Feminist dilemmas in qualitative research: Public knowledge and private lives

112 Pages·1998·16.92 MB·English

by  Ribbens, Jane & Edwards, Rosalind

st Dilemmas
2 Research

bomil
in Qualitat
Feminist Dilemmas
i. Qualitative Research

Public Knowledge and Private Lives

edited by

Jane Ribbens and Rosalind Edwards

SAGT Pablicitions
Tovwtga = Tmasand Gals See chi
ee

Contents

atk meet Notes

PautT Tatnvasing Oia Nees

Tieton ths Feige. Pie Rn
etd Paso ld Rss
Pisnvw se Posy Voc! are eget
Divuskuet hg berleant

oe REDone

Sanse Lives, Personal

Pact AL peking wo Ute

te Mefering Maltapsed Voie:

1 Liviu Se. Vests ite Pade Dinwanse Rerars
Auctiva S22 Rests: abion
vee
4 Shang Layer Peaessioul aaa Pas? Nani
nz anal Chair eve

Tae Vite
5 Publica Prive eu Dies eae Fea
sa Chere
Ban et

6 Tysovstied Volos 2x4 Wicren Own ores Le Sli ot
‘anire Wer-sn rss
sine Foe

Part Heorlag aud Tepreendog: Refccng the Pete ia Pubic
Meigs Cor op Volos. Png Resse

18 Relieieus vag Soie.srmted Retsione’ Miciad, Anaissmg
veto at Doze Woes

ops ad doccut Ane soo “ilenvnas in Rzaese ing
the Yosef Chiko

1 Ratoonseuvting Kessuzck Naat: Sell Saciolarioe
‘owity wm Allerat Setings
ie Ba

Ww

us

1
LL Sremny the Woke the Fes
Melber

Le
rene

Sse towiast
oe
»

Contributors’ Nows

Pam Aldo os, Letter Paseigecal Sling Ce Tees a Fes
Lords aK asl acorn Stectm at Universh pnt Shalt
EAC er PED 2s ur vases pegs oan sing, ne

ag. (ze pros ston kes aige ten! et ie sists ie sural
‘Eecare al. payeholagr. less cowl glen sein ece ese
Shisiengs ths eles ae weal 22
Send allow ser oa aekewledge se suppl ata tee
fed her PhD senernsor, Chaitinging om
antes Poae iar pK. Busty BALA.
Heonea, 3 Maske. Megstall Kagan Bb
fed Fisvnwinas. Dieoatce Peat, Fats Sei

me aiken, P Aldea. R. Alond, # sllegtee. U. Gal
Soule Topar © Hasan, D. Marks ata, Ware

saipinar paces tase

Sevley. & Gukebe,
tesa 3, Warass #1895
ri Restores BL.

ina ll Souin Fesbans* ane Rescastar fe ohe Sein! ef So

Scinmos Ol ielegy Ue voity Tok Sheqnserernehes rena rerbes
Nese gel ee aud vit lates eakiap pentane peg ames I
viel sock see elu pu gal ab Feigin. Her ese sr
Se aeance eemgnite 2 me Heceey aM ae? pees nL te eg
Sh eee lg, soon eee um cis aes poe aS
Vote even: neta cles ol vil ry ede we
Fractve ke POL? aoe at bropulogial sy new te Sect me

Sorsn she fie Sen ame a ter

Maxine Binh is a Lecturer at Laberay Caley Suffers i oe
sncioogy ef Sdhcod, ar sextar nies en re uC splat of oe
erin slits Her PAD loo. ae secuaectston ellen.
sicrss in leer thersps groups Ca protaed seLcunwvcers. are
Tisec ith hers eign ga ariner en a seared eta arm,

Andrea Thoncer i: Assits we Profenae oa Sezelogy sad troeraconal
Tews egunene Sead ee St ars Tener Hales, Cana, She ea
Tain Palins Se -ra,an WEAF Dosnpmer: Studien she ssive? her
Ta) ion Cambs [sree Sack” and Baila! Seloness, Her cure
dean » emer amued rs trade cgi, spirsirelagea or acre
al dopeols so cmenca co seules Serene and eiaaships wien
sxselehl site ber ale soe Lis eset ind ping 3
eouahiers
‘uotnd fans ne se ie Soil lie Sonal Seness Rese
i, et ih tinct, Renate nn steam meters
AV vfs ig ils anh, wean shoes ov auch as pices
ios, STeawanin le cacctl i He eh, 3 ae nM
Fra ie ste atti, fhe, deonelsaatieue gal eileen
tices al picoms, Aecleor i eett, Hoyaa a pable
vata aivee oes Browne Sookie, Sepals ee Coameeg Fail
ft dat ISB Akay pe! somes fide Duis Me. Dav
SUL ges | Relbour 98. Sgt sou tae acrenigond Cee
ule or Tin” teva 448, et, F887: She se-eirer

1 Besant ae fn

SN. La cere ines
ne ont ses reese eZ

{Feece ind Po, be heated fa
Seabaug mutierbeest aed elcauen
eslendad a scorpeeae grabber

Molanic Mauthnst ura: 4 Research es tthe Soci! Seonas Rosca
Ura rites 22 seven, Lomas Linierssy, WK, Se he eu 4
hasan erpricalrssrch poate win elena alt acho a
usehoafe eh furs lls pesohsing 23d taal He" a one src I
eet oa inva

Peripher ancelogy oF sce arene 3 A
aed sete icerantiars She alg se4shss Psst Mhwlsoey che
IME intieuiss's Sextasid Pain id the Paral Sire Croan
sche Fesinns,¢98 shout In vor lare #21 99 Sosinkoe. eu 80
Suse Sigs 801 Relations ips

Neth Mier Rese ete os Resta ites and
Feunicrey Clezny,“cssty o Fna124 i eseteoe seg
sueseicaigeatunsrvawelheghl Herdxicnsercabon ge Giavetne?
sual pose avlaalifesanl nce Lg enn eagle soln eepeciets
a vevee ase. ssl poalel lapse, He cused rset are. Ea
‘nla: Seaperccese clans pate epee pares ad shear
Tuutkel ceuitoes: euilevitsik paler, fy Ee and meal Hex
elalSealth promet ak ut elec amd epstzmleeal vas fn
‘ulate escalate vee vital zevaeen and ojane lbs

‘ing Miler sa Sevecr Lessier 1a socto.ogy as Ono Ranks Wave
UR She hese BAn Socal Leeor, snd ur MSH Roverah Ma ees She
ceurtenly storing we et les. bese whe. Fa Tanp ial eta
‘womens snvisin «9 ruothortwed, Sle inca in Fas sorilogy hal

an ills Lesa maciioston 9 saps afewsryeretife he
ney tees she oer bes anaes fom fing avd werSiny ols Sol
Fane an Ropshadsss, ving bastiae 2 iger daveias© west Tse

sv Tn se gs ara Cater

aver Pam i¢ Y2erater in Rénaicioy, Teatning aul Viselcgurent a He
Eiahwsts 1 Shele This lraces “car'hg Meron boc

nese at the Lesied Kovels Fins ane Siapsmne Fa ac king on oe
egeae a setolo ens are alycaa tees sas hs Boda score
eri i le eprom got ue eto lan 6 ~ Fo too Et
ean ncaa nn. tet tape fasts no anes Hheaseas
stuns as cdt.ow ane ape Fads then OF artes aces sth
Eo coated Ualtee bee as rsh she hgose sca 20 €&
Comapasuass rated to bola ears ians Sc Res: Asia eguntes

Jane Rithonsie 4 Sesto: Leto a Sool al Gaba Boasts css
(Cahors ts Dattlur ose Conssct asic Beaokeld Research

Fle yd ce

ig. ana que smear metus, espace eS see aesticaraa
sU 2 Stvies Hermit. punbiious aol ch soe ual Tao Caete
1 Fesanstr $3 oun op esters 85), tor nat Fee

linat neth Bitars urd, Mars Higess gin Abed Faker dy
Haters tates” Chevy Seuss Slots 1 Me wen Danks an

An Baer, 19; ed emestloscip fei Heat Seog w+ smal
elo? Bis Svs nora Fr 1385, 18:29 She isa al
cate ee icinp ane teperencing er acy areegscsL ae
tus and see anoee soogssenssgen Cran ari es wgellet Sle 24529
Eas skghier shoes Ie sci etd carey fives us, bese sets
eal eves ha "91TH. fogs

oad so. ate Wt Se

Mic Some sa koceua stanivan wom? yahoos works Be
She tet Lecce es Souchag #4 inves ey ef Ram, CK, Her ree
fntoress icine bearazae ou ele" yan enh ati slgrasen ame

inwrigran, fai desplelon, ea auz erica ep

ay Standing fe 4 Leeuser mm Siwuen’s Simiee ge Tsai lob Moose
Thvsteity CK Ste ss extras. ansert ous @ DF on ne snaths ¢
inweosrnens in sir eh res sche al Seal bok ulcers. I
seve fastest im tke mes aki es Fr Rs
‘wie Hetintone ae hac leagues: an sca 308M
hist ally fens ering al anos Ge et MCAS
Teas ter semester
PARTE
INTROEHICING €

UR YOLCES:

1 Living on the Filges
Public Knowledge. Private Lives,
Peroni Eaperisuce

linc Lawes std Ja

So vie aa il 35s Foca and ter

Gd iy fi" aig a sii rts er ay ee
Meow's Dy ie ie turd ey ua eT chncugh aes sheers
hunwetly sue eosin, Onto Ws. sh eae a

pe sly seeks dead. me
thy Dil stave vests te ea lite gsm Dea
“We his ey i tid pal eile es nc

Slices bul ae usta. iar He eset pmo
ths eit eelesiou aerna vo expr I uetela ltrs ils oes
et Lnowirg abcu. te vial eek. au 2 Lesley ane pts +l yal
alive resents prays, ie anemples ts experes [uct a a ie

Sel of Topics. nich may be Ereay ssetbec ae seaceaies “4 “pet
ses trite £3 penvanel ved exerci, eae ese
of rscateh vg paicula’y sires: ibe af te itera eave
sea rascal isrenar ara ch
aS specials
nes vets in es pe

oe case cut alee

rah els

ion of rsa ocr

“Feis inograron st shenreial ad prec

legs znboeded 4 rh sel vess-ch aroces, ae rice ston a

Aaa teens a Henevan a ose of sscanch ry alloy

hin are th sslyervan share Zn parteian 1

reve pli 1 etait social scones “pi

lllos ns, 28,ataeleg, eral con't ane ean
viel ail soucrtica Ai-Pmete pee Hl

tees Ui ela a
te procer iz arabic es

{Gorn owe hot shea cone sae hat
nen Fae th 9 ie eo zyme an ora
pny a = aes

Tes figay et alge ane vheaae

esos
sleet Quests 206 5 Bi
eae parca 9 2oysis eos ed sscuts ht Lurie ersten uF
“estate teseeos 16 ase eecpes abl sube atte wees Ta nt
fire is evil pene rere. 86 ome. 2 Inge igh te Bowes svt

‘ag i oe opp fa E25 hes Ros Seem losteaee Is scat
ingress ok bo sed en 9 ieee ol pubes mace el
fess erases, Msieyeth a espicsing hae sphete wx seatscLers. fw
sursees laced al isle. horsen public wos! Ene lege oh! poh
bd experentes
Tans a aar toot 8 Fee gvamined “pre are “persons i
wos tine ac 0 AAT er sae, a pers poet
Deinish anal bone the Anvvignt Socal kx ytsNote alec
terse pusks hion.cdae ane seewala ard seal esting and i

(heme pevaemaced seh gs af easy theag_ Im ts ary ¥e ibd cu
Seoser at enna, lone Aicaers et we,

Thecitins oust etsw apie” a de eee: pees ar eb
fuitabo servers sce peuple Hh car 95m perc! ed seperti,

santahor we erabesg aus boo» phrase dT san aPeckire shel

‘ara enssuamang estos ea, 00 ne RE FONE Ue eI ee ecker
peyr's sifou es apd Uancateslers 1 par public rele
felge Same Vs ot wanes accor oe psi wis ant ad
‘sherveint seneany relic ai ft we hats aac hag, aed
Sys sa av the Raniedge we povctce, «esta #0 HEF HBO
veniet he hong hee sepenlad tu au zupuly 42 usr Toe ad
‘Hspoifact, ell wea sour el righ

tien Feshasopie ander soratieion espe eC usits, dkme
vis ane povsnea Hise sspelenge ama tatetsteastage Uno aul a
hoe for eae #4 erent ws sh ellesinen, Stl eaters ACLU
ni sbueesis and ier ar sues APs avelved i he socal co ston ne
fate! pc sori of noes tan Me domata of pu. aa: wee
trae wivin see Anhauisy rhe aise hea Rossel SILESIA a sete
fn icr denen ils 6 omrineng taht, arms amoneeige
hye prsttors hy aestval dire slings

Une 5 wenger toch eign a parila grees 3° pesceafes Fame
ef enewleege ie realness om, reac her sed or under: tod
bpateacnreg ee ror wvcenangeseire davingar sandeep

(era ak peut ey Hel Sef (TSE: Guetta gaa Smith, 1982) end
Dioteelt 108/905 lee cogil stengls oat ao Fe ii

rarpaeagrwis cae powvslunst gre“ elegy rare pul
Tones coumen an nvstatncinos Fah SO€aps i arts emee =
ones eaponinces, kesear tnt ie hit past Fal, arene e223
Teed #9 e8h goose ane Itser rstely “a tsenns af ie oe SA
Eovantie sclvaics 9 celal, tatu owle re alld m2 shave with ae
iexersensez on e poten Weel eeu sone plvars earnest
Devene chee Paine tal se pina Ie le seme tive hs ener (22 PEO

Sersman, Fa

formar bre eelorae sey
woh deve som

1 pepe sive hears he be
induc “wwa ste fsb se peapesoas
1383s ue gist the se rls ws po 8
couse JL anucae ere email nee face Lae ves of ao West
scene huh, shes pet Use en" 2isea ev ora
beeimes [vo open ep ake pitts for atawel 2, parlsh sue
veStanye 1Oag. 25 USL, Deeps Uns aptizasm. hoes
resecschersoy case deter canbe LestPe she ete. te a ABTS EE
Escotsst hot re pesipgeal ze predownine it Wesern kaoledge ees EE
sransale them tio w licautee reccamsnc.¢ te Wes.zem potas nhenees
dee, (be ered pra leave cen a pte saa zabugcet,
Risainge) Aosanie dacues ton dhe ema ‘solomziciow ie clen use 23
Sessribe tha relausa et soetus, dersinaien,Sice sugges shie east
re ecurtythesseh” —chefegeesn obs Waster zhataes
feaabastivent in eve pacesean and diserinatig oF ce
firmgh "the Ing snatng rn aves oF hema ts ane ser sk de
feusse iMehaor 99) 24) Whar ee

svsfeaprsad habhneaty dou tl soso sega eet so
eave spnitng a ths goaey a aliaarnne Hig sans ee snl
Nie tue ate a sogwentetive Tar iy assay to table sere
Hopacre Imad ly ssyemeigr igen Isto Lin ale gata

icc cll ale tees uilaomgy 8s fay ale a aeiaa be Be il Br
bite cerns uodieuce, se ange eae lly asso erp ae
fish au taetsanstge uf he On has daca toe ot Soto ete
(raf can be sheers. aid. acepind iy he docaiagt eter eter
sce hive alte te Sub Id olde Ober wees arab 3
Inet! bee uae es.ern uence anesh the teseercer a "eerphe
(as tebe Genugebwe nature cia Zorsimaice Lver ts Lie eeanehe tae
seth mice ervellcpusens x he ala ig selec, ks
tacky tel mote Zee Une sense. agen pus 32 aise est
ord ora marron oto the edge Ica, VS. esse a Wl 1998,
Devers, fe etiggest rng 2 ray be to e2ate an “her,
Fey she Weiter sescursca ft ireseuple at 33 centre af te cares
oorenl, Pauai 991 agence Be Wall 195, nes atguan tha she ain

shiv Renisan Flee Wovcd emia searchers and Tite Wir whore wi
incviably be exper, shares” ve goes iventoate ef the evar,

Ta saci caters ere vs erst 3 angie? 24 metholag

ok Aicoreg Alin 4 ie feetion, rae tenets eng “Psa ah
Eecnov enape aldnsti racation ane “nando red 2 near >
fend pesinsist wchoseleg eared recivane uaares vsta‘rh ala
uy enya enn
Lincertaneinsy o coneapes
are posed with, nasiasertcathor thant amaessfantewr choose
Feveuras. ayrg Fin a quaseeces rumevock see hae expla
the unr ying isemlogt bealeof their svere hae ere equ
tative asus) OF ee a2 gueliezs lesucs cen“ sevied eur wt &
pesitivie er aeheviaw ah signee <aradigr fe. for storm, che deboos
Benreon Wigse 992, yita, KRSbs, Riche. de9a red Dene: 21950,
savell Pan lps iseusia vin thsnlune: Parteese wher aro EEE
the eerie in 22alathe seu, sse7s"~ inch a ots an
aecetseiinasave a This ead sells = Fer eine ea a
ent, al snving om the seges 3", gi 2 ean, having “a engigs 8h
ein slovenia a

sokan eis vstene because
alii. relia” an veprsesteiveness

Sieg ea hy Hoes

Stuocnss qin eigad win zane mlacingiten Wlolo we sts

Seitnie vain el ks tea fel hietfsc byes pai ien

x

eo
lo shige spt wrote sks tote lest sae

Fats sry orenn cut es nono of eke ths one
Serge ae! ser rns pent sia sol beet ye se
srrehestrens iecoriems aber kre vo suresh aes ae ne

Nacas.a sant, f.cid. tbe mien se & especie een of koe odys
Jota thas whe vos soe ane sre you ae testes dacs ee cue
i ae kaom.cege vou peucuce ba ote Ha hes weston ake eat wa
caching to eostraeaivale La sotiedge sa sorecave ales tugs der
"es aeggost that, sates than arlene dsvoain we ase high standard
sd aka ead asounses dena he sices nce themrghout ey naira
Susy” eeestdsrng tx ikzskecions ef prcetial skciss You chs havea:
boing pinduced, Use eg snptace eases malieatioas in dst, 9 theo

Earns ef ls a seazcine eapsedge wah ate ii les sou
beset The poses fear che maracking.shcooi a ran ng ten
Finan alc nid pve seolal ot, at elvan

uslinad ste" 2ooe Brut teuggls te rahe @ stg all Top Gwe
sspsrerhs tan lp auch vies sn aml eas ps bh al ga

Sate ithe fes'acingei8 Semel fu solar ny sow” eal eg
ree a

The Winnevs Wokstay a sli eg

Thaeiue tase sab uotetine ators see! this eile’ eee che
fost Soir Rewslminy "seg ie sores "aubie ane “pewate 2 bo.
Jee s gonna ule sh ot ware fates see x AA gues om Mae

he sibare seers ines
russe er matter, hag aot hos wel undive.oed et azcored elie “se
thir eke staintsny os elmztines m2 whneh sve ose sacle al
Tevkacaes.akigs an spell alert, Uno oven be exe maeeshiy oe
SSiyoers Ba ke na.an Qienrs Silt bausckele Rescaoea, Je ore
i i colicin af al earent of pest sszabors el hss Warishep. and
Ts nor a suibor a the Wosksian are coatsibuters le his arse tee
fing the ie ea searhig all hae haz same pes ce La aroduelon
one sage, Ap thas" koe art

teell yp oithitses £4! eaasest and o shall spore se 0:32 oC thes
al ee spadal net =p tae Wivcehep fe sarlickes with se Wsioe
le hk

“The Rips ick! eye Q salt tive FamisBorsc eld Resa
inser plngrs sega “entice song conte ot Aoneae ane vias

pestieus ad copeialls wont » expe

ines Fhe csigica! mershenee al wars gin ISAT aber wae oastat st
A Peatgnl we Suiraner Soho tye sinal ky 2 Aalthie Soelsat

Asoacem, sinew Lee, he stoner fw eles ab aes ie Ht2 has Fas
ite betwern ve ad 9, Bap ea ah Tan ae the Wa esp
by weed el amauta. aliionga forue esametions ser trate se ae aloo

‘od in a postazede ga ke for BSA sere seny Ths cd
et sae owt Se-conscLsy wet seme ouL. Ea gee) hewitt
wotans Wee ‘od, tad eae Govan a tide vel the Wak

Alles nctars his Worksop Levojeres duce Jw ans hig
sesrgracunts deerralrerse es, ana we thi sbi gaia or the we
Js grsap ees sporatsc Whe deszacelsesareh muy soratmee bo regia
very aga ie ne ect ey toe eae as0arch 9 be rasta ee

sigaes sla ng wtead somtimes ae © habe ignsicest ime tor
stim Mr fy ie the mercene of ener into 22 ps
orks wren 4 éelig o@ eeiaant i hankieas Bexesen alr
Sa sats Tn Nias FS se ae sary Ras ee Belong
feelegwrt 4 lim fe fst songese sre ne tang oar
sie wih prieae nae fling Es gins nacre me Paiese oad
mi bis-puble sone acing While ica bigest asset aeanieas
fur aaae ses uneinvocebis* Teing) bea adeno uf tall aoe
sing tus. oF an pus lee se gga ea Eu amas BN aye
1988.20,

Srmerabere cf (ce Worsshop. tle inely Learn sae oe 1” goals

ca bees expel lial neat we Baie ofa rae ners? pon

to sien we saves. rarticulr ersoral etcareezt. bese! ype eur ls
tel exhrienes ead ka ace ‘The Sorkss9 us eaalidog omen wth
special ype o:corenesssat fe thelt seme ai eu aes Haas For
hs eps hick ifs esacecie precucien Beets te Eaom:rege prodt
This cess parisula mplcators ferploree teste iz snaeqten! dor
rors) fa how 5 wn hee” me

The ina” nwwns ol the Whrksen, Remsen persons! sad

fees and epcesee’
Dr copse ol neat, ta a ue

Fei ae va pest rae le aad Gnomes tate Teo
“oy tavotot ans svelte ho etry ation soc

vot IOKE Aon erscEs! sar anssiann ue takes acd bat eran
Sophie tae aiisuis susoundieg eae Pstinlees gnoeclian Moms

Heo en dri 2". soup SF yc nt secu Sich sop he
‘lace great based er dag fetes megs aed sa 0 en,
‘oval 0 atte ibe Sic tonazdfstution, ali, ade
vapacaneceteiale

The Wert: Wes tus emerges apes fy eich so eueeshobs ane
lait ke pos hee enansssu ie gassrhans tae Ti alg fe
Te vertines sn ena ttre cspoan reuse sel ye ee

wilt cd ign sdebace che Wocksbajics 3 sz anovsta i epg te
ving tiv le aera Foeo.ced ia ameatch ws me wunhger sech
cainber’ ens sing Tasies ang tkeuglns, ane hep ie sll sack ets

h 7s vesccue panes. Tis seck. ery sss 4 ne ramon of Fae
Sonate heat ar

obti sanante and pivare tes

Ye bth ose Lawes“ et ise cieeed a a

"ee wen satzation un 2 ciel wks Ickes tae heel Se ce
comes 9, eri ie Siren. Selig ake tual seme he ee

‘oe er PHD. shee ceneae ome sem wf thea ee

Suse 2 rie errs afaay eben sacauan hy te cater ee eee
Sppuantalsanitstma ice laanectargy iad ae
sof hss rates Sms ane san ompcbe ee Las

rel cnew 3

he prea eto. esr: ual ee tesa ula,
in hes dps nie hs sh larese iene, segs alive er his

SSoVKH Fass dase ens iv aethelge fr
fase "ssanacieane ef soap

tie morieeF Loxinone Diocese Kou, Ion ay besa seed
vue the acest Lor asaya yea ow ants oT tre soiaieg
alaudiesee" fasieegs onus metserslnarieee ca Teo renee
tiv esha ale wins pee aot niece ei as as hacame 4
froiacsheste see coscuch, orate sf gaia rane 2 he fn
(Geils sete ez ag eh aut 0 the, Her or back, sac aa et
sls cauteyed the song emcuors cel eve ca eos at ds gato

te teats vas! tore I ew he,

“ose eget, works. al tea eran wt
snsnts evasen lecvily ead aeadzais wards eal forms oo
olsugi #20 did toe gopeityencognsee ay scliey ar Sie oe

Segh, Horatio vsolacing (iz exporeness af xseen ia ees

ova har nna aso. fense AP the eenaae ats wiley ser i
engeing:3noah Es on ate ede, LANE 13-141 Wess ara
Suskvv inde seca snsees aie an sang #908 ide ane a Lee
Jevovieed on alr eenneo asgeats the tea zoe 9. bere J
Tero) ls wrens sian a bys ear aat were as
Sarin: ssadesiaily ne vive ve ne Went the ural. ae aos eee
fenedie trey. be soimicte cee and nati of poral ekecorst
Seeley am: reqs nike sainecvnm ite

Vive else ane gralzed enenner

sialyl cose ea anansae ts Bote

cons 2a sent. te
Sos torus, 1 sles ree

vise ef he neck
Le resanehang the sepsis wer none mca studs Rasen
ane te edad ize. toe ef hese Ii 1 worl in C13 tence
roving saavtrgctes isa ase ou Toe fn» swe Lal sean nd
sevwhos senseanes sowed an “bey ir evel one Whe Resa we
Sesh

hog sxtona her easvonrs with ce anszlion sewers peas
irae rar een valzsracd esas va ata sem pies ie nearer
ete filha ceadestewooles ed cere kagaleie i? emi

hoekspevsnaliy anda tecaiecP tring itorsieve” prc oes
ine sn dsranvlices oven azedene saceense,

Foniuist an ciniarie sstnisicgcs sorted vo oreede U8 ne
Jig wal soy 1 iv casing wit sez Eanes ed eagle
slgeacease cet ut can lecralonperiences Neve pels. edi eas
‘sigal Hs Mae haswre ews choos ef Kew fares nee, one
Jeol striy ne ewan ie vg devleped area mics ails he
pl per rele ton, sa 4 Donace nied by ae ene le
ace sotas rcv, work sll silly 29 man abd apy shes
rein cenecpssae ost to osue the dames aed 8 arate wit
the priv specs, J [39 lata sy Mara et Stecesieneution of

Une pobles (Seces, WEL we tad Ie se Atel isto Be ses cae
adnosde ane Retoeas, 28Le grin, lee a tks ont: 6s debate
around she woe a ke cone, of incest ii eeplcarian th Rens
rimeste ses ve ler tens es Stibhreasoal Fea dy O58) 20 se the
prone and sighs vibe pene soe tvs
si tp is beat) et shops

yaya toe ee a Boa
i

We hese wien Defy Bors pages ane Seale Be" an Ribboa
Ish ons OE R.Gses ne Kiba ad Cderd. 1995p Yoo the
Lerorpinet=ongke and te Ie > iteccnsae packs. 19
bri sang ovel me elite a av espsze sal bs a9 ude
essing ef feth es ssi mnons vee adie ed Westar soles,
Nie [eviaisl ale Lee sr ueotes swens sown th ise"asio
proses! pais and pobre spars at bw kod of eave wrt #39

Rone ott ate peices rt bebse is Me. fevmove UE exces the

Peurmipe ey sce senurts ai tc an sop bene
tre tue nano ach oes ey 9s chad oe ve a6 el oe spree
Irnscviey of si stage Wis ocopauce fa tres a2 geca “
Ukageat thetoiss se ane al emmy yo sea choag Qadir practesl
wien pari lands wi, nase2 sartcalar is
ovtes shoes, ane pvc L nests oes sa else ye §
Bie olan 1 993; omy angact! sleet acetone public and pc

pases atl Sowis sah Leal #12 Tea hese ae REL ar
{fred eal prlk’s perezpons nf wha cons.es pi and prs ih
ccending we soci entvn, Thus Pie azerinas su-sattngs har
Ee ways nv Hey ame expe: tee. can be quite Uist foe eifeeos
cual groups Inline wnegeiegs ata ter asacienci seal boul
‘ubrantage for por ioc 0005,

‘Pureszmoce. we she 2 Sieces' vin £19913 that ual «pee

i angy sone whee 3 78 onsite oz unT kM oF sis

hey casas ora hewevating He uy af the Seka, sear 0 iseplines
vores ten publics sirens. We sold fue Cet as pest sit ecm
inns such chet all nce well afer eneepte CE are: Fd mins
vee rand scucuye, bl “Fp ial gal Deinemated wo ce line ese

Geewe ised ay the sows; gel patel aves. Whis sou ris «he
“ite so solots Ue mlevanes at ane vil recom 2s [ae swing ca
Peaory, ard theses sslseanes te ke 59 steel sues: Mure. (97S
88 oa. thoe spws'e eH2 H4 regs ih these ee cae he
sows ions thal projhtazea d kena fe ieh sira Tess ane abet ine
Gai errr conesne wir ha vzen we do sb eh rep ety
Pose-ntha dnsereweal ul fonesstusesnewn devia era rubies an
Festa tinny based soucerss

Wige'an oleae “et pei acd eve! ave ey and au
ce coup. ish exes stay he hdesibee by eforence We pines
vations ef oie. zaigabous inca. wockplace ey wovrirment noe sts
Siply Fe vraysed sermgat rs: panésr focreues—ubtng hey ako
fotos bee srongly soraerad issn, Varkegs ne"s he Sah te
rescuer vat isthe ie a worn about ueludirg Smiths sta
Sioa rive of litera ‘weslee nf args sxvonal cousuigr tess. Caras

ssten 2 9311 of ‘eonstay ing Woneigh 3 abet, NRARIATEN e

Paste ti rie ”

Faves tea PMS we btu seus wererse) Gros sium dussee

vii iDaors #1 cL, BS Galea 1984h concer cet
Jecivkio' Mia! M8, atl ee ures as angaeet les Ges acca
edits co ens uf bast ae ner Serres DE Higher, FS
Tessed e.g Voge. betty ean 2

Ai fai censicer-

ise vininds Ge sb vetanew uncastndngs a (sce le ed
Sie, Silks. 998) aes nes St sto teva
nl hw 98: Wane TH, serine canst
‘igen 8d Jasckis WN: Tom, Sh face ness eet
‘Shea ingomte rd ssn 153. et anscage os eos
4, he, eet allure ae ple aut apache

we ssopet 19 Conner. 1383 Senin, 1583 Be Le ages Boone hen
1 caeares My stat Fras 433-205 a ottawa ee
dea contest in carowes lotsa stare ane insiegalbe
.siserner a gas ohalaer= ies e240 and 12 te eames Acals
of saucy proceees an epiterietins ce pele Svanaeerieis re
Tce: and pears) Of sr, eve sbaere serch concer ot fi

S52 £5 postive eur alos a2 leypeeians ard oo bo
sion eter te eth proses und ements heirs,
Fane in dis one spies al alemeasity andi Alia i
peste. Naeevtis iss, sos argue tha. eseaiciy I> prays penned
Enceltesazscal capeiesien sBer 24 gelatine Abn fev we se
flags eats wa ocssed Leng ell exe shore
ears of Cee dae sont Wit Feng diag 9 Fo al ie sl
ig Fhorsoviaogyalhnagh Fey Sein rye er dina

Sse Tesi ds sacke bersaar Nentctan al eevee ans pa
tics: usued ou uienesees in tenes af “vat a sie sala 2 move fod

corantal nonetzsenfenss ne pa ss! ies ieee wots cane st
oo The ssn 4 nse re are cad aces ens
fStauicetizes 9 unas serpent wu wel By Useraghacn. 1
Neate 1852) In alton, Nisher ag oslo Brees elation, betssen
hy Read pes af samesnal wo see st se ceases, hele ds
Avings epan Taaies sai terse

Sues diseactiars Asvelinct fom -Ige sete eoneare eh non
‘ges instal eels ih he eosin mated on ade Nat
fan seangonee tn sidest seal saynabs. evenemes, Ramnist hai
Bg 5's un 2s he gene a2 OF thes Powe
BE arte documenta ela oo aa ace lesa? sve.
leurs ero in fed mi eatsps wes 9 be Faeesad wae the pee
emmein Gi ng. “he tary stata sed Urbans an ie
Lats as a dine sot cdenyr gee, lee example, Aan sal Pos, [PA
Davidontor al 1956: Palen, LINE Seodd ane Cl. ISR, Si -Renesbo,
TSPSL THis rare rex ge hal we sed sah azop debe el nee ith
Ferinisrs aku: alt ko vale the diteronsze of oven’ Hons, based

TWegs'y nea low lesions eomieess sapereness or wl

‘sty based