Table Of ContentPublic Policy and Mass Media
The mass media are playing an increasingly central role in modern political life
that expands beyond their traditional function as mediators between the world of
politics and the citizens.
This volume explores the extent and circumstances under which the media
affects public policy; whether the political impact of the media is confined to the
public representation of politics or whether their influence goes further to also
affect the substance of political decisions. It provides an in- depth understanding
of the conditions under which the media might, or might not, play a role in the
policy process and what the nature of their influence is.
Bringing together conceptual and methodological approaches from both polit-
ical science and communications studies, this book presents an interdisciplinary
perspective. It presents empirical evidence of the processes involved in the inter-
action between mass communication and policy and features case studies from
Western Europe and the United States and across different policy fields.
The book will be of interest to students of public policy, political communica-
tion and comparative politics.
Sigrid Koch-B aumgarten is Professor of Political Science at the Department of
Political Science, Philipps University Marburg, Germany. Her research focuses
on German and international industrial relations and its actors; new forms of
governance in the national and international arena; and the role of the media in
‘media democracy’. Katrin Voltmer is Senior Lecturer of Political Communi-
cation at the Institute of Communications Studies, University of Leeds, United
Kingdom. Her research interests include media influences on public opinion and
the policy process, the relationship between journalists and their news sources,
and the role of the media in democratic transitions. She is the editor of The Mass
Media and Political Communication in New Democracies (also published by
Routledge).
Routledge/ECPR studies in European political science
Edited by Thomas Poguntke
Ruhr University Bochum, Germany on behalf of the European Consortium for
Political Research
The Routledge/ECPR Studies in European Political Science series is published
in association with the European Consortium for Political Research – the leading
organization concerned with the growth and development of political science in
Europe. The series presents high-q uality edited volumes on topics at the leading
edge of current interest in political science and related fields, with contributions
from European scholars and others who have presented work at ECPR work-
shops or research groups.
1 Regionalist Parties in Western 6 Social Capital and European
Europe Democracy
Edited by Lieven de Winter and Edited by Jan van Deth,
Huri Türsan Marco Maraffi, Ken Newton and
Paul Whiteley
2 Comparing Party System
Change 7 Party Elites in Divided Societies
Edited by Jan-E rik Lane and Edited by Kurt Richard Luther
Paul Pennings and Kris Deschouwer
3 Political Theory and European 8 Citizenship and Welfare State
Union Reform in Europe
Edited by Albert Weale and Edited by Jet Bussemaker
Michael Nentwich
9 Democratic Governance and
4 Politics of Sexuality New Technology
Edited by Terrell Carver and Technologically mediated
Véronique Mottier innovations in political practice in
Western Europe
5 Autonomous Policy Making by Edited by Ivan Horrocks,
International Organizations Jens Hoff and Pieter Tops
Edited by Bob Reinalda and
Bertjan Verbeek
10 Democracy without Borders 18 Public Opinion and the
Transnationalisation and International Use of Force
conditionality in new democracies Edited by Philip Everts and
Edited by Jean Grugel Pierangelo Isernia
11 Cultural Theory as Political 19 Religion and Mass Electoral
Science Behaviour in Europe
Edited by Michael Thompson, Edited by David Broughton and
Gunnar Grendstad and Per Selle Hans- Martien ten Napel
12 The Transformation of 20 Estimating the Policy Position of
Governance in the European Political Actors
Union Edited by Michael Laver
Edited by Beate Kohler-K och and
Rainer Eising 21 Democracy and Political Change
in the ‘Third World’
13 Parliamentary Party Groups in Edited by Jeff Haynes
European Democracies
Political parties behind closed 22 Politicians, Bureaucrats and
doors Administrative Reform
Edited by Knut Heidar and Edited by B. Guy Peters and
Ruud Koole Jon Pierre
14 Survival of the European 23 Social Capital and Participation
Welfare State in Everyday Life
Edited by Stein Kuhnle Edited by Paul Dekker and
Eric M. Uslaner
15 Private Organisations in Global
Politics 24 Development and Democracy
Edited by Karsten Ronit and What do we know and how?
Volker Schneider Edited by Ole Elgström and
Goran Hyden
16 Federalism and Political
Performance 25 Do Political Campaigns Matter?
Edited by Campaign effects in elections and
Ute Wachendorfer- Schmidt referendums
Edited by David M. Farrell and
17 Democratic Innovation Rüdiger Schmitt-B eck
Deliberation, representation and
association 26 Political Journalism
Edited by Michael Saward New challenges, new practices
Edited by Raymond Kuhn and
Erik Neveu
27 Economic Voting 35 Political Theory and the
Edited by Han Dorussen and European Constitution
Michaell Taylor Edited by Lynn Dobson and
Andreas Follesdal
28 Organized Crime and the
Challenge to Democracy 36 Politics and the European
Edited by Felia Allum and Commission
Renate Siebert Actors, interdependence,
legitimacy
29 Understanding the European Edited by Andy Smith
Union’s External Relations
Edited by Michèle Knodt and 37 Metropolitan Governance
Sebastiaan Princen Capacity, democracy and the
dynamics of place
30 Social Democratic Party Policies Edited by Hubert Heinelt and
in Contemporary Europe Daniel Kübler
Edited by Giuliano Bonoli and
Martin Powell 38 Democracy and the Role of
Associations
31 Decision Making Within Political, organizational and social
International Organisations contexts
Edited by Bob Reinalda and Edited by Sigrid Roßteutscher
Bertjan Verbeek
39 The Territorial Politics of
32 Comparative Biomedical Policy Welfare
Governing assisted reproductive Edited by Nicola McEwen and
technologies Luis Moreno
Edited by Ivar Bleiklie,
Malcolm L. Goggin and 40 Health Governance in Europe
Christine Rothmayr Issues, challenges and theories
Edited by Monika Steffen
33 Electronic Democracy
Mobilisation, organisation and 41 Republicanism in Theory and
participation via new ICTs Practice
Edited by Rachel K. Gibson, Edited by Iseult Honohan and
Andrea Römmele and Jeremy Jennings
Stephen J. Ward
42 Mass Media and Political
34 Liberal Democracy and Communication in New
Environmentalism Democracies
The end of environmentalism? Edited by Katrin Voltmer
Edited by Marcel Wissenburg and
Yoram Levy
43 Delegation in Contemporary 51 Transnational Private
Democracies Governance and its Limits
Edited by Dietmar Braun and Edited by Jean-C hristophe Graz
Fabrizio Gilardi and Andreas Nölke
44 Governance and Democracy 52 International Organizations and
Comparing national, European and Implementation
international experiences Enforcers, managers, authorities?
Edited by Yannis Papadopoulos Edited by Jutta Joachim,
and Arthur Benz Bob Reinalda and Bertjan Verbeek
45 The European Union’s Roles in 53 New Parties in Government
International Politics Edited by Kris Deschouwer
Concepts and analysis
Edited by Ole Elgström and 54 In Pursuit of Sustainable
Michael Smith Development
New governance practices at the
46 Policy-m aking Processes and the sub- national level in Europe
European Constitution Edited by Susan Baker and
A comparative study of member Katarina Eckerberg
states and accession countries
Edited by Thomas König and 55 Governments, NGOs and
Simon Hug Anti- Corruption
The new integrity warriors
47 Democratic Politics and Party Edited by Luís de Sousa, Barry
Competition Hindess and Peter Larmour
Edited by Judith Bara and
Albert Weale 56 Intra- Party Politics and
Coalition Governments
48 Participatory Democracy and Edited by Daniela Giannetti and
Political Participation Kenneth Benoit
Can participatory engineering
bring citizens back in? 57 Political Parties and
Edited by Thomas Zittel and Partisanship
Dieter Fuchs Social identity and individual
attitudes
49 Civil Societies and Social Edited by John Bartle and
Movements Paolo Belucci
Potentials and problems
Edited by Derrick Purdue 58 The Future of Political
Community
50 Resources, Governance and Edited by Gideon Baker and
Civil Conflict Jens Bartelson
Edited by Magnus Öberg and
Kaare Strøm
59 The Discursive Politics of 64 Religion and Politics in Europe,
Gender Equality the Middle East and North
Stretching, bending and policy Africa
making Edited by Jeffrey Haynes
Edited by Emanuela Lombardo,
Petra Meier and Mieke Verloo 65 New Directions in Federalism
Studies
60 Another Europe Edited by Jan Erk and
Conceptions and practices of Wilfried Swenden
democracy in the European social
forums 66 Public Policy and Mass Media
Edited by Donatella Della Porta The interplay of mass
communication and political
61 European and North American decision making
Policy Change Edited by
Drivers and dynamics Sigrid Koch- Baumgarten and
Edited by Giliberto Capano and Katrin Voltmer
Michael Howlett
67 Changing Government
62 Referendums and Relations in Europe
Representative Democracy From localism to
Responsiveness, accountability intergovernmentalism
and deliberation Edited by Michael J. Goldsmith
Edited by Maija Setälä and and Edward C. Page
Theo Schiller
63 Education in Political Science
Discovering a neglected field
Edited by Anja P. Jakobi,
Kerstin Martens and
Klaus Dieter Wolf
Also available from Routledge in association with the ECPR:
Sex Equality Policy in Western Europe, Edited by Frances Gardiner; Demo-
cracy and Green Political Thought, Edited by Brian Doherty and Marius de
Geus; The New Politics of Unemployment, Edited by Hugh Compston; Cit-
izenship, Democracy and Justice in the New Europe Edited by Percy B.
Lehning and Albert Weale; Private Groups and Public Life, Edited by Jan W.
van Deth; The Political Context of Collective Action, Edited by Ricca
Edmondson; Theories of Secession, Edited by Percy Lehning; Regionalism
Across the North/South Divide, Edited by Jean Grugel and Wil Hout.
Public Policy and Mass
Media
The interplay of mass communication
and political decision making
Edited by Sigrid Koch- Baumgarten
and Katrin Voltmer
First published 2010
by Routledge
2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN
Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada
by Routledge
270 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016
Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2010.
To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s
collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.
© 2010 Sigrid Koch- Baumgarten and Katrin Voltmer for selection and
editorial matter; individual contributors, their contribution
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or
utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now
known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in
any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing
from the publishers.
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data
Public policy and the media: the interplay of mass communication and
political decision making/edited by Sigrid Koch-B aumgarten and Katrin
Voltmer.
p. cm. – (Routledge/ECPR studies in European political science)
Includes bibliographical referenc es and index.
1. Mass media–Political aspects. 2. Mass media–Social aspects. 3. Mass
media–Influence. 4. Communication in politics. I. Koch-B aumgarten,
Sigrid, 1955– II. Voltmer, Katrin.
P95.8.P85 2010
302.23–dc22 2009033333
ISBN 0-203-49199-8 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN10: 0-415-48546-0 (hbk)
ISBN10: 0-203-85849-2 (ebk)
ISBN13: 978-0-415-48546-3 (hbk)
ISBN13: 978-0-203-85849-3 (ebk)
Contents
List of illustrations xi
Notes on contributors xiii
Series editor’s preface xvi
Preface xviii
1 Introduction: mass media and public policy – is there a link? 1
KATRIN VOLTMER AND SIGRID KOCH- BAUMGARTEN
PART I
Policy issues, agendas and the media 15
2 Public policy and the mass media: an information processing
approach 17
BRYAN D. JONES AND MICHELLE WOLFE
3 Do the media shape parties’ agenda preferences?
An empirical study of party manifestos in Belgium
(1987–2003) 44
STEFAAN WALGRAVE AND JONAS LEFEVERE
4 Closing the circle: a case study in the role of spin in the
policy cycle 65
NEIL T. GAVIN
5 Knowledge culture and power: biotechnology and the
popular press 86
PIETER MAESEELE AND DIMITRI SCHUURMAN
