Table Of ContentAPPROPRIATING THE PAST
PhilosophicalPerspectivesonthePracticeofArchaeology
In this book an international team of archaeologists, philosophers,
lawyers,andheritageprofessionalsaddressessignificantethicalques-
tions about the rights to access, manage, and interpret the material
remainsofthepast.Thechaptersexplorecompetingclaimstointer-
pretandappropriatethepastandthemajorethicalissuesassociated
withthem,includinghandlingthesacred;contestedrightsoversites,
antiquities, and artifacts; the involvement of local communities in
archaeological research; and the legal status of heritage sites. The
bookcoversarangeofhotlydebatedtopicsincontemporaryarchae-
ological practice, focusing particularly on the relationship between
academicarchaeologistsandindigenouscommunitiesforwhomthe
materialremnantsofthepastthatformthearchaeologicalrecordmay
bepartofalivingtraditionandanchorsofsocialidentity.
geoffrey scarreisProfessorofPhilosophyatDurhamUniversity
andthecofounderanddirectoroftheDurhamUniversityCentrefor
theEthicsofCulturalHeritage.Heistheeditor(withChrisScarre)of
The Ethics of Archaeology: Philosophical Perspectives on Archaeological
Practice and the author of several books, including, most recently,
Death,Mill’sOnLiberty:AReader’sGuide,andOnCourage.
robin coningham is Pro–Vice Chancellor and Professor of
Archaeology at Durham University and cofounder of the Durham
UniversityCentrefortheEthicsofCulturalHeritage.Activeasafield
archaeologistinSouthAsiaandIran,hecurrentlyleadsaUNESCO
archaeological team that is excavating inside the temple of the
Buddha’sbirthatLumbiniinNepal.
APPROPRIATING THE PAST
Philosophical Perspectives on the Practice of Archaeology
edited by
GEOFFREY SCARRE
UniversityofDurham
ROBIN CONINGHAM
UniversityofDurham
cambridge university press
Cambridge,NewYork,Melbourne,Madrid,CapeTown,
Singapore,Sa˜oPaulo,Delhi,MexicoCity
CambridgeUniversityPress
AvenueoftheAmericas,NewYork,ny-,usa
www.cambridge.org
Informationonthistitle:www.cambridge.org/
(cid:2)c CambridgeUniversityPress
Thispublicationisincopyright.Subjecttostatutoryexception
andtotheprovisionsofrelevantcollectivelicensingagreements,
noreproductionofanypartmaytakeplacewithoutthewritten
permissionofCambridgeUniversityPress.
Firstpublished
PrintedintheUnitedStatesofAmerica
AcatalogrecordforthispublicationisavailablefromtheBritishLibrary.
LibraryofCongressCataloginginPublicationdata
Appropriatingthepast:philosophicalperspectivesonthepracticeofarchaeology/[editedby]
GeoffreyScarre,UniversityofDurham,RobinConingham,UniversityofDurham.
pagescm.
Includesbibliographicalreferencesandindex.
isbn----(hardback)–isbn----(paperback)
.Archaeology–Philosophy. .Archaeology–Moralandethicalaspects. .Indigenouspeoples–
Antiquities–Collectionandpreservation. I.Scarre,Geoffrey,editorofcompilation.
II.Coningham,Robin,editorofcompilation.
cc.a
.–dc
isbn----Hardback
isbn----Paperback
CambridgeUniversityPresshasnoresponsibilityforthepersistenceoraccuracyofurlsforexternal
orthird-partyInternetwebsitesreferredtointhispublicationanddoesnotguaranteethatany
contentonsuchwebsitesis,orwillremain,accurateorappropriate.
Contents
Contributors pagevii
Editors xiii
Introduction
GeoffreyScarreandRobinConingham
part one claiming the past
TheValuesofthePast
JamesO.Young
WhosePast?ArchaeologicalKnowledge,Community
Knowledge,andtheEmbracingofConflict
PiotrBienkowski
ThePastPeopleWant:HeritagefortheMajority?
CorneliusHoltorf
TheEthicsofRepatriation:RightsofPossessionand
DutiesofRespect
JannaThompson
OnArchaeologicalEthicsandLettingGo
LarryJ.Zimmerman
HintangandtheDilemmaofBenevolence:Archaeology
andEcotourisminLaos
AnnaKa¨ll´en
v
vi Contents
part two problems of meaning and method
WhatIsaCrisisofIntelligibility?
JonathanLear
ContestingReligiousClaimsoverArchaeologicalSites
ElizabethBurnsColeman
Multivocalityand“Wikiality”:TheEpistemologyand
EthicsofaPragmaticArchaeology
AlexanderA.Bauer
“Donotdountoothers...”:CulturalMisrecognition
andtheHarmsofAppropriationinanOpen-Source
World
GeorgeP.NicholasandAlisonWylie
ShouldRuinsBePreserved?
DavidE.Cooper
part three problems of ownership and control
LegalPrinciples,PoliticalProcesses,andCultural
Property
TomAllen
MonumentsversusMoveables:StateRestrictionson
CulturalPropertyRights
DavidGarrard
LootingorRededication?Buddhismandthe
ExpropriationofRelics
RobinConinghamandPrishantaGunawardhana
PartitioningthePast:India’sArchaeologicalHeritage
afterIndependence
NayanjotLahiri
References
Index
Contributors
tom allen is the Master of Grey College, University of Durham, and
holds a chair in law at the university. His main field of interest is the
intersectionbetweenhumanrightsandpropertylaw.Hiscurrentwork
focuses on the relationship between the rules of property law and the
constructionofcommunitiesandcollectivememories.
alexander a. bauer is Assistant Professor of Anthropology at Queens
College and the Graduate Center, City University of New York, with
research interests in Old World archaeology, material culture, trade
and exchange, archaeological theory, and cultural heritage policy. He
maintains a particular research interest in Peircean semiotics and the
ways it can be used to develop a pragmatic archaeological theory and
method.HehasconductedfieldworkinGreece,Israel,Jordan,Turkey,
and Ukraine and is currently Associate Director of the Sinop Regional
ArchaeologicalProjectinTurkey.Heisthecoeditoroftherecentvolume
Social Archaeologies of Trade and Exchange (Left Coast Press, ) and
hasbeenEditorinChiefoftheInternationalJournalofCulturalProperty
since.
piotrbienkowskiisacultural,heritage,andmuseumsconsultant;writer
and researcher; and Honorary Professor in the School of Arts, Histo-
ries, and Cultures at the University of Manchester. Previously, he was
Professor of Archaeology and Museology at the University of Man-
chester, Deputy Director of Manchester Museum, and Head of Antiq-
uities at National Museums Liverpool. He has directed fieldwork in
Jordan and has published extensively on the Iron Age in Jordan and
the ancient Near East in general, on the ethics of human remains in
archaeology and museums, and on community agency and sharing of
authorityinculturalorganisations.HeisCodirectoroftheInternational
Ummal-BiyaraProjectinPetra,Jordan.
vii
viii Contributors
elizabeth burns coleman lectures in communications at Monash
University. She has held postdoctoral fellowships at the Australian
National University’s Centre for Cross Cultural Research and Monash
University. She is author of Aboriginal Art, Identity and Appropriation
(Ashgate, ) and coeditor of a series of collections on the theme of
negotiatingthesacred:BlasphemyandSacrilegeinaMulticulturalSociety
(ANU E-press, ); Blasphemy and Sacrilege in the Arts (ANU E-
press,);Medicine,ReligionandtheBody(Brill,);andReligious
Tolerance,EducationandtheCurriculum(Sense,).
david e. cooper is Professor of Philosophy Emeritus at Durham Uni-
versity.HehasbeenaVisitingProfessoratuniversitiesinEurope,North
America,andSouthAsia.Muchofhisrecentworkhasbeeninthearea
ofenvironmentalaesthetics.Heistheauthorofmanybooks,including
APhilosophyofGardens()andaforthcomingbookonDaoismand
humanbeings’relationshiptonature.
david garrard has a background in academic philosophy but now
worksforEnglishHeritage.Heisinterestedintheintersectionbetween
aestheticjudgmentsandotherkindsofvalues,particularlyinthehistory
and theory of the conservation movement. He is currently editing an
anthologyofarchitecturalpoetry.
prishanta gunawardhana is Professor of Archaeology at the Uni-
versity of Kelaniya, Sri Lanka, and a board member of the Sri Lanka
Council of Archaeologists. He has edited several books and journals
andpublishedmorethanfiftyarticlesonarchaeology.Gunawardhanais
a Codirector of the Upper Malwathu Oya Archaeological Exploration
Project,acollaborativeprojectofDurhamUniversityandtheUniversity
ofKelaniya.HeisalsoDirectoroftheTerra-CottaProjectinSriLanka,
fundedbytheUniversityofKelaniya.
cornelius holtorf is currently employed at Linnaeus University in
Kalmar, Sweden, where he is responsible for the degree programme in
heritage studies. A prehistorian by education, he has long been inves-
tigating the intersections of prehistory, archaeology, heritage, and con-
temporarysociety,andheistheauthorofthemonographsMonumental
Past (–), From Stonehenge to Las Vegas (), and Archaeology Is
a Brand! (). Holtorf is currently finishing a field project on the
lifehistoryofamegalithinsouthernPortugalandhasplanstoinvesti-
gatefurtherthecontemporaryarchaeologyofzoologicalgardens.Heis
AssociateEditorofthejournalHeritageandSociety.
Contributors ix
anna ka¨lle´n is a Researcher in Archaeology at Stockholm University,
Sweden,whereshespecialisesinthearchaeologyandheritageofmain-
land Southeast Asia. Her main interest is in the role of archaeology
and the use of the past as narratives and materiality in contemporary
society. She is currently engaged in investigating the relations between
archaeologyandecotourisminnorthernLaos.
nayanjot lahiri isProfessorintheDepartmentofHistoryattheUni-
versityofDelhi,wheresheteachesIndianarchaeology.Shehasbeenthe
recipientofvariousfellowshipsincludingtheCommonwealthAcademic
Staff fellowship at the University of Cambridge (UK) and the Daniel
IngallsFellowshipatHarvardUniversity(USA).Sheisontheadvisory
editorial board of World Archaeology (UK) and on the editorial board
ofAmericanAnthropologist(USA).Apartfromarticlesinrefereedinter-
national and national journals, she has authored and edited six books,
including The Archaeology of Indian Trade Routes (Oxford University
Press) and Finding Forgotten Cities (Permanent Black). She was co-
editorofaspecialissueofWorldArchaeologyonTheArchaeologyofHin-
duism. Finding Forgotten Cities was a finalist for the Hutch-Crossword
Award prize in . She has been a member of the Delhi Urban Art
Commission.
jonathan lear is John U. Nef Distinguished Service Professor in the
Committee of Social Thought and Department of Philosophy at the
UniversityofChicago.Heistheauthor,mostrecently,ofRadicalHope:
Ethics in the Face of Cultural Devastation (Harvard University Press,
) and A Case for Irony (Harvard University Press, ). He was
recently awarded the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation Distinguished
AchievementAward.
george p. nicholas is Professor of Archaeology at Simon Fraser Uni-
versity.Hewasfoundingdirectoroftheuniversity’sIndigenousArchae-
ology Program in Kamloops, BC (–). He is Director of the
international research initiative Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural
Heritage: Theory, Practice, Policy, a seven-year initiative funded by
SSHRC Canada (http://www.sfu.ca/ipinch). His research focuses on
Indigenousarchaeology,intellectualpropertyissuesrelatingtoarchaeol-
ogy,thearchaeologyandhumanecologyofwetlands,andarchaeological
theory,onallofwhichhehaspublishedwidely.Heisseriescoeditorof
theWorldArchaeologicalCongress’sResearchHandbooksinArchaeology
and former editor of the Canadian Journal of Archaeology. His most
Description:In this book an international team of archaeologists, philosophers, lawyers, and heritage professionals addresses significant ethical questions about the rights to access, manage, and interpret the material remains of the past. The chapters explore competing claims to interpret and appropriate the p
