTN. #885
RAMIREZ TERESA VS DIAZ ISRAEL L 1454 15 539 LATE AMENDMENT DENIED
RANDLE MARVIN VS BILLINGSLEA LYNELL L 2260 16 778 MOTION TO COMPEL WITHDRAWN
RIVERA NILDA VS ESPOSITO JOSEPH L 7554 15 748 ENFORCE LITS. RIGHTS GRANTED
ROSEN SONDRA VS RWJUH L 3361 16 836 AMEND COMPLAINT GRANTED
ROY ARTHUR VS VELEZ GEORGIE L 11257 14 981 DISMISS W/ PREJUDICE ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/28/2017 -SEE ORDER
RUBURY FRANK VS RWJUH L 11363 16 1175 REINSTATE COMPLAINT RESERVED
SAAVEDRA AUGUSTO VS CUNNINGHAM SRI L 554 16 588 RESTORE COMPLAINT GRANTED
SARRO LISA VS HOLMDEL OB/GYN L 1458 16 839 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
SHELDON DEBRA VS STONER RICHARD L 1955 16 881 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE PARTIAL
SMITH CHRISTOPHER VS BUDROW KELLI L 5862 15 1053 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/13/2017 ~ SEE ORDER
SOMAR SWARSATTIE VS SILVA RODRIGO L 1756 16 324 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
SUTTON SAVITRI VS MERlDAN HEALTH L 3157 15 727 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
THE CROWS NEST CONDO VS SERRANO MAB L 3459 15 739 SUMMARY JUDGMENT GRANTED
TORTORELLA SAND! VS ONG TUYEN L 61 16 941 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
TOYOTA MOTOR VS SHOTWELL ANGIE L 6561 15 300 VACATE DISMISSAL GRANTED
UNITY BANK VS VESUVIO ABIGAIL DJ 171057 16 ORDER FOR ARREST GRANTED
URENA GRISSEL VS SOLOMON RYAN L 2659 15 1176 BAR EVIDENCE GRANTED
VALDEZ VS TAVAREZ L 6162 14 889 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
884 EXTEND DISCOVERY DENIED
VALOROSO ROBERT VS DELKA TRUCKING L 7254 16 1060 MOTION TO DISMISS DENIED
VARGAS MAXIMO VS ABREU JOSE L 1656 16 144 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
VESUV!O DOLORES VS SOUTH PLAINFIELD DA L 4059 16 777 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE WITHDRAWN
VITIELLO MICHELE VS MAPLE GROVE L 5561 16 803 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE WITHDRAWN
557 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE WITHDRAWN
WANG QIN VS WANG HENG L 3060 16 1048 ATTORNEYS' FEES ADJOURNED ADJ TO 4/13/2017
WATSON JOAN VS REGULA ADAM L 5961 16 203 DISMISS W/0 PREJUDICE WITHDRAWN
WITTMAN GEORGE VS AWUKU NAANA L 1463 16 251 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
YADAV BALA VS BOTTOM DOLLAR FOOD L 1260 16 809 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
ZUCKER CINDY VS PATEL UNA L 6063 15 750 EXTEND DISCOVERY GRANTED
FILED
Andrew Sklar, Esquire (ASO 16751992)
MAR 31 2017
Sklar Law, LLC
1200 Laurel Oak Rd Suite 102
Voorhees NJ 08043 ARNOLD L. NATALI, JR., J.S.C.
856/258-4050
Attorneys for Plaintiff
File No.: 50034
B And R Recovery, Lie SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
Plaintiff(s) Middlesex County
LAW DIVISION
v. DOCKETNO.: DC-4369-12
Janet Alpizar CIVIL ACTION
Defendant(s) ORDER FOR TURNOVER OF FUNDS
This matter, being opened to the Court by Andrew Sklar, Attorney for the Plaintiff, B And R
Recovery, Lie, by way of Notice of Motion for Turnover of Funds, and the Court having reviewed the
moving papers, and for good cause shown;
IT IS ON THIS)I DAY _ _,_/]1~,x~./_. _ /._. _OF 2017 ORDERED AND
4
DECREED that Wells Fargo Bank is directed to turnover to Middlesex County Sheriff Dept, funds
pr~viou.slv levierl ,mnn in the amount of $750.88 in PARTIAL satisfaction of the plaintiffs judgment.
l('_
Opposed__ Unopposed
l \
. eviewed the above motion. the Court finds
~av1:rmeritonous on ,ts face ,ind is unopposed.
it to ·6-2 it thererore w,H be granted
Pursuant to B., l · ' - h oving
essentially for the reasons set forth m I e m
papers.
7"1'1
:Jt;
07>/ 2,,I/ /'7-
f Il ED
CHRISTINA E. JONES ROWE, ESQ./ID NO. 008611998
LAW OFFICES OF TERKOWITZ & HERMESMANN
400 ATRIUM DRIVE, FIFTH FLOOR MAR 3 1 2017
S0'\1ERSET, NEW JERSEY 08873
ARNOLD LNATAU,JR.,J.s.c.
[phone]
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANTS EDA CORZO AND STEPHANIE CORZO
CJR/CC:320300
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
MARIANA K. BESHAI-ASCANDER, AN
INDIVIDUAL AND RAMY I. ASCANDER, HER ) LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX
) COUNTY
HUSBAND, PER QUOD,
) DOCKET NO. MID-L-7262-15
Plaintiffs, )
) CIVIL ACTION
vs. )
) ORDER
STEPHANIE J, CORZO, AN INDIVIDUAL; ) COMPELLING PLAINTIFF TO
EDA G. CORZO, AN INDIVIDUAL, ET AL., ) ATTEND AN INDEPENDENT
MEDICAL EXAM
Defendants.
This matter having come before the Court on Motion of the Law Offices of Terkowitz, &
Hennesmann, attorneys for defendants Eda Corzo and Stephanie Corzo and the Court having
considered the matter and for good cause shown;
:5
IT IS on this day of 2017,
ORDERED that the plaintiff, Mariana Beshai-Ascander shall attend an independent medical
examination rescheduled with Dr. Andrew Hutter for April 6, 2017 at 1 :30pm, and;
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the no show fee in the amount of$250.00 incurred due to
plaintiff's failure to appear at the February 21, 2017 independent medical examination scheduled with
Dr. Hutter shall be paid by the plaintiff; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that should plaintiff fail to comply with the within Order,
)71,t'}
plaintiff-Shall'be precluded from producing any expert medical testimony at the time of trial in this
matter;-an.1-
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, that a copy of this Order shall be served upon all parties within
>
7 days
a~., -t,c,, ..
1 ·
l,l 1_. /{£..CZ.£,. iJC
1
~ if
~ ARNOLD L. NATALI, JFI., J.S.e. J.s.c.
THIS MOTION WAS:
() OPPOSED
('y;) UNOPPOSED
Having reviewed the above motion, the Court finds
·1 to be meritorious on its face and ,s unopposed.
~ursuant to .8., 1: 6·2, it therefore wUI be gran~ed
essentially for the reasons set forth m the movmg
papen.
I* 57-/
o3;1=t/rr
SCHILLER & PITTENGER, P.C.
FILED
James R. Korn - 029311980
1771 Front Street, Suite D
MAR 3 1 2017
Scotch Plains, New Jersey 07076
[phone]
ARNOLD L. NATALl,JR.,J.s.c.
Attorneys for Plaintiff Marisol Chevres
Our file number 14439
MARISOL CHEVRES, SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION : MIDDLESEX COUNTY
Plaintiff,
v. DOCKET NO. L-5858-16
HENDRY BUS COMPANY, MABEL Civil Action
ACOSTA, JOHN DOES 1 through 5, and
ABC COMPANIES I through 5, ORDER SUPPRESSING
WITHOUT PREWDICE ANSWER OF
Defendants. DEFENDANTS PURSUANT TO
RULE 4:23-5(a)(l)
THIS MATTER having been brought before the court by Schiller & Pittenger, P.C., attorneys for
Plaintiff Marisol Chevres (The "Plaintiff"), for an Order suppressing the Answer of Defendants
without prejudice, pursuant to Rule 4:23-5(a)(l); and the court having received and reviewed the
//'%
motion papers of counsel; and for good cause shown; it is on this day of March, 2017,
ORDERED that Plaintiffs motion is granted; and it is
FURTHER ORDERED that the Answer filed on behalf of Defendants Hendry Bus Company and
Mabel Acosta is suppressed without prejudice, pursuant to Rule 4:23-5(a)(l ), for failure to provide
discovery; and it is
.I
FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel within 7 days of
-~1'.
VARNOLD L. NATALI, JR.,.
___ OPPOSED
;,c UNOPPOSED
ORDERED that counsel for the deli~que~t
party shall serve upon his or her chant in
?1
acr,ordance with R. 4:23·5(a)(1) a copy
th,s (wmr ;:ind the notice set forth m
AppfJrc-,; + of the Court Rules
1 : \
Having reviewed the, above motion. the Court finds
it to be meritorious on its face and is unopposed.
Pursuant to R. I :6-2, it therefore will be granted
essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving
papers.
2
FILED
The Honorable Arnold L. Natali Jr., J.S.C.
Superior Court of New Jersey APR O3 2017
56 Paterson Street
Post Office Box 964 ARNOLD LN ATALI, JR., J.S.C.
New Brunswick, New Jersey 08903
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
CITIZENS UNITED RECIPROCAL MIDDLESEX COUNTY
EXCHANGE, LAW DIVISION
Plaintiff,
DOCKET NO. MID-L-1858-16
V.
CIVIL ACTION
SEANTEL BENJAMIN, JOHN DOES
1-10 and ABC COMPANIES 1-10, ORDER
Addressing Motion Nos. 1211 & 1212
Defendants.
THIS MATTER having come before the Court by way of a motion filed by William B. Foti,
Esq., appearing as counsel for Citizens United Reciprocal Exchange ("Plaintiff'), for summary
judgment, and a cross-motion filed by Joseph A. Massood, Esq., appearing as counsel for Seantel
Benjamin ("Defendant"), for summary judgment, and the Court having considered, and for the reasons
stated on the record on March 31, 2017, and for good cause shown:
IT IS on this 31"1 day of March, 2017:
ORDERED AS FOLLOWS:
1. Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment is DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE.
Defendant's cross-motion for summary judgment is DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE.
2. The new trial date is July 10, 2017. The parties shall depose Ms. Byrne. Any renewed
application by Plaintiff shall include an executed copy of the Byrne Affidavit and the parties
shall address the issue discussed during the March 3 I, 2017 oral argument regarding users
of vehicles (i.e., regular or otherwise) and household members in the context of the renewal
application at issue.
3. Plaintiff's counsel shall serve a copy of this Order upon all counsel of record within seven
(7) days of its online posting.
HON'. ARNOLD L. NATALI JR., J.S.C.
The Honorable Arnold L. Natali Jr., J.S.C.
FILED
Superior Court of New Jersey
56 Paterson Street
MAR 31 2017
Post Office Box 964
New Brunswick, New Jersey 08903 ARNOLD L. NATALI, JR., J.S.C.
COUNTY OF MIDDLESEX, A SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
Municipal Corporation of the State of MIDDLESEX COUNTY .
New Jersey, LAW DIVISION
Plaintiff,
DOCKET NO. MID-L-5015-14
V.
CIVIL ACTION
DATA RX MANAGEMENT, INC.,
PRESCRIPTION CORPORATION OF
AMERICA, HEALTHCARE
CORPORATION OF AMERICA, and
GARY SEKULSKI, ORDER
Defendants.
THIS MATTER having come before the Court by way of a motion filed by Benjamin D.
Leibowitz, Esq., appearing as counsel for Plaintiff, County of Middlesex, for partial summary
. judgment, and the Court having considered the papers submitted, and for the reasons stated on the
record on March 31, 2017, and for good cause shown:
IT IS on this 31st day of March, 2017:
ORDERED that Plaintiffs motion for partial summary judgment is DENIED; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that counsel for Plaintiff serve a copy of this Order upon all
counsel of record within seven (7) days of its online posting.
HON. Ai&OLD L. NATALI':JRJJ.S.C.
1
Sam Rosenberg, Esq. (041601986)
FILED
Ronald J. Morgan (089832013)
ROSENBERG JACOBS & HELLER, P.C.
201 Littleton Road - Box 513 APR - 3 2017
Monis Plains, New Jersey 07950-0513
~tlJOlD L. NATALI, JR., J.S.C
[phone]
Attorneys for Defendants, Roy Fe1iakos,
M.D. and Imaging Consultants of Essex
MARYA NN COTTRELL, SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY
Plaintiff, Docket No.: MID-L-5557-16
vs. CIVIL ACTION
NATHAN HOLTZBERG, M.D.;
ORTHOPEDIC INSTITUTE OF ORDER
CENTRAL JERSEY, P.A.; KIMBALL
MEDICAL CENTER, INC.; et al.,
Defendants.
FOR THE REASONS SET FORTH
ON THE RECORD ON 5' >· 1
r •
THIS MATTER having been opened to the Court by Rosenberg Jacobs & Heller,
attorneys for defendant, Roy Fe1iakos, M.D. and Imaging Consultants of Essex, on Motion, and
the Court having reviewed all papers, and arguments of counsel, and for good cause shown;
IT IS on this
ORDERED that plaintiffs' Complaint aru:baaycrer-.e±ai-e hereby dismissed with
prejudice as to defendants, Roy Fertakos, M.D. and Imaging Consultants of Essex and further
Ordered that copies of the Order shall be served within seven days of ;,
{J , , r, r ( { /( ,. C I< · I... ) :/(
J~1:.
ARNOLD L. NATALI, Ji"I.,
OPPOSED [i] :; ;
UNOPPOSED [ ]
< ·:J-/ "', ~·: :(;
, 1cJe- ;z..,"*":(.,