Table Of ContentGUIDELINE F-14
(formerly 02-01)
Economic Analyses of Control Documents on
Private Sector Enterprises and Municipal Projects
Legislative Authority:
Environmental Protection Act, RSO 1990, Part I, Section 4
Responsible Director:
hcn asreBciv rceiSmon o,crEotceriD
Last Revision Date:
49 9,1lirpA
Table of Contents
1.0 DEFINITIONS
2.0 OBJECTIVE
3.0 PURPOSES AND USES OF ECONOMIC ANALYSES
4.0 INITIATION OF AN ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
4.1 si
syla ncAimono c nEeataiti n oIyttirohtuA
4.2 s
isylan Acimonoc En agnitaitin Iro fsnosaeR
4.3 Protocol
5.0 INFORMATION THAT MAY BE REQUIRED:
5.1 se
syla nsAsenevitceffE-tsoC
5.2 s
esylan Atcapm IlaicnaniF
5.3 se
syla ntAsoC-tifeneB
6.0 IMPLEMENTATION
6.1 no
itanidro odC nyatilibisnopseR
6.2 noi
tatlus nloaCnretxE
7.0 FURTHER ANALYSES
8.0 PROVISION OF RELEVANT INFORMATION
8.1 se
itr adPetalug e fRyotilibisnopseR
8.2 no
itamrof neItisiuq eeRdivo roePtruliaF
8.3 no
itamrof nfmIoodeerF
SYNOPSIS
e hrted nduemrofr e epyb atma hstesyla ncaimono cre okfrowema rsafedivo repniledi usgihT
"stnemu cloodrtn otfcno"empole v eetfhd rothsacapn asreBciv rceiSmon o ecnfhEootitcerid
.seitilapicin u rmsonoitaropr o,csmr i,fslaudivid n oidteussi edulc nsitnemuc oldortnoC
,sred r,otnet nfsioecit o,nlavorp pfsAoetacifitr e,Cstimr e,psecnec i,lstrop esr'retsiniM
.slavor pmpaarg od,rnspanoitce rdsintdanemeriu q,esrre dlroOrtnoC
r o rfnooituceso rlpatnemnoriv n nera oefcnedi v sedaeriuq e erobs lya asmisyla ncaimonocE
.noitcivn oracet fganicnetnes noitamrof neidivo r op stsiisyla ncaimono c ne faeosopr uephT
t o rngonitnemelp m fisoecneuqesn occimono cde nsanoitacilp mliaicnan ief httuoba
.stnemuc oldortn o ncsitnemeriuq egrnitnemelpmi odte s eulbl iswisyla nea h ftsotlus eerhT
lortn onscievitcej bloatnemnoriv nreo/d nsatnemeriuq eertairporp pe a hnetodic epdleh
.stnemucod .noituceso r napein igafnidnemmoc err osfis a sabdae s euobs lna ascisyla neahT
1.0 Definitions
Economic Analysis:
ralucitr a fpsoecneuqesn oec hettaula vde nyafitne d oistelpicni rcpimono c fenooitacilp peahT
;ycil o npsiegna h rcnooit c fasoesruoc laicnan irfo/d nsasenevitceffe-ts o,ctsoc-tifen esbedulcni
;sesyla nsatceffe tnereff igdno msaeul adv nsaecneuqesn oecse h ftnooitubirts i rdeocnedic neiht
denimre to e ssdslniaoi greor/ dsnraot cceismon o,csepuorg
Regulated Party:
lavor prrpeoa dtonrctaoej b osuyhistwi trnee hnrtoooitarop r,oycnap meotcav i,rlpaudivi dnnAi
Control Document:
yeblbaecrof nyeltcer idd n,atneipic eer hnto pgunidn i,betuta t ysdbeziroht u sahici htwnemuc oAd
secit o,nlavorp pfsAoetacifitr e,Cstimr e,psecnec i,lstrop esr'retsin ieMdulc neise h;tnoitucesorp
slav(o rmpapra g,dosnrnapoitc esdrtninademeri u,qserr eldorrO t,nsorC e,dtrno eftoniFor
purposes of this guideline, a Control Document will also refer to a prosecution.)
Financial Analysis:
stcef fleaicnan idf ncaimono cee hettamit s oesteuqinhc eltacityla ncaimono c fenooitacilp peahT
,smr i,fslaudivid n nisotnemeriuq elratnemnoriv nceifice p fs)ostifen edb nsats ohctob(
seitilapic i snrnuoomitarop rnow co,rsCnoitaroproc
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis:
sdoht eemvitanret l fasots oec h ftnoosirapm osacevlov nhici hewuqinhc eltacityla ncaimono cneA
ll itwa hdtoht eem h ftnooitanimret e,d r;otcef fleaicifen e rbeovitcej bdoeificeps-e reapveih coat
erutidnep x retoup n filoev edlex iraf otfcef f reeovitcej bnoev i fagtonuo mtasehg ieh hetveihca
Benefit - Cost Analysis:
stifen edb nsats oec h ftnooitaul adv nnaoitacifitna u,qnoitacifitne dei hstevlov ntia hktrowema rAf
noit cfsaoesru oecvitanret ld ansamargo rdpenif ehdt idwetaicossa
Environmental Objectives:
,)slavorp prsaoredr os(tnemuc oldortn ondcieifice pssevitcej beovitatila urlqoaciremuN
: odtetim itl otn u,bgnidulcni rro ina is(noitartnecn otcnatull o,pset awro leflbawol lmaumixam
. c,tee mti it rnseugpnid atonlatul l)ospesae ltenratul leonprob-retaw
2.0 Objective
stnemuc olDortn ofsCoecneuqesn occimono cd enlaaicnan ie fhttuo bnaoitamrof neitaren eogT
.snoisic egdnik a nmliennosr eyprtsin idM nraetsin ieM h ytdbe s eunb atca hsteitr adpetalug enro
3.0 Purposes and Uses of Economic Analyses
(a) detaicos ssats oe chdtrof ftaonn attcia hyttr adpetalu g yseabmria lycfir ed vnsases soat
htiw a lortnoc ,tnemucod ro taht stsoc detaicossa htiw a lortnoc tnemucod era detcepxe ot
secneuqesn oeclbarised nrueh tr,ootnemyolpme n,useruso ltcna lepsuac
) b( sfeocneuqes ncoicmon orcee h dtsnotaife n,esbt s eothcut onboaitamro fendiiv oortp
tnemuc oldort n nsoaincoitidn olcatnemnoriv nrseonoitidn odcesoporp
(c) r;otnemuc oldort n nosaicevitcej bloatnemnoriv nneeodic epdl eoht
(d) ret fsagnira eghnicnetn er sorsfonoituceso rlpatnemnoriv nr eoefcnedi veedivo ropt
.snoitcivnoc
4.0 Initiation of an Economic Analysis
4.1 Authority to Initiate an Economic Analysis
ar odae Hnoisivi Da,retsini Mytupe Deh t,retsini Meh ty bdetaitin ie bya msisylan acimonoc enA
Director.
4.2 Reasons for Initiating an Economic Analysis
(a) cimono c re,ostcef fleaicnan iefsrev d,apihsdr aehud nsumia lyctr adpetalug ear
;tnemsses snsaatseuq ed rn,aeruso ltcna lshpac u,ssecneuqesnoc
) b( lortno cyrtsini Mahti wdetaicoss astceff elaicnani fr opihsdra heudn usmial cytilapicinu ma
;tnemucod
(c) r;otnemsses snsaatseuq eyrcne gtanemnrev oryGortsin irMehtona
(d) gnir u rdeocnef esaadat acdimonoce/laicnan isftnese rnpoituceso rnatpinadnef eaD
.gnicnetnes
4.3 Protocol
e h rtdoa enHoisiv ieDtairporp pea hhtguor hetd a emlbla hssesyla ncaimono cre osftseuqeR
.hcn asreBciv rceiSmon o,crEotce r ehiohcDttn asreBciv rleaS g erefhoLottceriD
5.0 Information that may be required:
:eriuq eyrllamr olnla hhscna rsBecivr ecSimono ceE h,tsesyla ntacudn oocT
5.1 Cost-Effectiveness Analyses
(a) rsoet aergrahcs i rdnooissi m fesomr e ntsievitcej bmoargo r fpnooitacifice pesvitatitnauq
;sleve lytilau qlatnemnorivn etneibma
) b( eveih clal itwa hstmets ytsnemegan a rmsoeigolonhc e ftnooitacifice pesvisneherpm oac
d n;anoitanibm o n crieono l,asevitcej bdoeta tesht
(c) rsoeigolonhc edteifice pgsnitnemelp m fisots ogcnitare pdo nlaatip aec h ftsoetamitse
.sevitce jdbeot a etehsvtei hsocetarudec otrnpemeganam
5.2 Financial Impact Analyses
:)c( 1r.e5 ddneubirc sneoditamro f ennohiottiti dndIa
(a) sra eeyv itfsa e tlra onfoitare pso'ytr adpetalug eer h ftsotnemeta tlsaicnan idfeliated
:mumin i tm,agnidulcni ftonemeta t,sstee hescnal a,bstnemeta tesmoc ndietadilosnoc
;seicil ogpnitnuoc cdaetpo dda nsaeci rrpefsna rttnavel e,rnoitis olpaicnan i nfsiegnahc
) b( ,suc oef h styitr adpetalug etrnemhsilbatse-itl u,megr a faltonemhsilbat seelgn ieasrehw
d n;aderiuq eer rtanemhsilbat sceifice pes hrt oaft aldaicnan idfetagergesed
(c) .setare pyotr adpetalug eer hhtci h nwyirtsud nei hrt oaft aedcnamrofr elpaicnanif
5.3 Benefit-Cost Analyses
: 1n.o5it creeS ddneubirc sneoditamro f ennohiottiti dndIa
(a) ruob a,lslairet a,mslacime h,ctnempiu q fesoeititna ulqacisy hep h ftsoetamitse
suoir aevveih codateriuq esreul alvaicnan irfie hd tn)a.c t,ekr ofswora ersyoruoh-nosrep(
slal es,wanoitceto rlpatnemnoriv nfseoeerg erndooitcud enroitull o,ptnemeta bfsaolevel
;gnitlu sseerune vsrenoroitcu dte sryonca
) b( t otnu bg(nidulc ntinemuc olDortn oeC hhtt igwniylpm o fcsoecneuqesn olcaicnanif-non
d;nnaoitcu d torurop ptdueosae r dcrenociu d,esrffo- y)daoelttimil
(c) sni algaic ods nlaatnemnoriv nee h ftsonoitpircs eedvitatila urqo/d nsaetamit seevitatitnauq
ral l eosfhdeottami t,seelbis seorp e,h dw)nsa(noi tdceasop o ermhp otgrnfitlu sseers srool
.secneuqesn oecse hhtt idwetaicos ssaeulav
6.0 Implementation
6.1 Responsibility and Co-ordination
:sesyla ncaimono cle l fanooitatnemelp mei hettanidro- olcla hhscna rsBecivr ecSimono ceEhT
(a) ;tnatlusn oy arcbeosuoh- nti udoeirr a eclbl iswesyla nraehte hewnimret eodt
) b( tnave lree r hd st nsiofathontemeriu qehe htrttinwetsis nedo recsasduoh tt eaemhrtu sonte
;seicilop
(c) yodt u etmns ooerlfbarap m doynctail atunqetsi sef snroatoalcu ste arehrtu sonte
d;nraehtona
(d) r oeflbissec cd andaeniatni ae mrsaesyla ne ahfstotlus erreh td onaat a,dstrop eerrus noet
.ecnere feerrutuf
6.2 External Consultation
d neatavi rrpeh td ontanemnrev olGared ee Fh,tseirtsin ilMaicnivo rrPeh thot iswnoitatlusnoC
.deriuq e srnaekatred n eulbla hsseicne gcailbup
7.0 Further Analyses
erev eessu adclu oscts oeccnailpm otcnemuc oldortn oec htta hstetacid nsiisyla nlaaicnan ifafI
sisylan atsoc-tifene bevisneherpmo cero ma,sffoya leeyolpm er o,serusol ctnal p,snedru blaicnanif
.detnemelpm ie byam
8.0 Provision of Relevant Information
8.1 Responsibility of Regulated Parties
reh td onlaaicnan ihfc uesdivo rodptetcep xe ersaesyla ncaimono cteseuq eo rhsweitr adpetalugeR
.sesyla ne aht tuyorr ao,ctdede es,nastnatlusn os ctrlioennosr eyprtsin ionMtoitamrof nfsioepyt
8.2 Failure to Provide Requisite Information
8.3 Freedom of Information
tnemsses slaaicnan itfseuq eor hsweitr adpetalug e yrnboitamrof ndieriuq eer hetdivo r opetruliaF
stcef feesrev dtanacifing i osenv ashtnemeriuq eyrrotalug eer htta hnta e omdteterpret n eilblahs
.noit s yentu irqdaeptalu genehort
rsonoitaropr oncwo r,Cseinapm oectavi r,pslaudivid nyyibrtsin ie M hodttedivo rnpoitamrofnI
eFh tf osnoisivor peh to ttcejbu se bllah sseitilapicinumreedom of Information Act.
e hFrted neurusolcs imdo rtfpme x eelbl inwoitamrof nhic utsa hdtetcep x setiI reedom of
Information Act .snoitaropr orscomr i,fslaudivid neitavi rosptniatr etepisuac eb ,revewoH
eh ty beda me blli wdeilppu snoitamrofn iyn af oytilaitnedifno ceh tgnidrage rnoitanimreted
.rotanidro- onCoitamrof nfmIoodee rsF'yrtsiniM
