Audit 7-20-16 Agenda

250 Pages·2016·9.97 MB·English

A U D I T C O M M I T T E E M E E T I N G
OF THE
BOARD OF RETIREMENT & BOARD OF INVESTMENTS

JULY 20, 2016
9:00 A.M.
TAB
A

U
Table of Contents
......................... 1
D
I
Agenda ............................................................ 2
T

Minutes ........................................................... 3 C
O
Executive Summary ........................................ 4
M
External Financial Auditor Selection .............. 5
M
Audit Committee Charter ............................... 6
I
T
LACERA MAPP Amendment ........................... 7
T
E
Internal Audit Charter .................................... 8
E
FYE 2017 Audit Plan ........................................ 9
M

FYE 2016 Internal Audit Annual Report ....... 10
E
E
Recommendation Follow-Up Report ........... 11
T
IRS Section 415b Adjustments Audit ............ 12 I
N
Member Data File Exception Processing ...... 13 G

Duplicate Vendor Payments Audit ............... 14 |

J
Office Renovations Audit.............................. 15
u
l
y
Minor Survivor Eligibility Audit .................... 16
2
0
For Information Only .................................... 17 ,

2
0

1
6
AGENDA
MEETING OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
AND/OR BOARD OF RETIREMENT AND/OR BOARD OF INVESTMENTS*

LOS ANGELES COUNTY EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT ASSOCIATION
300 N. Lake Avenue, Suite 810
Pasadena, CA 91101

July 20, 2016 – 9:00 a.m.

The Committee may take action on any item on the Agenda,
and Agenda Items may be taken out of order.

2016 COMMITTEE MEMBERS
Joseph Kelly – Chair
Michael S. Schneider – Vice Chair
Vivian Gray – Secretary
David Green
Shawn R. Kehoe

AUDIT COMMITTEE CONSULTANT
Rick Wentzel

I. APPROVAL - MINUTES OF THE REGULAR AUDIT COMMITTEE MEETING OF APRIL 15, 2016
(Attached)
II. PUBLIC COMMENT

III. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive
(Updated: June 30, 2016)

IV. ACTION ITEMS
A. Recommendation, as submitted by Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive, and David
Redman, Senior Internal Auditor, that the Audit Committee:
1. Submit a recommendation memo to the LACERA Board of Retirement for the
Board’s consideration to select one firm named to become LACERA’s external
financial statement auditor for the five year period beginning January 1, 2017 and
ending December 31, 2021, with a two year extension at the option of LACERA,
or
AGENDA – REGULAR MEETING OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
July 20, 2016
Page 2 of 4

2. Submit a memo to the LACERA Board of Retirement that refers two or more
candidate firms for presentations to the Board for final consideration in selecting
LACERA’s external financial statement auditor for the five year period beginning
January 1, 2017 and ending December 31, 2021, with a two year extension at the
option of LACERA
(Memo Dated: June 30, 2016)

B. Recommendation as submitted by Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive, Leisha Collins,
Principal Internal Auditor, and Christina Logan, Senior Internal Auditor that the Audit
Committee:
1. Provide direction to staff on the proposed updates to the Audit Committee
Charter,
2. Upon approval, recommend to the Board of Retirement and Board of
Investments to adopt the revised Audit Committee Charter.
(Memo Dated: June 30, 2016)

C. Recommendation that the Audit Committee, if the Charter Changes are Approved, for
Amendments to County Code, Section 6.127.040, on LACERA MAP Program as
submitted by Steven Rice, Chief Legal Counsel, and Johanna Fontenot, Senior Staff
Counsel.
(Memo Dated: July 1, 2016)

D. Recommendation that the Audit Committee review and approve the updated Internal
Audit Charter as submitted by Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive, and Leisha Collins,
Principal Internal Auditor, and Christina Logan, Senior Internal Auditor.
(Memo Dated: June 30, 2016)

E. Recommendation that the Audit Committee review and approve the Audit Plan for
Fiscal Year End 2017 as submitted by Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive, and Leisha
Collins, Principal Internal Auditor, Quoc Nguyen, Principal Internal Auditor
(Memo Dated: June 30, 2016)

V. ADMINISTRATIVE REPORTS
A. Internal Audit Annual Report – Fiscal Year End 2016
Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive
(Report Dated: June 30, 2016)

B. Recommendation Follow-Up Report
Quoc Nguyen, Principal Internal Auditor
(Memo Dated: June 30, 2016)

C. Status of Other External Audits Not Conducted at the Discretion of Internal Audit
Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive
(Verbal Presentation)
AGENDA – REGULAR MEETING OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
July 20, 2016
Page 3 of 4
VI. AUDIT REPORTS
A. IRS Section 415b Adjustments Audit
David Redman, Senior Internal Auditor
(Report Issued: January 8, 2016)
B. Member Data File Exception Processing
George Lunde, Senior Internal Auditor
(Report Issued: March 24, 2016)
C. Duplicate Vendor Payments Audit
Gabriel Tafoya, Senior Internal Auditor
(Report Issued: March 29, 2016)
D. Office Renovations Audit
Christina Logan, Senior Internal Auditor
(Report Issued: April 12, 2016)
E. Minor Survivor Eligibility Audit
Nathan Amick, Internal Auditor
(Report Issued: June 29, 2016)
VII. FOR INFORMATION ONLY
A. Legal Office Opinion on Audit Committee’s Authority Under the Brown Act to Meet
in Closed Session with Respect to CAE Personnel Issues
Steven Rice, Chief Legal Counsel
(Memo Dated: July 1, 2016)
B. Attorney-Client Privilege/Confidential Memo
Human Resources Compliance Audit Recommendations
–Liebert Cassidy Whitmore (LCW)
Steven Rice, Chief Legal Counsel
Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive
VIII. CONSULTANT COMMENTS
Rick Wentzel, Audit Committee Consultant
(Verbal Presentation)
IX. GOOD OF THE ORDER
(For Information Purposes Only)
X. ADJOURNMENT
AGENDA – REGULAR MEETING OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
July 20, 2016
Page 4 of 4

*The Board of Retirement and Board of Investments have adopted a policy permitting any member of the Boards to
attend a standing committee meeting open to the public. In the event five (5) or more members of either the Board
of Retirement and/or the Board of Investments (including members appointed to the Committee) are in attendance,
the meeting shall constitute a joint meeting of the Committee and the Board of Retirement and/or Board of
Investments. Members of the Board of Retirement and Board of Investments who are not members of the
Committee may attend and participate in a meeting of a Board Committee but may not vote on any matter
discussed at the meeting. Except as set forth in the Committee’s Charter, the only action the Committee may take at
the meeting is approval of a recommendation to take further action at a subsequent meeting of the Board.

Documents subject to public disclosure that relate to an agenda item for an open session of the Board and/or
Committee that are distributed less than 72 hours prior to the meeting will be available for public inspection at the
time they are distributed to a majority of the members of any such Board and/or Committee at LACERA’s offices at
300 N. Lake Avenue, Suite 820, Pasadena, CA 91101 during normal business hours [e.g., 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
Monday through Friday].

Persons requiring an alternative format of this agenda pursuant to Section 202 of the Americans with Disabilities Act
of 1990 may request one by calling Cynthia Guider at (626)-564-6000 extension 3327, from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
Monday through Friday, but no later than 48 hours prior to the time the meeting is to commence. Assistive Listening
Devices are available upon request. American Sign Language (ASL) Interpreters are available with at least three (3)
business days notice before the meeting date.
MINUTES OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
REGULAR MEETING OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
AND BOARD OF RETIREMENT AND/OR BOARD OF INVESTMENTS*

LOS ANGELES COUNTY EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT ASSOCIATION
300 N. Lake Avenue, Suite 810
Pasadena, CA 91101

April 15, 2016 – 9:05 a.m.

2016 COMMITTEE MEMBERS
PRESENT: Joseph Kelly – Chair
Vivian Gray – Secretary
David Green
Shawn R. Kehoe

ABSENT: Michael S. Schneider –Vice Chair

BOARD MEMBERS AT LARGE
None
AUDIT COMMITTEE CONSULTANT
Rick Wentzel
STAFF, ADVISORS, AND PARTICIPANTS
Robert Hill Beulah Auten
John Popowich Bernie Buenaflor
Richard Bendall Derwin Brown
Sylvia Botros Ted Granger
Leisha Collins Cynthia Guider
Elvia Gonzalez John Nogales
Christina Logan James Pu
George Lunde Steven Rice
Quoc Nguyen
David Redman
Gabriel Tafoya
Darla Vidger
MINUTES OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
APRIL 15, 2016
PAGE 2 OF 6

I. ELECTION OF AUDIT COMMITTEE CHAIR, VICE CHAIR, AND SECRETARY
Mr. Green called for the nomination of the Chair, Vice-Chair, and Secretary of the Audit
Committee for the 2016 Calendar Year. Mr. Kehoe nominated Mr. Kelly for Chair and Mr.
Green seconded the nomination. Mr. Kelly was unanimously elected Chair of the 2016
Audit Committee.
Mr. Green called for the nomination of the new Vice-Chair. Mr. Kelly nominated Mr.
Schneider for Vice Chair and Mr. Green seconded the nomination. Mr. Schneider was
unanimously elected Vice Chair of the 2016 Audit Committee.
Mr. Green called for the nomination of Secretary. Mr. Kelly nominated Ms. Gray for
Secretary and Mr. Green seconded the nomination. Ms. Gray was unanimously elected
Secretary of the 2016 Audit Committee.
II. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE REGULAR AUDIT COMMITTEE MEETING OF
DECEMBER 3, 2015

Mr. Kelly called for a motion to approve the Minutes of the Audit Committee Meeting of
December 3, 2015. Mr. Kehoe presented a motion for approval and Mr. Green seconded
the motion. The Minutes were approved unanimously.
III. PUBLIC COMMENT
No items to report.
IV. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive

Mr. Bendall introduced Rick Wentzel, the new Audit Committee Consultant. Mr. Wentzel
provided a brief introduction.

Mr. Bendall provided an overview of the April 15, 2016 Audit Committee meeting and
updates to the Audit Committee meeting book.

V. AUDIT COMMITTEE GUIDE AND ORIENTATION
Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive
Darla Vidger, Internal Auditor

Mr. Bendall and Ms. Vidger reviewed the Audit Committee Guide and Orientation.

Mr. Bendall also reviewed the results from Internal Audit’s Quality Assurance Review from
January 2016.
MINUTES OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
APRIL 15, 2016
PAGE 3 OF 6

VI. ACTION ITEMS
A. Recommendation that the Audit Committee review the Audit Committee Meeting
Schedule and provide direction to staff on changes as submitted by Richard Bendall,
Chief Audit Executive.
(Memo Dated: March 29, 2016)

The Audit Committee did not feel it was necessary to change the meeting dates for
this calendar year. Instead, the Committee confirmed the subsequent meeting dates
of July 20, 2016 and December 1, 2016.

B. Recommendation as submitted by Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive, Leisha
Collins, Principal Internal Auditor, and Christina Logan, Senior Internal Auditor that
the Audit Committee:
1. Provide direction to staff on the proposed updates to the Audit Committee
Charter,
2. Upon approval, recommend to the Board of Retirement and Board of
Investments to adopt the revised Audit Committee Charter.
(Memo Dated: March 29, 2016)

Ms. Collins provided an overview of the Audit Committee Charter updates.

The Committee provided feedback that they would like further clarification on
the Committee’s CAE oversight authority from Mr. Rice as well as greater
clarification on the Committee’s compliance monitoring responsibilities.

Mr. Kehoe moved that staff incorporate the guidance provided by the
Committee and Committee Consultant into the Audit Committee Charter to
bring back to the Committee at the next meeting. A second to the motion was
provided my Mr. Green. The motion was approved unanimously.

C. Recommendation that the Audit Committee review and approve the updated
Internal Audit Charter as submitted by Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive, and
Leisha Collins, Principal Internal Auditor, and Christina Logan, Senior Internal Auditor.
(Memo Dated: March 29, 2016)

As the Audit Committee Charter and the Internal Charter are so closely related, staff
noted that they will apply the guidance provided by the Committee on the Audit
Committee Charter to the Internal Audit Charter as well. Staff stated that they would
bring the updated Charters to the next Audit Committee.
MINUTES OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
APRIL 15, 2016
PAGE 4 OF 6

D. Recommendation, as submitted by Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive, and David
Redman, Senior Internal Auditor, that the Audit Committee:
1. Authorize staff to issue a Request For Proposal (RFP) for an external certified
public accounting firm (Auditor) to perform the annual audit of LACERA’s
financial statements with a proposed contract term of 5 years, fiscal years
ending 2017-2021, with an optional two-year extension; and
2. Approve the attached RFP Draft with its "Firm (Auditor or Bidder) Minimum
Qualifications"; and
3. Provide direction to staff regarding the evaluation process of proposals
received and the selection and interview of “finalists.”
(Memo Dated: March 24, 2016)

Mr. Redman provided an overview of the External Auditor Request for
Proposals (RFP) requirements, timeline and planned evaluation process.

Mr. Kelly inquired how the RFP requirements were changed to allow for more
respondents. Staff provided clarification on the proposed changes to the RFP.

Mr. Kelly moved to approve the recommendation as stated. Mr. Green provided
a second to the motion. The motion was approved unanimously.

VII. REPORTS
A. Risk Assessment Process
Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive
(Updated: March 29, 2016)

Mr. Bendall provided an overview of the Internal Audit Risk Assessment Process and
its purpose including proposed changes to the process.

B. Internal Audit Goal Report
Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive
(Updated: March 23, 2016)

Mr. Bendall provided an overview of the Internal Audit Goal Report and the planned
goals for the 2016 Calendar Year.

C. Audit Plan Status Report
Richard Bendall, Chief Audit Executive
(Memo Dated: March 31, 2016)
Mr. Bendall described the Audit Plan cycle and gave a high-level recap of work
performed since the last Audit Committee meeting.