Table Of ContentCritical Muslim 2
The Idea of Islam
Critical Muslim 2, April-June 2012
Editors: Ziauddin Sardar and Robin Yassin-Kassab
Deputy Editor: Samia Rahman
Publisher: Michael Dwyer
Managing Editor: (Hurst Publishers) Daisy Leitch
Cover Design: Fatima Jamadar
Associate Editors: Abdelwahhab El-Affendi, Muhammad Idrees Ahmad, Iqbal Asaria,
Michael Muhammad Knight, Vinay Lal, Hassan Mahamdallie, Ehsan Masood
Contributing Editors: Waqar Ahmad, Merryl Wyn Davies, Farid Esack, Iftikhar Malik,
Parvez Manzoor, Usama Hasan
International Advisory Board: Karen Armstrong, William Dalrymple, Anwar Ibrahim,
Arif Mohammad Khan, Bruce Lawrence, Ebrahim Moosa, Ashish Nandy
Critical Muslim is published quarterly by C. Hurst & Co (Publishers) Ltd on behalf of and in
conjunction with Critical Muslim Ltd and the Muslim Institute, London.
Distributed in the United States, Canada and Latin America by Oxford University Press, 198
Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, United States of America.
All correspondence to Muslim Institute, CAN Mezzanine, 49–51 East Road, London N1
6AH, United Kingdom
e-mail for editorial: [email protected]
The editors do not necessarily agree with the opinions expressed by the contributors.
© 2012 Critical Muslim and the individual contributors. All rights reserved.
C. Hurst & Co (Publishers) Ltd.,
41 Great Russell Street, London WC1B 3PL
ISBN: 978-1-84904-221-5
ISSN: 2048-8475
To subscribe or place an order by credit/debit card or cheque (pounds ster-
ling only) please contact Kathleen May at the Hurst address above or email
[email protected]
Tel: 020 7255 2201
A one year subscription, inclusive of postage (four issues), costs £50 (UK), £65 (Europe)
and £75 (rest of the world).
The right of Ziauddin Sardar, Robin Yassin-Kassab and the Contributors to be identified as
the authors of this publication is asserted by them in accordance with the Copyright, Designs
and Patents Act, 1988.
A full CIP record for this book is available from the British Library
A full CIP record is available from the Library of Congress
THE
BRITISH
Ma mUSEUM
Discover the
Islamic World at
the British Museum
From early scientific instruments
to contemporary art, explore
how Islam has shaped our world
through objects for centuries
britishmuseum.ot1!
Great RusseLL Street
London WC1B3DG
Holborn, Russell Square
Mosque l £)'!"! p. bnemeii^ glass.
Svi-i^cA:-" 1330-1=M5.
OUR MISSION
Critical Muslim is a quarterly magazine of ideas and issues showcasing
ground-breaking thinking on Islam and what it means to be a Muslim in a
rapidly changing, increasingly interconnected world.
We will be devoted to examining issues within Islam, and Muslim socie-
ties, providing a Muslim perspective on the great debates of contemporary
times, and promoting dialogue, cooperation and collaboration between
‘Islam’ and other cultures, including ‘the West’. We aim to be innovative,
thought-provoking and forward-looking, a space for debate between Mus-
lims and between Muslims and others, on religious, social, cultural and
political issues concerning the Muslim world and Muslims in the world.
What does ‘Critical Muslim’ mean? We are proud of our strong Muslim
identity, but we do not see ‘Islam’ as a set of pieties and taboos. We aim to
challenge traditionalist, modernist, fundamentalist and apologetic versions
of Islam, and will attempt to set out new readings of religion and culture
with the potential for social, cultural and political transformation of the
Muslim world. Our writers may define their Muslim belonging religiously,
culturally or civilisationally, and some will not ‘belong’ to Islam at all.
Critical Muslim will sometimes invite writers of opposing viewpoints to
debate controversial issues.
We aim to appeal to both academic and non-academic readerships; and
emphasise intellectual rigour, the challenge of ideas, and original thinking.
In these times of change and peaceful revolutions, we choose not to be a
lake or a meandering river. But to be an ocean. We embrace the world with
all its diversity and pluralism, complexity and chaos. We aim to explore
everything on our interconnected, shrinking planet — from religion and
politics, to science, technology and culture, art and literature, philosophy
and ethics, and histories and futures — and seek to move forward despite
deep uncertainty and contradictions. We stand for open and critical
engagement in the best tradition of Muslim intellectual inquiry.
Crescent Films is an award-winning independent
production company with a record of producing high
quality, original and entertaining television programmes
for, amongst others, the BBC and Channel 4.
Based in London, Crescent films specialises in
documentaries on South Asia and the Muslim World. Our
recent productions include ‘The Life of Muhammad’ a
three part documentary series for the BBC, ‘Seven
Wonders of the Muslim World’, ‘Muslim and looking for
Love’ and ‘Women only Jihad’ for Channel 4.
www.crescentfilms.co.uk
[email protected]
CM2
April–June 2012
CONTENTS
THE IDEA OF ISLAM
Ziauddin Sardar INTRODUCTION: WHAT’S THE BIG IDEA? 1
Bruce Lawrence MUSLIM COSMOPOLITANISM 19
S Parvez Manzoor JIHAD, ANYONE? 40
Samia Rahman ‘THE RACE OF WOMEN’ 57
Michael Muhammad Knight THE TAQWACORE VERSION 75
Soha Al-Jurf DO YOU BELIEVE? 85
Carool Kersten HERETICS 101
Ben Gidley COUSIN TROUBLE 123
ESSAYS
Stuart Sim THE TYRANNY OF PROFIT 137
Andy Simons ALL THAT MUSLIM JAZZ! 156
ART AND LETTERS
Robin Yassin-Kassab ERBIL DIARY 167
Hassan Blasim WORK FROM IRAQ 178
Ahmad Saadawi
Nazand Begikhani
Samarqand al-Jabri
Mimi Khalvati FOUR POEMS 184
Said Adrus LOST PAVILIONS 188
Aamer Hussein SHORT STORY: THE MAN FROM BENI MORA 197
REVIEWS
Ehsan Masood MARYAM AND THE MAULANA 209
Iftikhar Malik PAKISTAN: RECKONING AND REDEMPTION 226
Hassan Mahamdallie BEING AMERICAN 236
Jerry Ravetz THE ARABIC MAIMONIDES 240
ET CETERA
Vinay Lal ASSESSMENT: EDWARD SAID 245
CITATIONS 261
Merryl Wyn Davies LAST WORD: 9/11 AND ALL THAT 271
CONTRIBUTORS 279
Istanbul: Model for Muslim Cosmopolitanism?
The Muslim Institute is a learned society providing a space for
its Fellows to freely debate and discuss the intellectual prob-
lems and issues facing Muslim communities and the wider
society. Our aim is to stimulate excellence in knowledge and
thought.
Become a Fellow to enjoy the facilities and activities available
to help you engage with the best in contemporary thought
and ideas.
Benefits of joining
• monthly gathering
• winter conference
• dynamic website
• Critical Muslim
• free books and monographs
website www.musliminstitute.org [email protected]
THE IDEA OF ISLAM
}
INTRODUCTION: WHAT’S THE BIG IDEA? by Ziauddin Sardar
MUSLIM COSMOPOLITANISM by Bruce Lawrence
JIHAD, ANYONE? by S Parvez Manzoor
‘THE RACE OF WOMEN’ by Samia Rahman
THE TAQWACORE VERSION by Michael Muhammad Knight
DO YOU BELIEVE? by Soha al-Jurf
HERETICS by Carool Kersten
COUSIN TROUBLE by Ben Gidley
