Table Of Content=
eeeSe e e RRO Oe ee eid SeSe eS Oe See 8 SS ee OR ee eer LPLEE LLE ELE EEE EEOEL LE AO ee hteethetiettieietatttattt h teeta telietind eeee eeee rere errr ak ate diatce iated’ eee e FEE SSSS OWe e S eeeee e ee LLL LLL LLP EE LE SSS SSS SSS SSS er ee eee eee ere SESE OSS SSS ESS SSS OOOO Se LLL LLL ELLE EEE EEE EE TEER LSSSS SSS EPO SE™ LLL LLL LALLA LL LER EE EAE OE ee 8 acee tieteied LLL LLL LLL AEE EEO LPLLLLELE OLLLLE LL EEE EEO eres LLLL LLL ED Sde iedeieedinalietietediesied LLL LSS SS FH SSS Setieiendieedikcte: dietietit LLL LLLP LPL OL EAE an chethaliect cect Uae etic tea howe tate “Sapte Ae ara eta than eea rtnet ar aan = SSSSS Sa eee LLL LEE LOL LE EELS LOES OS O ° Ree a cec okeetetheththetint ietaiecieedeeteindintthti ettiee ih tetataenae SSSSS SSS SSS SSS SS SS SS SS eee ee ee SESSS EE SO a Se See thc aecincchetiet-the.tiediectlesthertipsithtee tite tnctitheetiete tint LLLP EELS SSSS S SS ee LESS SPSS SD POPE LE OO ee ee Se SPSS SSS SS SSS EB OF ee SES PSS GPSS SSIS SE a a ae . LEE OS LPO LE LLL LD SS ee . CS OSSe S OOSeS Se E ee Se ah aheediett atht hles tea hscieetcic ance ei tines eine neat See ee ed cieethesiliiiec het ht heaiest settee: oer lcd eee taeda elidel “eee SSSSSS ES Sya on— i lene nest insti Anciectinntinineinetinctaed SEEPSS SS OSS SPSS SOM — — LLL EE EO PELE LEED OO =~ - LL LLL LEE L ELL_—*E ck chesc tectheo taie tintiectietipnettecn eeitnnc t e etn nett LLL LLLP LLL LL EE LEE LLL LLL LLL LE EL ARE EE EIT ES EOS EES RS EE SS eee LLLP LLOEEEL EL EESE EEOEO OT De clitc hecliednndictiectiedietiestetinesticaltaise r’ LLL LLL ELL LLL LEE LLL LBLS m chcee etede tietts eet er etceeet tienee nrei aeee LLL OGLE OE LLL LOE aw Ne eck, deecthcteeetsn eat thetn t tiinx nt then Ate i ett aet ne! ELOS SSSS SSSE OSS SS SOS SS eS LELPOLOOLLBLL LD DE de kth tr cheatin tk ete tiveness need cecil tte eed IO Pe SLEEP LOSS ELE OE LOLOL EOE SOOT tolerate. atpntittiinet eitatieed’ EELS SS FESS SSS SS ee SELOELE EOEE CE FEET Senses OeSOE SR ees eeec e meaana SLES OSeS OSE SS SRS RE SS a eSeE SSS S SCS SBSSE EELS CEE LEO COTET EOO OO Ch oe eR ELS SSS SSS SSS PSS OS SSE SS —_———— - EPP OR ESE SSS ee PLO LELOLE ELE OEE LL ELS EFLEEOEOOL OE PE SSS S SSS OSES OLS FEO OO i nae PPLE LOE OO Core eS eee See eS eee ee=ee es e LLP LLORES LEEALER LE EE ~eee ewer SeS eeee= r oie dette ttc ae <atit erd SESE PEOEL LL © PPS L SORE TSS TOESTS SPELLS EEE LEE CES OEE ET ELLA LE ET aes PLL EE LATE ASS ES SS PE Se Se Se ew eS Re Gea eSS H ae —itincine LLL PLL EE SSS ELLA EEE ERE LE EOE TE - Neegec ekeecinctheaieata.chtesDtiteetd itye.oi tbed —_ LEAL PLE OD PA EE SSR ESS OPES SOO LLEPSSS P OSSE SLEEPL E LL LEE SS NE cecee atin eee tnta e NeeT 5 baht tee ere SESe Se
Rhetorics of Surveillance from Benthamt o Big, Brother
<n
a— ==
ep eSSe poseresrccces = Se ——— aSS ee e — = S= n== a : = = —- nomen ae
e
= n —
= ——e =
: S ee—
ae : Sate g eseeeene = ee Seeee
ee — y st . Lecte > aeeee S _— n = +9 i pus o — mseb) , and Peter Weibel
a 7 -
._-/
4
=
,
Se
’
'
-
-
te "
-
.
-
7 Be :
2
ee
¢
s
a
c
7 :
mM ally rics
aa ’i ] al
+ = & ae 6
CTRL = SIR Nod=
aa
Rhetorics of Surveillance from Bentham to. Big Brother
edited by Thomas Y. Levin, Ursula Frohne, and Peter Weibel
ZKM
Center for Art and Media |K arlsruhe
The MIT Press
Cambridge, Massachusetts
London, England
GRAND RAPIDS PUBLIC LIBRARY
A publication by the ZKM |C enter for Art and
Media, Karlsruhe on the occasion of the exhibition
CTRL [SPACE ]
Rhetorics of Surveillance from Bentham
to Big Brother ‘
ZKM | Karlsruhe
12 October 2001 — 24 February 2002
es
© 2002 ZKM | Center for Art and Media,
Karlsruhe, Germany; and Massachusetts Institute
of Technology
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be
reproduced in any form by any electronic or
mechanical means (including photocopying,
recording, or information storage and retrieval)
without permission in writing from the publisher.
Individual texts are copyrighted by the respective
authors.
This book was printed and bound in Graz, Austria,
by Universitatsdruckerei Klampfer GmbH.
Library of Congress Control Number:
2001096063
ISBN 0-262-62165-7
THE BOOK THE EXHIBITION
Editors: Curator:
Thomas Y. Levin, Ursula Frohne, and Thomas Y. Levin
Peter Weibel
Curatorial assistance:
ZKM | Karlsruhe Publication Program: Sabine Himmelsbach and Ursula Frohne
Dérte Zbikowski, editor
Ulrike Havemann, assistant editor Project Manager:
Sabine Himmelsbach
Assistance:
Katrin Kaschadt, Miriam Stiirner, and Jens Lutz Assistance:
Anke Hoffmann and Katrin Kaschadt
Special thanks to:
Elke Cordell, Anna Elkins, Julia Heine, Andreas Registrar:
Kiihner, Stephanie Liike, Anna Reiss, Bettina Gina Lindner
Schénfelder, Joachim Schiitze, Marco Sonntag,
Franz Wamhof, and Thomas Zandegiacomo Technical Manager:
Del Bel Martin Haberle
Translations by: Assistance:
Sarah Clift, Pauline Cumbers, Beth Drenning, Volker Becker, Jan Birkholz, Claudius Bohm,
Jeremy Gaines, Andrew Homan, Timothy Jones, Martin Boukhalfa, Dortje Drechsel, Stefanie
June Klinger, Neil Levi, James Manley, Thomas Ebersold, Silke Felisenfeld, Dietrich Foth, Mirco
Morrison, Marion Olivier-Dalhuisen, Bernard G. Frass, Gregor Gaissmaier, Jiirgen Galli, Peter
Prusak, James Rumball, Michael Robinson, and Gather, Ines Gottwald, Ronny Haas, Sebastian
Lisa Rosenblatt Hammwéohner, Werner Hutzenlaub, Daniela
Jakob, Oliver Klingel, Gisbert Laaber, Thomas
Copy editors: Linder, Thomas Linder, Christian Nainggolan,
Charlotte Eckler and Lisa Rosenblatt Masahito Okamoto, Christiane Ostertag,
Sebastian Reiter, Hans Schaller, Bernd Schoch,
Designers: Eva Seufert, Marco Sonntag, Gregor Stehle,
[thinc]2 communications, Cologne Manfred Stiirmlinger, Keyfo Temur, Emil
Michael Throm and Sabine Regh, design Tomasson, Christoph von Throtha, Gabriel
Anna La Tona, Matthias Rincon, and Eike Vormstein, Werner Wenzel, Christian Wetzel,
Verfiirden, design, lithography, and production Predrag Zaric, Elke Cordell, and Anna Reiss
Conservation:
Tilman Daiber and Iris Winkelmeyer
Educational Program:
Bernhard Serexhe
Public Affairs:
Carmela Thiele, Sabine Peters, and Petra Mayer
Website:
Tom Fuerstner, Lydia Lindner, Petra Kaiser,
Anna Elkins, and Christoph Pingel
7 : A aaa)
: Fy
eet OT Ae i; e
' he teeel? qorte4 I :
’ _
a ( ca) Coreg dys) 26 ra
oe = cota a
ee ee
_ ?
; >
Ogre ; - : ie i1i+-° =" oe OS®. we ghee= =
me ee © eR eee i
a’
_ -_
