2 Comparative and Development Public Administration

1150 Pages·2010·3.21 MB·English

ISBN:0-8247-0436-3
This book is printed on acid-free paper.
Headquarters
Marcel Dekker,Inc.
270 Madison Avenue,New York,NY 10016
tel:[phone]; fax:[phone]
Eastern Hemisphere Distribution
Marcel Dekker AG
Hutgasse 4,Postfach 812,CH-4001 Basel,Switzerland
tel:[phone]; fax:[phone]
World Wide Web
http://www.dekker.com
The publisher offers discounts on this book when ordered in bulk quantities. For more information,write to
Special Sales/Professional Marketing at the headquarters address above.
Copyright ©2001 by Marcel Dekker,Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means,electronic or
mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage and
retrieval system,without permission in writing from the publisher.
Current printing (last digit):
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
To my son,Cyrus

Foreword
For the last decade, this collection of essays on topics in comparative and development public
administration has been a basic source of information for academics,practitioners,and students
around the world.
Professor Ali Farazmand of Florida Atlantic University has now planned, organized, and
edited this revised and expanded Second Edition, which updates and enhances the value of the
original publication. Although a large majority of the chapters have been retained,most of them
have been revised taking into account recent developments.
More than 20 new chapters have been added,increasing the collection to 76 chapters and
making it even more comprehensive and current. Most parts of the volume contain new contribu-
tions. The contents are organized in two main units,the first treating a variety of elements in the
study of comparative and development administration and the second dealing more specifically
with administrative performance and political responsibility. There are two major alterations in
the format,one in each unit. The first is a new group of four essays on historical bases of public
administration and bureaucracy, dealing with ancient Persia; Greece, Rome, and Byzantium;
India; and the Aztecs,Incas,and Mayas. The second is the deletion of a brief section on bureau-
cratic behavior and public policy,although one of the two articles in it has been shifted elsewhere
in the volume.
As before, the authors represent an impressive array of expertise for many countries, but
their contributions do not advocate any particular approach to comparative analysis. The result is
a collection valuable enough to serve the differing needs of a variety of users.
This is a welcome addition to the literature available in our field at the opening of a new cen-
tury.
Ferrel Heady
Professor Emeritus
Public Administration and Political Science
University of New Mexico
Albuquerque,New Mexico
v

Prologue
Public Administration always involves both processes and tools:the processes of implementing
public policy and the tools of public office. Officials bear the responsibility for turning goals into
realties—without them, policies remain only promises. In this context, development has two
faces:it may refer to policies that affect a society’s ability to achieve public goals,or to the capac-
ity of government agencies to implement these purposes. I think of the first as the administration
of development,and the latter as the development of administration. Of course,both need to be
viewed in a comparative perspective in order to reach valid conclusions. Analyses based on just
one case or country cannot discover what has general and theoretical significance and what is bet-
ter is explained by unique circumstances.
This second edition of the Handbook of Comparative and Development Public Administra-
tionis a greatly expanded version of a work that has already established itself as a prime source of
knowledge in this field. It is divided into two parts:the first dealing more with the administrative
processes involved in development (both economic growth and bureaucratic capabilities) and the
second part focuses on bureaucracy as a crucial instrumentality for these processes. Although the
work emphasizes development in less developed countries,it does not neglect the experience of
more developed countries:each sheds light on the other. Moreover,although the focus is on con-
temporary conditions,the book includes chapters on historical antecedents that put current condi-
tions into a deeper context. Whatever happens today needs to be understood by looking into the
past and this perspective also paves the way for anticipating the future more clearly.
The bureaucratic role in development is always complementary with non-bureaucratic
roles. Within governance as a broad process,the agenda or goals of development are normally set
outside the bureaucracy which is then charged with special responsibility for implementing pub-
lic policies set by others. The private sector,including entrepreneurs working for profit in market
systems and civic groups working for a wide diversity of principled concerns,is a partner in this
process in that they both support and constrain public officials. Public policy depends heavily on
their cooperation and initiatives to achieve its goals. Thus,both administration and bureaucracy
must always be seen as elements in a complex,as parts of a much larger system.
Nevertheless,the processes of policy implementation and the interest of bureaucrats as cit-
izens and subjects of a state inevitably help shape outcomes. We need to see these forces at work
in the making of policy,where bureaucratic interests play a role,as well as in the implementing of
vii
viii Prologue
policy where the capabilities and constraints experienced by officials help shape outcomes. In
short, the divide between politics and administration is always amorphous and fluctuating. In
some respects,we may even say that administration is just a form of politics. The chapters that fol-
low shed light on these phenomena in many ways,at different levels,places,and times. They do
not necessarily agree with each other or present a unified message. Rather,just as our world is a
manifold inviting multiple perspectives on complex phenomena,so this handbook offers the read-
er a wide variety of points of view and insights. Editor Ali Farazmand has performed a remarkable
service by bringing them all together and presenting them in a coherent pattern.
Fred W. Riggs
University of Hawaii
Honolulu,Hawaii
Preface
The second edition of this encyclopedic handbook is a major update—a revised and expanded ver-
sion of the first edition,published a decade ago. The first edition was an overwhelming success as
the only comprehensive handbook ever published that covered the twin fields of comparative and
development public administration plus the field of bureaucratic politics and administrative theo-
ry. It was well received,readily adopted by key scholars,teachers,and trainers at universities and
institutes around the world. Due to its overwhelming success,the first edition was reprinted sev-
eral times during the 1990s, a decade of historical changes that included the fall of the USSR,
sweeping privatization and governmental reforms around the world,and accelerating globaliza-
tion of capital with significant implications—both positive and negative—for governance,public
administration,and national self-determination.
The second edition of this encyclopedic handbook reflects these global changes with new
discussions of historical roots of governance and public administration traced in the ancient civi-
lizations,as well as original materials on ethics and accountability issues in modern public admin-
istration. Contemporary changes of significance demanded substantial revision of the first edition,
plus significant updates that reflect currency in the fields of comparative and development public
administration,as well as bureaucratic politics and administrative behavior worldwide. Addition
of the historical materials as well as new treatments of ethical dimensions contributed to the
expansion of the handbook from the 55 chapters of the first edition to 76 chapters,plus major revi-
sion and expansion of the chapters carried over from the first edition. The breadth,scope,issues,
and coverage of materials in the new edition take the readers well beyond the horizon of the triple
fields through their intellectual/conceptual foundations,development,and applications around the
world.
The purpose of this edition remains the same as that of the first:to bring together essays that
analyze basic issues and major aspects of the fields of comparative and development public
administration, and comparative bureaucratic politics and public policy. Aspects of each field
include a wide range of sectoral issues of industrial,urban,rural,agriculture,education,and other
aspects of development and administration. The major concerns of students of comparative and
development public administration as well as of policy makers include issues of changes,mod-
ernization,dependency and independence,government reorganization,administrative reform and
development,privatization,globalization,political economy of reform,ethics and accountability,
ix
x Preface
professionalism,and historical roots of modern public administration in the ancient and medieval
civilizations and philosophical grounds of both the East and the West.
Additionally, a focus on bureaucracy, bureaucratic politics, and political regime mainte-
nance,as well as alternatives to bureaucratic administration,can be chosen for comparative analy-
sis of administrative performance and political functions. Alternatives to bureaucratic administra-
tion have gained global currency. Much of this global trend in government and public
administration reforms has embraced sweeping privatization, which must be understood in the
much broader context of the globalization of capitalism.
This book covers these aspects and approaches, as well as a wide range of functions and
related issues. These include budgeting and financial management, planning and development,
personnel administration, public management, public enterprise management, policy analysis,
organization and reorganization, local and intergovernmental administration, globalization and
regionalization, civil service politicization, bureaucratic politics, administrative efficiency and
effectiveness, representation, corruption, ethics and accountability, civilization and administra-
tion,change and revolution,democracy,and more.
Such a comprehensive treatment has never been attempted before. Although smaller collec-
tions are available in the fields,they are narrowly conceived and have not gone beyond certain spe-
cific areas of the world. Most of these works either are grossly outdated or serve only a limited
audience. The new edition of Ferrel Heady’s Public Administration:A Comparative Perspective
is,of course,a powerful textbook and is well adopted,but it is neither a handbook nor an ency-
clopedia. The worldwide adoption of the first edition of this handbook as a primary textbook as
well as a reference book provided a strong impetus for publication of the second edition. The
result is a comprehensive and up-to-date volume of original materials on governance, public
administration,comparative and development administration,and comparative bureaucratic poli-
tics administrative theory and behavior that could have easily been published in two volumes but
is offered in a single volume for adoption as a primary textbook as well as an encyclopedic refer-
ence book.
The book is divided into two major units,followed by a comprehensive index. The first unit,
which is very broadly focused,is organized into 10 parts and 56 chapters It covers a wide range of
issues and aspects of public administration and public policy in developed and developing nations
of the world. Part I examines comparative and development administration in the temporal context
of past,present,and future perspectives,followed by a discussion of the problems and organiza-
tional aspects of development and comparative administration. Part II presents a comprehensive
discussion of ancient civilizations and administration,with original chapters on the administrative
legacies of Persia,Greece,Rome,Byzantium,India,early native America,and later European tra-
ditions that shaped the modern enterprise of public administration. Part III presents 11 chapters on
public administration in more developed nations of the West (North America and Europe), the
East (Japan),and Australia. Of these,five chapters are entirely new,while others have been revised
and updated. Part IV offers impressive material on public administration and governance issues in
the former Soviet Union and eastern and southern Europe. Part V presents nine chapters on vari-
ous aspects and issues of public administration and governance in Asia and Africa,with the most
chapters focusing on Asia—covering countries from China,Thailand,and Korea in East Asia to
India. Kenya,Nigeria,and southern Africa are covered by three other chapters.
Part VI covers various aspects of public administration in developing nations of the Near
and Middle East,Latin America,and the Caribbean; seven chapters—three new and four revised
and updated—analyze such issues as state and public administration traditions in Iran from
ancient times as well as contemporary reform in that country,bureaucracy and reform in the Mid-
dle East and Latin America,local government in authoritarian Chile,and state administration in
socialist Cuba. Part VII presents two chapters examining the issues of dependency,independence,