Coal Waste Impoundments: Risks, Responses, and Alternatives

243 Pages·2002·10.32 MB·English

by  National Research Council

i
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. IMCPOOAULN WDMAESTNETS
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit Risks, Responses, and Alternatives
ed from thosed from XML files creatypesetting-speding styles, and other tion as the print version of this publicat CBoomDamrCidvio itNostmeinaoem tnE iooi aotnntrn eatCh elE o RSoaancerlti s hWeEen aaaacrrncsetdhthse LR aCInimeofdseup o RnSouceutriuscnldoedisumersceensts
been recompd breaks, heaease use the
s orPl
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted.
the ori liginal;ccident
n ofe orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a NATIONAL ACADEMY PRESS
ogiai Washington, D.C.
Aboriret
ii
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. MNotfNhofaOer iStn aicTceopoTi InepSmChanrailmoEcfs Rpee :istsrt eyttTi,use a thaedethenae yer r d b epcwN sarhHpoala aCeostjnie anosocclsunutteih panb.t lphclA eoaAil dtrf, ctm oiewasrdd i htnt ehhboimeseyst e yrsra aue mnotbpi feoajo eEmgnrctr.n bt ew Ageoeiermnfns ryet eeha e noricrsetpih n birodngeesrip,taeo waownnnre sntfde, o w nfftrrhi aonttehshmd eeIain inptNrshg ptsaesirptt, o iucecovotconeeiun daaoncll f c blcA uiyMolscs mti eahooddpenfie e sctGmt,hie noeoyne vr cN. oe reTfears ncth Siaioeocnnm nigmdea m nBlew cmeAoientasbchdr ae adardrn etsoeidg omfo an tftrhyshdee
al papmattinative v eoxrgparensizseadti oinn st hoirs apguebnlcicieasti othna ta rper othvoidseed o sf uthpep oarut tfhoorr (ths)i sa pnrdo djeoc tn.ot necessarily reflect the view of the
e origincific forauthorit ILnitberranrayt ioofn Calo Sntgarnedsas rCd oBnotrookl NNuummbbeerr 02-0300190-9078321581-X
ed from thosed from XML files creatypesetting-speding styles, and other tion as the print version of this publicat AN2BW82hCCP001trooodatia002ptxnpvdsi1––: tyeioh/2e6 t3/rrnCiidw8:i23no ag o5O44gnwilhnn ––taArtow sl63i t gt2nch23c.ini0,ateo41n uda0D p23atUpe2iil Com.e( nebiins lind2yy lt o ueuA0 tPtfdsh0hv tr te5reSeeh a5 Ws.tiNt,assi N otaarenetsWsihp oboionynfra gtAVl t aoAmarnence amarNdivcegeaatmuirloyaypeb noole.lfi tfSarconim eanr:ecae)s. All rights reserved.
been recompd breaks, heaease use the
s orPl
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted.
the ori liginal;ccident
n ofe orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
iii
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution.
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit sTohcei eNtayt ioofn dails Aticnagdueimshye do fs Scchioelnacress e ins gaa pgreivda itne, sncoiennprtoiffiict, asneldf -epnegrpineteueartiinngg
ed frobeme tn hrecomposed from XML files creatypesettind g-brsepaeks, heading styles, and other tion aes atshe e use the print version of this publicat cosrEnaAruttAThheeehcsuehnclsseleehabeteegape srieCdfc fdaioettNeorntsreeanotvidcre,msaornsn e he e teitnidogmhybr,risn fioirae oi dnno ecpelnl tfieggsnf ogrh tagd eiyse tu Eetalo sies ns icrflniA Nn vnesdoaoamgger ocegrtfa1iae re i nantea8slenndmit dedspon6w m eeo tevobn3geeorefmienea,idir sl nntnrtsslfituhyhs gnaoh.etA,ce e r.gre eoIo esa sct NrffnAh.t t asu ehiiaE aU.dsrcosne rtt Decnaip ignhaofnmdigoiu eerengane.inrdtyn an nemaoW ew lttenedo nrihyArieafc mfoetir irle hcnhc e mSi .aga ga on stcuAadohos efgipnte v eeua.has rmd e wnrscWo oNrm c ciyrtganieaheieun sarmtnotcs,ay ln i ecf,fihoema d t esoannnSinsat sfsstaaa icdt a. c tlbneai pa h TdearA idl rtnemimlepheh s c ctcameschaeeaieor ihntceddNsdaa gahdi.r elte aasrennl tmntittteeqioen irtlrmzyoural so 1eoo nitg.oersig9fra erefoDg ly6a ttst nSahAhi 4nr anin. cet,eta cn geiiB uanetzNdds onndrnadu atu tdeact aopoiticmteedoi n eietsrioovnyhr t tn nttiMi ebhhhoosoaaiyeeeerffrll.
s orPl The Institute of Medicine was established in 1970 by the National Academy
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted. tApohrfceo Sa fpdecuseibsemilnoiyccn .eos Ts fi hntSoe tc hIiseneen scetcuxietrausemt beti hyna eaci tttsissoe ucnronv ondifceg eprr esot hsloisecfi yo ree nmmsapalio ntctneehsnraisbtr tpimeleirter yttmao gi bnbiveienre asgn n ott oofa dtathhvpeeips hNreeoraa pttliortoih tan hotaeefl
the ori liginal;ccident fceadreer,a rle gsoevaercrnhm, aenndt aenddu, cuaptoionn i.t sD orw. Hn ainrviteiayt iVve. ,F tion iedbeenrtgif yis ipssrueessid oefn mt oedf itchael
n ofe orien a Institute of Medicine.
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b StaTopedpohccveleihirie caNsnnitieoiancnsltge goid os gteahn yitgeaen e wlr fn m1Reci9dtyiehne1 so ere6tafdha l btre bogco yAho ta hvt csC heatsehrodo enAue cmNnmcicaaeayidnttl’ie etosw. m n tpFahayusule, rn Ao tpbchrcgotreaiaso odCneaneisodmzi nuoe ycngdf o c ofbiimnufly rS hamttchachiusceee onrbnNriicendatecytagsoin omoakcnnnfeead o lswt wAtchhieicltee hea pnNd drgcgieaenemtenci oayeiapnr nnoaaaddflll
egp Academy of Engineering in providing services to the government, the public,
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr ajAonlidbn ettrhltyes sbacnyide b nDotitrfh.i cW A amcnad.d Aeen.m gWiineuesle far ainnrdeg tcchhoeam iIrmnmsuatnniti tuaietnesd . o vTfih cMee Cecdhoaiucinrimcniela .ni sD, arred.s mBpierncuitcsitveee rMleyd.,
PDF esettind so of the National Research Council.
ut this nal typned, a www.national-academies.org
ogiai
Aboriret
iv
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. GFRAARCNYKO ALM.IDNAM MVI.ITOS,RT UREn, EiJvR e.Or, sCiNthy a CoirfO ,T SeAtnaLnnfe osWrsde eAU, SKniTnvoeExrsv iIitlyMl,e CPaOlifUorNniDa MENTS
pnv
al pamattiative BC.ADRABVAIDRA H AEN.FRILYA, SB,e Karndi gThetc Phineosloolgdi eCso, nInsucl.,t iPnigt,t sDbuenrgvhe,r ,P Cenonlosryaldvoania
e origincific forauthorit NORIBndEeRpTen deRnt. MCoOnRsuGltEaNntS, TEEdmRNon, tonU, Anilvbeerrstaity of Alberta (emeritus),
ed from thosed from XML files creatypesetting-speding styles, and other tion as the print version of this publicat DRRMDCRJAOIALAOACCIBJVNDNHKAKCIEnI ATAWo DedRVOnnNRe T.Tts.pASNRu Du IMeTcS.lA nNLLtkJEDa.dM.Sy..EnESSSeAItWWnPACTN,L tLDRHN GMEECEAeUIIH,oAS ,nG CSn,Pv,N A MsTHEeUeu,rnREn Ainl,nAn tgRDiCaNsevipn,ny,o e, pte lUlr,SvUaoe sSCnhalirra.atsaniSehyfvc dpieI.e hae onohts riytfaSeGase prinKtrtedae nyaoat aMa eMnnlokto dsiUifeigona l,Kni nlsiVcen,iHae arvgLlin le,reI tagnaraIuwsniSlcncntic.udhtrk,iy.e ar y,F,nv E ,SocUe AnLcreygntdoe iimCtxnvt(iseeoeindnemlrglasriisetiilnontetryrsn,gia ,t A ,PutC isaIoro)nirn,zklc oo.,rIn an(aLeddmeoexpeierningtdutoes)nn,t ,
been recompd breaks, heaease use the DNARVCI SDt aRf.fWUNSCH, State Geologist of New Hampshire, Concord
s orPl TAMARA L.DICKINSON, Study Director
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted. KKMKAREORIRNSIET IHCNE.A NML .ROLIM..OLKHIRRPOEAS,FC PR,OF Se,Ms eRenBaeiros,c reRh aP erArcsohesjas eAorccctsh isAa oAtscessiaisstitesatanntt
the ori liginal;ccident WINFIELD SWANSON, Editorial Consultant
n ofe orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
v
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. JSAUMSAENS CM.C.LOCABNOBDM, OKMNen, tICuTchkTayiEr G, ETeho OolomgNaic sEaslo ASn uRPravTretHyn,e rLR AexEsisnSogOctioaUnteRs, CDeEnSver, Colorado
pnv
al pamattiative VGIRCAKHI AJ.MCO AW.DAARVTI,S C, oCloolroardaod oG eSoclhoogoicl aolf SMurinveesy,, GDoelndveenr
e origincific forauthorit PM.GUERORFAFYR EWY.H FIETIZSMS,A CNo,l lCegoelo orfa dWo iSllciahmoo al nodf MMainryes, ,W Giolllidaemnsburg, Virginia
ed from thosed from XML files creatypesetting-speding styles, and other tion as the print version of this publicat DTRHRMLPJAHHAI.IUIBCAMLIOWGRLHNCETEMHLURAnOiNStI vAECyRPPN EiMNESr. D TMoHR C.JT nMAJ.I..EmNIWO.CYSPc ePI’HETPLAENn.LIEAWOtLRNEaFGERSDlII,I L ELLOLS,N, ,JMD HaNW WoRCbI,r.,E oNal, tRJ ehUIrrCRGvEadI .CtGate, Ra,o Rl laEhHiTar,fre y nnoUeoTsD,vdxrol ,ninIi-e aundrIoCipsodraaac aclna A haiSIrehfmolnts&ft mo sas,CeF ,tMtIeNn ioeanItnt rnlua caUltpUctts. leio, n.on oL, rTi foinavCa vufatEew eliclTreonr s sEvsnIevoinietc,nint ysrlyhAg,aot, ,n iinA nnAtnCoudmaerlsot,hioe ehzelOerg,leoni ieyWnvhmntga,giia elol,Pa l aCesaSQnhsatduiaalnaditfigleooitntnoryann,i ,a SDaClt Lake
been recompd breaks, heaease use the NTARMC ASRtaAff L.DICKINSON, Senior Program Officer
s orPl KERI H.MOORE, Research Associate
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted. KAREN L.IMHOF, Senior Project Assistant
the ori liginal;ccident
n ofe orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
vi
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. RJOAHYNMB JOO.ANAMDRO JDREAU ONSONL,O AEZm,A CoRrhuaTsiorH, PU eSntrCiovlIeeErusmiNty CC ooEf mCSpa alAinfyoN,r nDHiao ,Ru BsEteorSnk,Oe TleUeyxRasCES
pnv
al pamattiative DPAAUVLID B L.B.DAIRLTCOHNE,R J,R U.,n Uiv.eSr.s Gitye oolfo gFilcoarli dSau, rGveayin, e(sevmilelreitus), Reston, Virginia
e origincific forauthorit BAADRABMA MRA.D LZ.IDEUWTORNOSWK,I ,L Hoaurivsiaarnda U Sntaivtee rUsintyiv, eCrsaimtyb, rBidagtoen, MRoasusgaechusetts
ed from thosed from XML files creatypesetting-speding styles, and other tion as the print version of this publicat WGSDJBNAOUINIERILANLSOTCLNCAALHR ISiINENTGtOAty HE aLENKMf A. fRYITM ENL.U NRF.. HGGRFI.DEORN.EPELRRAE RSSN,RFI OOSC,,B U.NUIEWEIZ,,,nR C.UAiUKvGln,atei EareiDrvkhsfRifie rtUe,Drye rsUnc eioSttinpyovfcia reviSoreretofnsmr uicNsteteiyhten ,yC v tCW aoooadfnofr a sVor,Euc lRiielnrntsgeviatnniie,nrg orCoi ,aI noMn,m lcCua.em,hs nsBabtaraoicllaolh ttQoutensuse,a vtOltiisltnlyet,a rSioalt Lake
been recompd breaks, heaease use the TDAPAANAUMNVLEIAD MRM AA..CL. FLUIEN.TDANLIRC,E YSKRe,,I n SNPieorSnorO igPoNrrrao ,mP gSrr oeOangmfirfoa iOrcm ePf rfOriocfgefirrcaemr Officer
s orPl LISA M.VANDEMARK, Program Officer
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted. KKMJEREONRINSNIT IIHCFE.AENMR ROL T..OLK.EIRRPSEAST,C PEROFPe,,Ms ReABaedrs,cm eRhai enrAcsishestas rAoracctshiisva oAetce siAastisesstoacnitate
the ori liginal;ccident VYEVRONNAN EJ. BPO.FWORESNB, EARdmGHin,i sStreantiiovre PArossjeisctta Antssistant
n ofe orien a KAREN L.IMHOF, Senior Project Assistant
w digital representatioe breaks are true to thhic errors may have be STWHEIRNAEFNSINEIAOL DNK .SLWW.RIALUMNDSODORYNE, ,P, EProdrjoietjcoetrc iAta Als sCsissoitnsatsnautnlttant
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
vii
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. ripbneyev r msitephawTeekch iitniNsisgv Rt eorisCet s pp’ aropsno rudvtRb iledhtiepseacho shce rantdb ni ecRrdeeaienpld v o eiarrexentw pvdaei sercC wtsriioosetemuidc,n amdilbn iycat t osae cmiepnc.omd osiTrevsdhiniabdetnlsu ec apt ehlau snar wtpd cio whttshooie l s lepe onarnofss uscfitreoshedtri us tth hrtehaienste diitnrahe sppetdp eiritrnvueodpetvierooesnrndett
pnv meets institutional standards for objectivity, evidence, and responsiveness to the
al pamattiative study charge. The review comments and draft manuscript remain confidential to
e origincific forauthorit pinrdoitvecidt utahles ifnotre gthreitiyr roefv tihewe doefl itbheisr arteivpeo rpt:rocess. We wish to thank the following
ed sf robeme tn hrecomposed from XML files creatypesettoirnd g-brsepaeks, heading styles, and other tion Plaes atshe e use the print version of this publicat crTVeohicmreog mmRJATJJJJGSWirAnoao.aeyhSilamemmhsivicbldortalnetnheiyel emeeh,pieSta vr sasMnsohRtwr.ae m PEddKM uWsn.aCo e O a gr n.GoVrW.nGoMn.tMghldfDig.oh.eaa oA F. i,kotWecsrnt sntahcWld,uEeth,um ls hi fnMorklMegs tbeefeeHei,n ig rsleirssrsoClonoit,,.es,e,h nr E e urnEoVBspAgV, d celtrnSadoJeioilkiinrrrnmgorravir,rg,. gwd tiaf, niUWiDen eid dPnEiswnstetnnoeuiy,h rnoiea aidpaa o aevrvrtS an salUhiflyiPNecndnd srreer ohotnodwg assmsyAloin v tliseyivHCu tiomdeoseyewstersolneeerrt ar eooasecn totesln hcelfh idsfrootRtt i ueeenhyM afaMfel n i lta EtfcAn esoi iLbi onnsEnbonnIdo,augeneyt tmnawI vrar ss lSnvagcntieG icensyeiIdat rn.skrui erohs(v steaoCrtetniaredficr oavtmtt(ge ui treetrsoieptoemoe ,e fo nd nIMp eren)tt rar(hanciot.rtleiH.deu vo tosniroiSr)dre res(cpendreideobe) t rtneihtrmrc eegbeda ees)cnr,fo ,yo n aUrcencnl oduiitn vsssie Portrraensuulisectl ya tai snvBoedef..
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted. Btiinnhadsert etiNoptuanettn,ii odoJnren.ana, ltl U Renpxeirtsaoeemcdae irSndctauhatr tiCeeosson u Gnoaecnfo idllt, oh tgihtsihe cayartel wpSoaeurlrrltev erweryeas,v psG ioecenwaosri lrboilgecedio sf mto oEmru mmte neaitrnksi i tnuagswc. c ceAoerrerpdt paaoincnican etrthe eafdwut ilbatlhyyn
the ori liginal;ccident cthoen saiudtehroerdin. gR ceospmomnsiitbteieli tayn dfo trh eth ien sftiintault icoonn.tent of this report rests entirely with
n ofe orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
viii
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution.
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit
ed from thosed from XML files creatypesetting-speding styles, and other tion as the print version of this publicat
been recompd breaks, heaease use the
s orPl
ginal work hane lengths, wally inserted.
the ori liginal;ccident
n ofe orien a
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret
CONTENTS ix
ee
er book, not from thg, however, cannot bersion for attribution. Contents
pnv
al pamattiative
e origincific forauthorit
ed from thosed from XML files creatypesetting-speding styles, and other tion as the print version of this publicat 1. EINXTCACDFCISEmRtiooodiCunspOaaavdepUllloasyD ouWTPRn sDaUncrIaenoaVedilfCs dsddumopEtT u sefRoCe ecI SsFnIO etoIaUmitpiamo lNnHo lMpnPe prCo a troaMRuzolnueanebAdnarfdl ddnueRUm mimsRnYseeegse ani n nnitint nk FsI i Omatnihnigtlpe hu t oSehUrueryen ns sMUidttemeinmndieit sneSndgttsa SSteteasctteosrs 1122222337703456121
been recompd breaks, heaease use the 2. CUFSReuRdrfeEarNcaelT MM RiiEnneiGn SUga LCfeAotnyT tOaronRld Ya Hn Fde aRRlAtehcM AlaEcmWtatOioRnK Act 334551
the original work has n of line lengths, wore original;ally inserted. Plen accident 3. PLASOGISmulNetuhmpnRrNeoermeryruI faN Fnaualreds GnyIdemdm eC DeWrpaOniosltau A pLtDneoLadresw asmSMilsLg e PaannUnrn taaaR dScng RtidSeitcYm itCnae etgsoRen n CEtDsrFteirUtlueecSrgtiEaiaot eInM PrPoOgUraNmDs MReEleNvTanSt to 445556691297
ohe
w digital representatie breaks are true to thic errors may have b ICSmulompsoumurnaer daymnde nRt eScylastmemat iMononitoring 667890
egp
naa
file: This ng files. Pme typogr
PDF esettind so
ut this nal typned, a
ogiai
Aboriret